World Water Day – 2017 15 Paper No. 130 WATER RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT IN POTHOHAR Dr. Muhammad Nawaz Bhutta and Dr. Saleem Sarwar 16 World Water Day – 2017 World Water Day – 2017 17 WATER RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT AND MANAGEMENT IN POTHOHAR By Dr. Muhammad Nawaz Bhutta and Dr. Saleem Sarwar ABSTRACT Optimum utilization of every drop of available water is becoming increasingly important with the ever -increasing population to meet their food needs. In the Pothohar Region rainwater is wasted by flowing over steep slopes, rather causing soil erosion and damaging the water ways and dams. It has been estimated that annually 2.4 MAF water is lost as surface runoff from Pothohar Region. Rainwater harvesting structures (RHS) would contribute in enhancing the crop production and reducing the hazardous eros ion. The Pothohar Region has a total command area of 5.5 million acres (2.2 Mha). Out of which about 86000 acres are being irrigated by existing rainwater harvesting structures. Since 1978, a number of interventions have been constructed and only 0.1 MAF r ainfall runoff is being utilized out of potential of 2.5 MAF. Proper harvesting of this balance of 2.4 MAF is inevitably required for regional economic growth. A total of 8,707 sites for RHS have been identified for construction in four districts of Pothoh ar. The storage size of structures varies from 10 AF to 100 AF. A sample of 40 RHS sites were surveyed. The local geology of individual RHS sites suggests that 78 percent will be of earthen embankments and 22 percent will be stone masonry wall or concrete faced rock -fill structures. The catchment area for these sites will vary from 0.25 to 3 mile 2 and average annual water yield for 1 mile 2 is about 161 acre feet. The reservoir area varies from 1 acre to 16 acres. Sediment yield has been estimated as 1.5 AF per mile2. For spillway design 25 years return period is proposed for all RHS. The structure heights vary from 20 to 35 ft and there exist reasonable agreement between reservoir area and storage capacity, and structure height. Crop water requirements of va rious crops assuming 140% annual future cropping intensity was calculated. There is sufficient water available to meet the crop water requirements. The overall estimated cost of 40 RHS is Rs.181.511 million including Rs. 115.963 million for component of RH S and Rs. 65.548 million for spillway. The incremental NVP values range from Rs. 413,000 to Rs. 5,042,000 depending upon the scale of CCA of each rainwater harvesting structure. Economic cash flow has been prepared at 12% discount rate. The life assumed as 25 years. All the RHSs sizes for their multipurpose usage are economically feasible even for sensitivity analysis. The EIRR for overall project is 19.15% and FIRR for overall project is 17.43%. INTRODUCTION The Pothohar Region lies between Indus and Jhel um rivers having a total command area of 5.5 million acres (2.2 Mha). Out of which about 86,740 acres is being irrigated by existing rain water harvesting structures. The topography of Pothohar area is undulating and the altitude varies from 300 to 600 m a bove mean Sea Level. In the Pothohar Region rain water is wasted by flowing over steep slopes, rather causing soil erosion and damaging the water ways and dams. 18 World Water Day – 2017 Since 1978 in the Pothohar region the construction of rainwater harvesting structures has been completed under various multi -sectoral development projects. It included construction of RHS (mini dams and ponds) dugwells and tubewells etc. Key achievements upto date are given in Table 1. Table 1: Key Achievements in Pothohar RHS (mini dams & ponds) Dug Wells Tube well Turbines Total Number 2154 4,112 399 187 – Area irrigated (ac) 54460 20,560 7,980 3,740 86,740 A total of 8707 new potential sites for RHS have been identified for construction in four districts of Pothohar (Table 2). Out of these Attock district contains maximum number of potential sites (2,596) while Rawalpindi district contains minimum number of potential sites (1,431). Table 2: Tehsil wise Summary of Potential RHS Sites District No. of Rural UC Total Rawalpindi 119 1,431 Chakwal 59 2,313 Attock 61 2,596 Total 42 2,367 Grand Total 281 8,707 SAMPLE SURVEY A sample survey of 40 potential sites in Pothohar area using ASTER DEM data (30 – meter resolution satellite imageries) was conducted. Figure 1 shows the map containing these potential sites of RHS. RHS upto 10 AF are not considered feasible. RHS from 1 0 to 30 AF are small, 30 to 60 AF are medium and from 60 to 100 AF are large. Design criteria for RHS are likely to involve following: I. Mark the potential RHS sites in the Pothohar Region. The criteria of selection will be based upon imagery / topograph ic survey of the Pothohar area. II. Determine height and storage capacity of the RHS on the basis of satellite imagery/ topographical survey. III. Identify the command area in the adjoining vicinity of the rainwater harvesting structures. World Water Day – 2017 19 IV. Recheck design of the RHS on the basis of general geology of the area assuming that rock will be available approximately 5 meter from the surface. Moreover availability of impervious material within 5 Km lead be looked into. V. Design of spillway will be done on th e basis of 25 year return period inflow. HYDROLOGICAL & HYDRAULIC STUDIES In order to study the effect of the climatological factors in Pothohar area, rainfall data of Gujjar Khan, Islamabad, Jhelum, Chakwal and Cherat station operated by Water and Power D evelopment Authority was used. The span of available data is from 1954 to 2009 (1954 -1970 monthly data, 1971 -2009 daily data). The normal annual rainfall in Pothohar region varies from 400 mm to 1200 mm (15.7 to 47.2 inch) depending upon location, the maxi mum being the northeastern area and the minimum in the southeastern. About 45 % of the rainfall occurs in the months of July, August and September. The maximum mean monthly rainfall (350 mm) occurs in Murree in the month of July while minimum rainfall (1.8 1mm) occurs in the Chakwal in the month of November. There is an appreciable variation in the summer and winter temperatures. January is the coldest month, while June is the hottest month. The absolute mean monthly temperature in the valley ranges from 1°C in January to 46°C in June. The temperature analyses for the Jhelum gauging station were carried out to determine the inter -seasonal and annual changes in this region. The daily maximum and minimum data of Jhelum from 1980 to 2013 was collected to assess variations in the temperature of the region. The results indicated that mean temperature over the period of 34 years is 30.68 ºC, whereas, average maximum temperature was recorded in 2003 with a value of 33.07 ºC. The average minimum temperature recorded ov er the same period was 16.77 ºC with minimum temperature of 11.74ºC recorded in 2003. The results indicated that minimum temperature is 5.58ºC that occurs during the month of January and maximum temperature occurs during the month of June with value of 39.73ºC. 20 World Water Day – 2017 Figure 1: Potential Rainwater Harvesting Sites in Pothohar World Water Day – 2017 21 Water Availability and Sediment Yield Small Dams Organization (SDO) of Punjab Irrigation Department (PID) has carried out studies1 on some of its existing dams an d established monthly rainfall -runoff relationships as per observed rainfall-runoff recorded. Following regression equations for the three zones (see Figure 2) were developed: Zone A: Bishan Daur River at Missa Runoff = 0.983*10-7*(Rainfall+112.6)3.5 Zone B: Sill River at Chahan Runoff = 0.9222*10-2*(Rainfall+21.3)1.6 Zone C: Ling River at Kahuta Runoff = 0.428*10-2*(Rainfall+32.5)1.5 Runoff Monthly in mm Rainfall (monthly) in mm Water availability for 40 sample RHS is given in Table 3. Table 3: Annual Water Yield of Selected Rainwater Harvesting Structures Sr. No. Total Sites Total Catchment Area (miles2) Total Annual Water Yield (AF) Chakwal 19 42.72 8296 Rawalpindi 4 4.99 1300 Attock 8 5.62 1172.8 Jhelum 9 4.74 834 Total 40 58.07 11602.8 Surface Water Hydrology Project (SWHP), WAPDA has some gauging stations in the vicinity of the catchment area that have long term sediment record. Sill River near Chahan that lies about 3.2 km upstream of Chahan village, about 27 km south west of Rawalpindi on Pindi Chakri Road ( Table 4). The predicted sediment rate value of 0.59 AF/km2 is estimated for the RHS. Catchment of these RHS are very small compared to 1 Design Manual Volume 1 Hydrology and Hydraulics for small dams projects 22 World Water Day – 2017 Chahan, moreover, vegetation cover is also found on most part of these RHS compared to catchment area of Chahan, therefore, sediment rate will be far less. Table 4: Sediment Yield for Various Catchments in the Pothohar Region Sr No River Station Catchment Area (km2) Data Record (years) Mean Annual Runoff (AF /km2) Mean Annual Sediment Yield (AF /km2) 1 Siran River Phulra 1,057 36 470.3 1.5 2 Haro River Garlia 3,056 37 225.4 1.0 3 Haro River Khanpur 777 32 283.1 1.2 4 Soan River Dhok Pathan 6,475 42 171.4 2.0 Design Flood Design flood for each RHS is determined using Unit Hydrograph Method. Frequency analysis of the one -day annual maximum rainfall data of Gujar Khan station has been carried out to assess the rainfall of various return periods using Gumble Extreme Value Type I distribution as per normal practice in Paki stan. The results of frequency analysis as an example is given in Table 5 and in Figure 6. Table 5: Frequency Analysis of one Day Annual Maximum Rainfall Figure 2: Plot of Gumble K Factor and Estimated Rainfall Return Period K Computed Rainfall Depth (inch) 500 4.395 9.36 100 3.137 7.64 50 2.592 6.90 25 2.044 6.15 20 1.866 5.91 15 1.635 5.59 10 1.305 5.14 5 0.719 4.34 2.33 0.001 3.36 1.02 -1.518 1.29 World Water Day – 2017 23 US Soil Conservation Services (USSCS) approach has been adopted to estimate design flood for the RHS. For the spillway design 25 year return period is proposed for all RHSs. Assessment Of RHS Height And Spillway Width Area capacity curves for RHS were generated from 0.5 m contour interval topographi cal survey. Flood routing was carried out to determine the Normal Pool Level (NPL), Highest Flood Level (HFL) and Dam height for these RHS. The Muskingum -Cunge flood routing procedure has been adopted. HFL was computed by selecting appropriate spillway rating curve for each RHS. Freeboard of 3 ft. was added to compute structure height. The results show that storage of these sites varies from 11 AF to 100 AF and reservoir area varies from 2 ac to 16 ac. Wave Run-up analysis was also carried out to determine the potential wave height for these RHSs. The topographical survey indicates that for these RHSs, average fetch length varies from 0.12 mile to 0.25 mile. USBR (2012) Design Standards No. 13 was used for calculation of wave run -up. The results show that ma ximum wave of 1.71 ft will be created for average fetch length. Crop Water Requirement The crop water requirements of various crops to be grown in command area were calculated by using Crop Coefficient (K c) Approach. According to this approach, crop evapotranspiration (ET c) is calculated by multiplying the reference crop evapotranspiration (ETo) with Kc. The Gross irrigation requirements at RHS outlet is computed by dividing net irrigation requirement over irrigation efficiency. Table 5 indicates monthly ir rigation requirements at RHS outlet in Chakwal District which needs to be assured through RHS operation. Table 6: Crop Water Requirements for 100 ac with 140% cropping for RHS in District Chakwal Reaches Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec CWR (AF) 100 ac Per ac Rootzone 11.8 5.3 7.7 7.9 11.6 21.4 17.1 9.4 18. 2 13. 6 9.4 5.8 139.2 1.4 Nakka 16.4 7.4 9.9 9.2 12.9 24.4 20.8 11.5 23. 4 17. 3 12. 9 7.9 174.1 1.7 RHS Outlet 17.3 7.8 10.4 9.7 13.6 25.7 21.9 12.1 24. 7 18. 2 13. 6 8.4 183.3 1.8 There is sufficient water available to meet the crop water requirements in the various months of the year. The demands have been adjusted with spills and shortages such that maximum flow would be regulated and command area of 10 to 43 acre can be irrigated from these RHSs. Hydraulic Design of Spillway Design of spillways for 40 sample RHS is based on USBR guidelines for cut spillways and pressure flow principles for pipe spillways. The pipe spillways are provided in the RHS with spillway outflow capacity of less than 300 cusecs. 24 World Water Day – 2017 District Chakwal RHS: There are 19 feasible RHSs sites in the district Chakwal. The storage capacity of these sites varies from 11 to 100 AF. Most of these site will be earthen having RHS with open cut spillway are 14 and RHS with pipe spillway are 5. District Rawalpindi RHS: There are 4 feasible RHSs sites in the district Rawalpindi, the storage capacity of these sites varies from 14 to 68 AF. These sites will be earthen having open cut spillway. District Attock RHS: There are 8 feasible RHSs sites in the district Attack, the storage capacity of these sites varies from 18 to 58 AF. Most of these sites will be earthen having open cut spillway however pipe spillway is provided in 2 RHSs. District Jhelum RHS: There are 9 feasible RHSs sites in the district Jhelum, the storage capacity of these sites varies from 11 to 61 AF. Most of these site will be earthen having open cut spillway however pipe spillway is provided in 6 RHSs. GEOLOGY AND GEOTECHNICAL STUDIES The regional geology of this area is mainly represented by sandstones, siltstones, clay/ shale intercalated by conglomerate beds belonging to Murree & Kamlial Formations of Rawalpindi Group and Chinji, Nagri, Dhok Pathan and Soan Formations of Siwaliks Group. There are older formations of Paleocene and Eocene age southernmost part of the catchment which are mainly represented by limestone, marl and some fine laminated shale / argillaceous rocks in this part of Pothohar area. The rock mass outcropped of Pothohar Region, is mainly massive sandstone of Nagri Formation, while in the reservoir and in catchments of these RHS, Dhok Pathan Formation is predominant with a horizontal bed of Soan Formation at the top. The Nagri Formation consists of sandstone with subordinate clay and conglomerate. The sandstone is greenish grey, medium to coarse grained, cross -bedded and massive. In places, the sandstone is bluish grey dull red with “salt and pepper” pattern, calcareous, and moderate to poor cemented. The clay is sandy or silty chocolate brown or reddish – grey and pale orange, the proportion of which varies from section to section. The Dhok Pathan Formation is typically represented by monotonous cyclic alternations of sandstone, and clay beds. The sandstone is commonly g rey, light grey, gleaming white or reddish brown occasionally buff or light brown in color, thick bedded, calcareous moderately cemented soft and cross–bedded. The clay / shale is orange, brown, dull red or reddish brown and occasionally rusty orange calca reous and sandy. Conglomerate in the form of lenses or layers is an essential character in the upper part. AGRICULTURE DEVELOPMENT AND BENEFITS Total reported area of Pothohar region is 5.55 Mac, out of which 2.56 Mac (46%) area is cultivated and 2.99 Mac; (54%) area is uncultivated. Under uncultivated category, 36% of total reported area is not available for cultivation, 11% is under forest and only 7% is culturable waste which can be brought under cultivation provided irrigation supplies are available. The percentage of cultivated area to total reported area is quite low (46%) as compared to 72% on Punjab basis. Sown area is 1.98 million acres, out of which 1.76 million acres are barani and 0.22 million acres are irrigated. The irrigated area is only 11% of the total sown area. World Water Day – 2017 25 The proposed RHSs, will mostly supplement irrigation supplies to rainfed areas of Pothohar. According to land use statistics of Pothohar, about 13 percent of CCA under these proposed RHSs is culturable waste, barren and no agricultur e is being practiced but it can be brought under cultivation provided irrigation facilities are available. The total CCA for these sample sites comes to about 994 acres. Agriculture Under Without Project The present agriculture in the command of 40 propose d rainwater harvesting structures is rainfed with poor per acre yields, no substantial improvement is anticipated. It is assumed that cropped area and yields will remain constant and hence no projection has been made for future without project. To determin e the bench mark agriculture development status in proposed RHSs, it is assumed that CCA under RHSs will comprise of about 87% of rainfed area and about 13% of culturable waste with no agriculture. The annual cropping intensity of matured crops under command of proposed RHS is assumed as 15%. Agriculture Development Under With Project Construction of rainwater harvesting structures in the Pothohar Region seems to be the viable option for storing runoff water and bringing barren lands under cultivation. Considering water and land resources as constraining factors, 25% of command area will be served with high efficiency irrigation system (HEIS). About 61% will receive surface / flood irrigation and 14% will be irrigated with bed and furrow method. The crop production is envisaged to be achieved through bringing barren / rainfed land under cultivation and practising of cropping pattern with high return crops including orchards and high value crops on 25% of the command area which is proposed to be served with HEIS. Irrigation water will be provided to field crops through improved water channel with minimum water losses. Cropping intensity of 140% has been proposed keeping in view the water availability, soil suitability and climate conditions. The projections of future proposed cropping pattern and intensities and cropped area for rainwater harvesting structures were estimated. The ultimate annual cropping intensity of 140% will be achieved within a period of four years and will observe linear trend from base year to 4th year. In consistence with government policy, orchards and high value crops comprising of olive(2%), grapes(6%), citrus(6%), peaches(2%), guava(3%), fig(1%), vegetables tunnels(2%) and flowers consisting of rose petal(1%), rose cut flower(1%), gladiolus(0.5%) and tube rose cut flower(0.5%) have been included in the cropping pattern. The crops will attain the ultimate yields during 5 thyear and afterwards taking this level constant, no projection has been made upto project life. The growth rate will be higher in the first 2 years due to application of water and other non -water inputs and afterwards with some slower rate. The ultimate crop yields are almost at par with adjacent irrigated areas. Incremental Production & Benefits Though 140% cropping int ensity is still less than intensity achieved in many irrigated areas in Pothohar, the major shift in cropping pattern with inclusion of orchards / high 26 World Water Day – 2017 value crops / flowers will have major impact on farm incomes. Similarly improvement in crop yields is proposed from one and half to about two folds in traditional crops. Gross value of products (GVP) has been worked out by multiplying the crop production with per unit farm gate price of crop production. Per acre cost of crop production has been worked out by developing farm budgets and for future without and with project conditions for proposed RHS. Per acre cost of production of various crops has been multiplied with respective cropped area under with project conditions to compute gross cost of production (G CP). By subtracting the gross cost of production from GVP, net value of production (NVP) has been obtained for proposed RHS. Based on CCA, calculations of GVP, GCP, NVP and net agriculture benefits for surveyed 40 RHS are given in Table 7. Table 7: GVP, GCP and NVP for 40 RHSs (000 Rs.) Storage Category Command Area (Acres) GVP GCP NVP Incremental NVP Without Project With Project Without Project With Project Without Project With Project Small RHSTotal 251 853.40 26,656.20 652.60 10,893.40 200.80 15,762.80 15,562.00 Medium RHS Total 298 1,013.43 31,654.68 774.97 12,936.09 238.45 18,718.59 18,480.13 Sub-Total (3):- 445 1,513.00 47,259.00 1,157.00 19,313.00 356.00 27,946.00 27,590.00 Total:- 994 3,379.60 105,562.80 2,584.40 43,139.60 795.20 62,423.20 61,628.00 FINANCIAL AND ECONIMC EVALUATION The financial cost includes all taxes and duties. The total cost includes management cost, environmental and social development, agriculture marketing support cost etc. Financial and Economic Cost Basic Cost of each RHS consists of two components: RHS and spillway. The overall estimated cost of 40 RHS’s is rupees 181.511 Million ( Table 8). Cost of HEIS, Social & Environmental Management, Agriculture Supports and Project Management Support has been added. The Standard Conversion Factor (SCF) is used to convert financial cost of material into economic cost. For this study, the SCF of 0.90 has been adopted. SCF Cost per acre of CCA is also given to determine the threshold cost of a RHS being feasible. Table 8: Financial Cost of Proposed RHS Size Command Area (ac) RHS Cost (Rs.) *Total Cost (M.Rs) Cost Per Acre (Rs.) Embankment Spillway Total Small (20) 251 41,407,234 19,722,975 61,130,209 93.97 374,385 Medium (12) 298 36,188,720 22,378,980 58,567,701 90.03 302,051 Large (9) 445 38,367,163 23,446,243 61,813,407 95 213,483 Total (40) 994 115,963,117 65,548,199 181,511,316 279.02 280,704 World Water Day – 2017 27 * Includes RHS cost, HEIS, Social & Environmental Management, Agriculture Suppo rts, Project Management Support etc. Economic Analysis The economic cost of the project is taken from financial cost for economic cash flow statement and operation and maintenance cost is calculated as 0.5% of total cost. The agriculture benefits have been taken from Section–5 (Table 7). Economic cash flow has been prepared at 12% discount rate. The life assumed as 25 years. Incremental benefits have been calculated by taking the difference of total benefits and total cost. Economic parameters have been wor ked out on incremental benefits to indicate the feasibility of investment. For the economic analysis of RHS, following are the basic assumptions: 1. The RHS will be developed for both agriculture and fisheries. The small size RHS will be developed for ag riculture plus fish farming. Whereas, medium size will be developed as 30% for agriculture + fish farming and rest 70% for agriculture only. 2. The large size RHS will be developed by allocating 50% of the RHS for each fisheries and agricultural crops and 50% for agriculture only. 3. Agricultural benefits will include development of conventional irrigation on 61 % of CCA, HEIS on 25 % of CCA and bed and furrow system on 14 % of CCA. 4. The useful life of civil structure is considered as 25 years for economic analysis. Economic Analysis The Economic Internal Rate of Return (EIRR), Benefits Cost Ratio (BCR) and Net Present Value (NPV) are calculated from the cash flow statement. Based on the feasibility study of 40 surveyed sites as given in Table 9 , it c an be deduced that per acre cost of RHSs varies with location and size. This cost includes structures, spillway, HEIS, environmental and social management cost, agriculture marketing support and project management support etc. The economic analysis has been carried out for multipurpose usage of RHS (agriculture + fish farming) to establish economic viability of each RHS category (small, medium, large) and then of overall project. The economic analysis given in Table 9 reveals that all the three sizes of RH Ss are economically feasible for multipurpose use (agriculture + fish farming) with EIRR as about 20.57% for small size, 17.70% for medium, 19.1% for large size and overall 19.15%. Table 9: Summary of Economic Analysis Results Sr. No. Description RHS Small Medium Large Overall A Economic Indicators IRR % 20.57% 17.70% 19.1% 19.15% NPV (Million Rs.) 43.54 27.40 64.41 135.39 28 World Water Day – 2017 Sr. No. Description RHS Small Medium Large Overall BC Ratio 1.9 1.63 1.81 1.79 B Basic Project Costs (Million Rs.) 59.1 52.36 95.0 206.49 C Total Command Area (ac) 251 298 445 994 D Total Cost Per Acre (Rs.) 281,571 239,087 213,483 236,259 E Benefits Rs/ac 95,804 78,866 78,617 82,809 Financial Analysis The financial value of project benefits has been estimated by using market prices and including taxes and duties. All other assumptions are same as for the economic analysis. The financial analysis is given in Table 10. The analysis reveals that small size RHSs are not financially feasible having FIRR as 11.8% which is less than 12%. The medium size has FIRR as 15.0% and large size as 17.1% and both are financially feasible. The projects financial rate of return (FIRR) is estimated as 15.1% and BC ratio as 1.30 to one. Financial cash flow for three categories of RHSs showing agriculture, fisheries an d total benefits are given in Table 10. Table 10: Summary of Financial Analysis Results Sr. No. Description RHS Small Medium Large Overall A Economic Indicators IRR % 17.75% 15.99% 18.0% 17.43% NPV (Million Rs.) 29.76 1.39 51.85 100.55 BC Ratio 1.5 1.39 1.59 1.52 B Basic Project Costs (Million Rs.) 59.1 52.36 95.0 206.5 C Total Command Area (ac) 251 298 445 994 D Total Cost per ac (Rs.) 281,571 239,087 213,483 236,25 9 E Benefits Rs/ac 62,234 62,033 62,026 69,614 Economic and Financial Sensitivity Analysis Economic analysis was carried out for overall project as base case and then repeated for following three scenarios: a. Increase cost by 10% b. Reduce benefits by 10% c. Increase cost by 10% and reduce benefits by 10% World Water Day – 2017 29 The values of economic parameters for base case and above three scenarios are given in Table 11. It indicates that project is feasible with BC ratio of 1.79 and EIRR as 19.15% and even under worse scenario, the project will be economically feasible. Table 11: Sensitivity Analysis Results (Economic) Scenario Net Present Worth (Millions Rs.) Benefit Cost Ratio EIRR (%) Base Case 135.39 1.79 19.15 Sensitivity Analysis a. Increase cost by 10% 118.11 1.62 17.84 b. Reduce benefits by 10% 104.58 1.61 17.71 c. Increase cost by 10% and reduce benefits by 10%. 87.34 1.46 16.47 The financial value of project benefits has been estimated by using market prices and including taxes and duties. All other assumptions are the same as for the economic analysis. The projects financial rate of return (FIRR) is estimated as 17.43% and BC ratio as 1.52 ( Table 12). Sensitivity analysis shows that project is robust and financially feasible under worse scenario. Table 12: Sensitivity Analysis Results (Financial) Scenario Net Present Worth (Millions Rs.) Benefit Cost Ratio FIRR (%) Base Case 100.55 1.52 17.43 Sensitivity Analysis a. Increase cost by 10% 81.40 1.39 16.11 b. Reduce benefits by 10% 71.34 1.37 15.97 c. Increase cost by 10% and reduce benefits by 10%. 52.19 1.25 14.72 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS General: Pothohar region presents a good potential for construction of rainwater harvesting structures for storing runoff water and bringing barren lands under cultivation. Criteria: Following criteria was adopted for analysis: a) Mark the potential RHS sites utilizing imagery and general landuse map of the Pothohar area. b) Determine height and storage capacity of the reservoir on the basis of topographical survey. c) Identify command area in the vicinity of the rainwater harvesting structure. 30 World Water Day – 2017 d) Recheck design of the structure on the basis of general geology of the area assuming that rock will be available approximately at 10 ft depth from the surface. Mo reover, availability of impervious material within 3 miles haulage distance shall be assumed. e) Design of spillway will be assessed on the basis of 25 year return period inflow whereas highest flood level (HFL) of the RHS will be determined on return period. f) Prepare BOQ and calculate base cost of the RHS and add 5% for physical contingencies. g) Considering water and land resources as constraining factors, 25% of command area is proposed to be served with high efficiency irrigation system (HEIS) and Drip Irrigation is the option. The rest area will receive surface / flood irrigation and bed and furrow irrigation. The crop production is envisaged to be achieved through bringing barren land under cultivation and practising of cropping pattern and intensity of 140% with high return crops including orchards and high value crops on 25% of the command area proposed to be served with HEIS and traditional crops on 75% of area proposed to be served with conventional irrigation and bed furrow method of irrigation. h) Calculate agriculture benefits per acre of command area. i) Perform economic analysis of the RHS. j) Structures having storage capacity less than 10 AF and above 100 AF will not be considered is recommended. k) Solar system shall be installed for such RHSs with pumps ranging from 2Hp to 5Hp depending upon availability of command area and willingness of farmers to adopt HEIS as more than 90% RHSs would require lifting of water instead of gravitational flow. Geological Studies: Mostly shale and cla ys predominate at the abutments while hard strata of sand stone is encountered in the nullah beds at shallow depths at most of the sites. Required construction material in adequate quantities and of suitable quality for the construction of these sites is available. Hydrological Studies: The catchment area for these sites will vary from 0.25 to 3 mile 2 and average annual yield for 1 mile2 is about 161 acre feet. The annual sediment yield is 2 AF/mile2. The spillway will be designed to pass 100 year return period. Sediment Control and other Benefits: With the construction of these RHSs, flows will be conserved for regulated flows for sustained irrigation in the Pothohar region. Moreover, these RHSs will be helpful in checking sediment in already constructed sm all dams in the Pothohar region. Agricultural Studies: Command area is available in the vicinity of these sites. The present agriculture in the command area is meager and below subsistence level mainly due to slopping land and non-availability of regular supply of irrigation water. Because of assured irrigation supplies after the construction of these RHSs, annual cropping World Water Day – 2017 31 intensity of 140% will be achieved within a period of 4 years after project commencement. Project Cost & Economic Analysis: The basic co st of 40 sites including RHS and Spillway come to about Rs. 181.511 million. The average per acre of CCA cost is about Rs. 182,606. The overall project cost also includes HEIS, social and environmental management. Agriculture marketing support and project management cost etc. and it comes to about Rs. 279 million with average cost per acre of CCA as Rs. 280,824. A threshold limit of RHS cost in terms of its being economically feasible is about Rs. 375,000 per acre of CCA. 32 World Water Day – 2017
Filename:
2-Water-Resources-Dr.-Muhammad-Nawaz.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
862 KB
Categories:
World Water Day 2017
Downloads:
1
