UNIQUE CHALLENGES FACE WIND POWER DEVELOPERS, BUYERS Utility reso urce pla nners are u sed to v iewing ne w ge neration in terms of firm, dispatchable capacity. Dispat ching a renewable res ource such as wind requires a different perspective. Wind capacity can serv e as a hedge agains t fossil fuel price risks and perhaps future emissions restrictions, but it requires a much more structured planning horizon. Integrating wind farms into their portfolio may be the most difficult challenge utilities face today. Wind power has grown over the past de cade from a boutique and un-appreciat ed generating technology to a reliable and mu ch-sought-after resource. Bob Dylan wa s prescient when he wrote, “The answer, my friend, is blowin’ in the wind.” Much of D ylan’s early work focused on polit ics, social commentary, and philosophy, s marking him as an establishment outsider. But his enduring qualities have raised him to iconic status. TIME magazine named him one of the most influent ial people of the 20 th century, and his latest album reached No. I on t he charts this past August. H is last visit there was 30 years ago. The acc eptance of wind power is following a s imilar cour se, although it will c learly become part of the ma instream faster than Bob Dy lan. Overall, the wind power news is good, but many technical and commercial hur dles remain, in the opinion of POWER editors. Many readers may take issue with our appraisal. That’s fine: Spurring debate on issues of the day is what POWER magazine does best. In this lead article of our special report on wind, we discuss a few of the sit ing issues that are sl owing penetration of U.S. wind power. Following it is a companion article — ”Wind farmers: Heed the lessons of the me rchant gas-power business” — that takes a sensible look at the technol ogy issues. Our purpose is to pragmatically exp lore the issues and provide a departure point for discussion and studied alternative viewpoints. If you don’t agree with our asse ssments, write me at editor @powermag.com. We’ll print the best of your letters in an upcoming issue. Wind Picking up Speed Today there are several unmistakable s igns that wind power has reached the mainstream. Among them are the number of competing manufacturers with full production lines, major utilities such as Xcel and F PL Energy making money wit h diversified wind portfolios, and growth both in the number and size of projects—and opposition to them. Calling wi nd power mature would be prem ature, because not all of its application and siti ng problems have been solved. But solutions seem to be on the horizon. 1 Case in point: The integration of wind power into a power system makes predicting day- ahead loads on a real-time basis more variable and uncertain. This uncertainty naturally requires additional operating reserves (spi nning and non-spinning) for not just demand and energy, but also f or other ancillary servic es such as regulation, ramping, and load- following ( Figure 1). Yet transmission owning utilities are us ed to precision when dispatching their fleets of conventional plants . The expectations of your local and state regulators with regard to reliabi lity will also influence how fast wind becom es part of your portfolio. Some regulators are pushing hard for wind generat ion. while others wouldn’t know a wind turbine if they walked into it. More on this issue later. First, the Good News In its third-quarter report, the American Wind Energy Association (A WEA) projects that 2,750 MW of wind power capacity will come on- line this year. That’s about as much generating capacity as Rhode Island has. Accounting for a big chunk of the total is FPL Energy’s just-completed Horse Hollow Wind Energy Center in Taylor County, Texas. At 735 MW, it takes the title of the largest wind farm in the U.S. The plant ent ered service in September and is powered by 291 GE 1.5 – MW turbines and 130 Siemens Power Generation units each rated at 2.3 MW (Figure 2). 2 FPL Energy currently operates 48 wind farms in the U.S. with a gross capacity of nearly 4,100 MW; more than 1,600 MW are in Texas alone. When Horse Hollow came on-line, Texas su rpassed California in total wind energy production, making the Lone Star State No. 1 in the U.S. California had been the leader for 25 years; at one point in the 1980s the Golden State was home to 8% of worldwide wind power capacity. Recent legislation calls for California utilities to get 20% of their supply from green sources by 2010. But tr ansmission bottlenecks may make that laudable public policy goal difficult to reach. If there’s one thing AWEA members would lik e from the yet-to-be-seated 109th U.S. Congress next y ear, it’s another extension of the federal Produc tion Tax Credit (PT C) for wind power. The credit, which was extended for two years by the 2005 Energy Policy Act, is now set to expire in December 2007. In the past, whenever the PTC was allowed to expire, investment in wind pr ojects was chilled by the uncer tainty of future subsidies, until subsidies were reinstated. The interim result was a n all-too familiar boom and bust cycle of wind project development. “To strengthen our energy independenc e we need s afe, domestic, and inexhaustib le energy, and wind power provides just that,” said AWEA Exec utive Direc tor Randall 3 Swisher. “The U.S. wind energy industry is working all-out to meet current demand for new wind f arms. But the nation needs a time ly and long-term extension of the wind energy Production Tax Credit to allow companies to plan bey ond 2007 and c ontinue to build a strong and secure energy future.” he added. According to the AWEA, some 1,345 MW of wind capacity already have been completed this year through the third quarter, bringing the U.S. total to 10,492 MW. The DOE’s Energy Information Administration notes that this year new wind c apacity may account for 18% to 20% of total U.S. new capacity; only new gas -fired generation will add more capacity. The AWEA had projected 3,000 MW for 20 07, but many projects slated for 2006 will slip into 2007, principally due to inte rconnection delays. Next year looks equally bright, with 3,000 to 3,500 MW projected to enter commercial service. Pushing the Limits Every state has a unique combination of natural resources, fuel availability, and political landscape that—more or less—defines the boundaries of acceptable power generation technology. Not every state has generous reserves of coal or oil, but many are blessed with strong winds and a citizenry that wants to put that clean resource to work. However, there are limitations on how mu ch wind a utility or region al aut hority can handle. Variables inc lude wind’s compatibility with generation ty pes already on the power grid (natural gas and hydro work well with win d power, for example), the utility’s service area size (lar ger areas can handle the fickle nature of wind farm production more easily), and the distribut ion of generating as sets (the more widely they’re spread out, the smoother the integration of wind power). Developers and system planners seem to have a good handle on int egration issues, if the number and size of wind farms recently commissioned is any guide. However, chal- lenges do remain. Participants at a recent technical s ymposium on utility-scale win d power hos ted by the IEEE, AW EA, the North American Elec tric Reliability Coun cil (NERC), and the Utility Wind Integration Group (UWIG) identified the following three key integration issues. Forecasting Tools Wind forecasting tools are needed to hel p system operators and manager s make the most efficient use of the resources on a gi ven system to minimize operational cost s. Mark Ahlstrom of Wind Logics ( www.windlogics.com) noted that as forecasts become more accurate, they will be delivered to syst em operators in the format most useful for decision-making in the control room. Bette r dynamic models of wind turbines and aggregate models of wind plan ts are needed to perform more -accurate studies of transmission planning and system operation. 4 According to UWIG (www.uwig.org), fluctuations in t he net loa d (load minus win d) caused by greater variability and uncertain ty introduced by wind plants have been shown to increase sy stem operating costs by up to about $5/MWh at wind penetration levels up to 20%. The largest part of this cost is associated with the uncertainty introduced into day-ahead unit commitment by uncertainty in day-ahead forecasts of real-time wind energy production. A well-functioning hour-ahead an d day-ahead market provides the best means of a d- dressing the variability in wind plant output. According to UWIG, commercially available wind forec asting tools can substantially r educe the costs associated with day-ahea d uncertainty. In one m ajor study, state-of-the- art forecasting was shown to provide 80% of the benefits that would result from perfect forecasting. Reliability Overall grid reliability and pos t-fault response now can be improved by including wind capacity in the mix, thanks to new high-tech features of modern wind turbines (which have become significantly more reliable themselves). The latest set of bells and whistles includes low-voltage ride thr ough capabilit y, reactive power control, voltage control, output control, and ramp rate control. Futu re designs are likely to sport post-fault machine r esponse c haracteristics similar to those of conventional generators (for example, inertial response and governor response). In one study of the impact of integrating 3,300 MW of wind power (10% market pen- etration) into New York’s transmission sys tem, system post-fault response was better with than without wind turbines, according to data from Hydro-Québec presented by GE Energy. The study concluded t hat the 3,300 MW are expect ed to increase NERC’s re- quired operating reserve margin only by 36 MW and reduce the New York Independent System Operator’s annual variable costs by $350 million. According to UWIG, wind generation may al so provide some additional load-carrying capability to meet forecasted in creases in system demand. This contribution is likely to be up to 40% of a typical project’s namepl ate rating, depending on local wind charac- teristics and the project’s compatibility with the system load profile. System stability studies have s hown t hat modern wind plant s equipped with power electronic controls and dynamic voltage s upport capability can improve system per- formance by damping power swings and supporting post-fault voltage recovery. Transmission constraints. Constraints — from interconnection and grid access to tariffs and grid expansion—are a big factor in determining whether wind will become a signific ant part of the generation mix. Federal Energy Regula tory Commissioner Nora Browne ll noted that F ERC wants to be a “platform for change” and help get the rules right on interconnection, imbalance, 5 reliability, and market access. “Being ‘risk-averse’ should not mean doing things the way they were done 30 years ago,” she said. Upgrades or addition s to transmission fa cilities may be need ed to provid e access to remote locations with large wind energy potential. Current transmission planning processes are able to identify s olutions to transmission problems, but the time required for their implementation often exceeds the time frame of project permitting and con- struction by several y ears. This fact will be the primar y reason why many u tilities wi ll miss their renewable portfolio standards (RPS) goals in coming years. Speaking as the head of NE RC’s Wind Energy working group, Mahendra Patel of the Pennsylvania-New J ersey-Maryland (PJM) Powe r P ool s aid t hat bringing more wind power on-line “is not a reliability issue” but rather a market issue, inv olving cost allocation among various sources. Truer words may never have been spoken. How Far Can Wind Travel? National G rid (www.n ationalgridus.com) pub lished a white pap er in September that directly addressed the “current inadequacie s in U.S. transmission policies that create obstacles for wind and other renewable generat ors in accessing the country’s electric grid.” In the paper, titled “Transmission and W ind Energy: Capturing the Prevailing Winds for the Benefit of Custom ers,” National Grid advocates t he “development of a consistent and appropriate polic y approac h to support the transmission inve stment needed t o harness wind power and integr ate it into the U.S. electricit y grid while continuing to maintain system reliability.” It adds that “obstacles to new gener ation sources continue to exist due to the lack of adequate transmission system access.” Access t o transmission, however, is constraining not just wind power penetration but the entire electric power industry. Existing grids were designed to support monopoly utility service in a given physical territory, not a competitive regional whol esale market in which large quantities of electricity are moved long distances. Complicating the problem, investment in transmission has lagged behind load growth for more than 20 years. There are many reasons for that, including lack of comprehens ive regional planning, inc onsistent cost allocation rules, and lack of financial incentives. The result plagues wind projects, which tend to be located in sparsely populated areas far from load centers, as much as it does mine-mouth “coal-by-wire” projects. The problematic approach to pr oject interconnect that’s in universal use today requires new projects to shoulder any sy stem reliability issues, and the ir resultant costs, when connecting to the grid. This piecemeal appr oach ad ds uncertainty to siting, financing, and procurement processes and consequent ly delays project schedules. A better approach would be t o level the play ing fiel d for wind farm developers s o they can economically move power from a wind-rich state to a state where there are green power sales opportunities. 6 Flight Fight Settled Aside from noise pollution (see box), perhaps the biggest stain on wind po wer’s green reputation is the turbines’ deadly impact on avian wildlife, especially bats and migratory birds. In 2004, the Center fo r Biological Diversity (CBD) sued the nine owners of wind turbines constituting the Altamont Wind Res ource Area an hour east of San Francisc o. The CBD c laimed that birds such as golden eagles, red-tailed hawks, burrowing owls , and other protected species are routinely torn apart by turbine blades or electrocuted by the wind farm’s transmission line s. According to CBD researchers, from 880 to 1,330 raptors alone are killed each year by Altam ont wind turbines. Wind turbines have been operating at Altamont Pass since 1981, and the lawsuit focused on early models. Sound advice: Make wind turbines seen but not heard By Teresa Drew and Roger Treagus, Golder Associates Ltd. For many developers of wind power projects, the “noise issue” is one that just won’t go away. It comes up in public forums, in m eetings with local government bodies, and in kitchen-table discussions with local landowners. Given the relatively low noise level of today’s wind turbines, why are they considered noise polluters a priori? Early models were louder for a v ariety of re asons, including a high er turning speed and less- efficient designs, Better sound shielding of me chanical noise sources, improved aerodynamics, and other techni cal ad vances have sub stantially redu ced, but not eliminated, the noise produ ced by today’s turbines of equivalent size. The human Factor One plausible reason for wind turbines’ bad aural reputation is their big visual impact. Because sight dominates human sensation, any source of noise that can be se en seems louder. Wind turbines are large, out in the open, often on high g round, and they move — alt of which attract attention. If people don’t like the look of a wind farm, they may transfer this dislike to the sound it makes. There are many steps that developers can take to re duce the actual and perceived noise impact of a wind power project. The most im portant is to consider noise e arly in the pl anning p rocess. M ost developers focus first on wind speed and reliability, as they should. However, noise should not take a back seat to other environmental consequences of a proje ct, such as th ose o n bird and bat populations, rare plant and animal species, and sensitive habitat and ecosystems. To account for noise, the site selection process needs to be broader than is often the case with other developments, right fro m the start. Hiring e nvironmental an d noise profession als to ve t potential locations f or certain d eal-killers can spare a d eveloper f rom wasting mon ey a nd time on dead-end candidates. Which Way is Upwind? When evaluating a potential site for noisiness, fluctuations in prevailing wind patterns should be taken into acco unt. Becau se sound c ca rries farther downwind, it’s important to know b oth the dominant direction and how often the wind deviates from it. The minimum distance, or setback, from a “receptor” such as a farm house or subdivision (including those planned for the future) should be increased if it is frequently downwind of the wind farm. 7 As an example, consider a recent wind farm project in which Golder Associates was involved. In our preconstruction projections, we indicated that, to limit the noise impact on a cluster of nearby homes, our client would need to shut down so me of the turb ines closest to it. But it would only hav e to do so when the wind blew in a particular direction (historically, only one or two days a year on average) and only when it blew above a certain speed. These parameters were integrated into the farm’s operating plan, and it now works at full efficiency almost all of, the time. When planning to limit noise pollution, realize that topography and ground conditions can significantly affect noi se propagation. Studies have sho wn th at lining a ridge with turbine s p roduces “shadow zones” on its slopes: noise levels are actually lower near the turbines than at a distance in the valleys below. For sites near a body of water, remember that reflections off the water’s surface] can amplify noise. Past, Present, and Future Finally, the planning of a school, hospital, or subdivision (or the recent rezoning of a property for such a land use) may create limitations on wind farm development. It’s a good idea for developers to build good relations with local authorities and regulators to learn what land use changes are possible. Noise criteria normally do not contain a land use component, making it even more i mportant for developers to be certain that encroachment on their site is unlikely. Sound level projections are more acceptable if they are based on real-world results. Developers need to conduct thorough preconstruction projections of a project’s noise impacts and then verify them later. Through p ractice, su ch dili gence imp roves the accu racy~ of proj ections for fu ture proje cts. It also comes in handy during discussions with municipal leaders and others who could possibly be affected by a future wind farm. If individuals are shown that previous projections of noise levels were accurate, they’ll be more willing to trust the projections being made for a wind farm under consideration. Teresa Drew and Roger Treagus are sound engineers in the Calgary office of Golder Associates Ltd., a ground engineering and environmental services specialist. They can be reached at 1 403-299-5600 or via teresa_drew@golder.com and roger_treagusc@golder.com CBD’s suit contends that the birds are part of the public tr ust and therefore the property of the public. In a dec ision issued in October 2006, an Al ameda County Superior Court judge held that California citizens cannot br ing suit under the public trust doctrine to prevent the continued killing of public trust wildlife. In response, Richard Wiebe, the CBD’s attorney, said, “The court’s ruling conflicts with more than 100 years of Califor nia Supreme Court rulings t hat clearly es tablish that California’s wildlife is property owned by th e people of California. It also conflicts wit h California Supreme Court rulings holding t hat citizens and public interes t groups can sue to enforce public trust property rights. The bird deaths are preventable and the operators must be forced to resolve this problem. A few intransigent companies should not be allowed to needlessly s laughter wildlife and impede the expansion of renewable energy.” A year earlier, in Sept ember 2005, the Al ameda County Board of Supervis ors adopted new permit conditions for more than 4,000 ex isting, obsolete wind turbines in the 8 Altamont Pass at the request of the CBD. The new permits require: • Seasonal shutdowns of turbines duri ng the winter migratory season, when bird deaths are particularly high. • Immediate shutdown of the 2% of wind turbines sho wn by studies to be particularly lethal to birds. • Monitoring of avian mortality. • The preparation of an environmental impac t report within three ye ars to assess the problem of bird fatalities and the most effective ways to reduce them. • Replacement of existing wind turbines by fewer, more efficien t, and taller turbines over the next 13 years. Wind now on the Radar—Literall y Another wind farm siting problem was the focus of a recent U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) report of obvious interest to any wind power developer. T he report, titled “The Effect of Windmill Farms on Military Readin ess,” concludes that wind farms located in the line of sight of an air defense radar system could degrade t he system’s effectiveness. The im pact, of course, woul d depend on the number and location of the farm’s turbines. The report, which was released this past S eptember, was prepared in res ponse to a congressional call for the secr etary of defense to subm it a report on the effects of wind farms on military readiness. Pe nding completion of the report, in March 2006 the Do D and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) adopted an interim policy (pending publication of the final report in the Congressional Rec ord) that warned that they would contest any wind farms “within radar line of site of the National Air Defense and Homeland Security radars.” The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) subsequently began issuing “Notices of Presumed Hazard” to wind projects located within 60 nautical miles of long-range radar installations. At least 12 projects in I llinois, Wisconsin, North Dako ta, and South Dak ota received such notices, placing a de facto moratorium on construction. According to a statement issued by Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) on June 2, the “ overwhelming percentage of land in this country is classified as within the ‘radar line of sight’ and possibly obstructive.” The DoD’s final report evaluated several miti gation measures and defined mit igation as follows: “either an approach that comple tely prevents any negative impact from occurring,” or an approach that sufficiently reduces any negative impa cts so that “there is no significant influence on the capability of air defense or missile warning r adar.” The report also noted that the only proven mitigation measure is “line of sight mitigation”—in other words, not plac ing wind turbines wit hin a radar’s fiel d of view. Line of sight mitigation may be achieved by employing the “bald earth” approach (increasing the distance between the radar system and the tu rbines), te rrain masking (hiding the turbines behind a mountain), or terrain relief (when the radar is relatively higher than the turbines). 9 The impac t of the DoD/DHS policy and t he FAA actions on wind farm developer s nationwide is immediate, signific ant, and pot entially costly. Any new project now must apply to the FAA for a hazard determination prior to starting construction on a ne w plant. The developer must submit a “Notice of Proposed Construction or Alteration” to the Air Traffic Division Manager of the FAA Regional Office with jurisdiction over the site location. T he report notes that specific DoD bas es and inst allations are assigned management responsibilities for specific sect ions of airspace. Wind developers should continue to work with local base and installation managers to eliminate potential impacts on existing facilities. COURTESY – POWER (By Dr. Robert Peltier, P.E.) 10
Filename:
Unique-Challenges.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
269 KB
Categories:
Volume 0005
Downloads:
1
