59 NIGHTMARE SCENARIOS A new IMF report throws the severity of Pakistan’s water crisis into sharp relief . Pakistan has the world’s fourth highest rate of water use. Its water intensity rate – the amount of water, in cubic metres, used per unit of GDP – is this world’s highest. This suggests that no country’s economy is more a water-intensive than Pakistan. The aggressive water consumption portends catastrophic consequence : According to the IMF, Pakistan is already the third most water -stressed country in th e world. Its per capita annual water availability is 1,017 cubic metres – perilously close to the scarcity threshold of 1,000 cubic metres. Back in 2009, Pakistan’s water availability was about 1,500 cubic metres. According to projections from a study pro duced that year, called Running on Empty , Pakistan would not become water scarce until 2035. Instead, thanks to lightning fast consumption rates, Pakistan is nearly water scarce today. And yet it gets worse. New NASA satellite data of the world’s undergr ound aquifers reveal rapidly depleting groundwater tables. The aquifer in the Indus Basin – whose rivers and tributaries constitute Pakistan’s chief water source – is the second most stressed in the world (this means rapid depletion with little or no sign of recharge). This shouldn’t be surprising : even seven years ago, groundwater tables in parts of Lahore had fallen by up to 65 feet (20 metres) over a five year period. Groundwater is water security’s last report – it is what we tap into when surface sup plies run dry. And yet in Pakistan, this safety net is fraying. The country’s water security blanket is in danger of being yanked away. In sum, Pakistan is voraciously consuming water even as water tables are plummeting precipitously. So what to do? The same solutions have been trotted out of years, many of them problematic. Build more large dams? Expensive and controversial. Demand that India stop obstructing downstream river flows? Impractical, Poor water governance, rapid population growth, and climate change effects – not upper riparian machinations – are the reason for Pakistan’s water crisis. The most reasonable recommendation is simply to use existing resources more judiciously. However, people won’t be willing to conserve unless they have a strong incentive to do so . Fortunately, there is an obvious way to generate that incentive – charge consumers a realistic price for their water. To that end, the IMF report wisely calls for water pricing reform. The might be the best way to case the water crisis before it spirals completely out of control. In Pakistan, as the report states, public water utilizes tend to set prices below cost recovery levels. Irrigation water charges recover less than a quarter of annual operating and maintenances costs. On the wh ole, agriculture largely untaxed – and yet more than 90 pc of Pakistan’s water resources are allocated to that sector. By charging more for water (ideally using a pricing scale tied to income level), not only would consumers presumably use in more judiciously, but the government would also gain desperately needed revenue. And the revenue would enable Pakistan to pay for badly needed repairs. Water expert Simi Kamal has estimated that repairing and maintaining the country’s existing canal system would free up about 75 million acre feet of water – close to the 83 MAF water shortfall that the IMF projects Pakistan will face in the coming years. This additional revenue could also be used to repair Pakistan’s dilapidated large dams. Tarbela has lost nearly 30 p c of its storage capacity since the late 1970s. Pakistan’s total dam storage constitutes only 30 days of average demand (the figure is 220 days in India). Revenue – 60 infrastructure, water-conserving technologies, and – perhaps most importantly – programmes that help the poor pay for and access water. Admittedly, all this makes for a very tall order. It presumes that leaders can muster sufficient political will to implement pricing reforms, and that consumers have the ability and desire to pay more for water. Additionally, pricing reforms is no silver bullet for the water crisis. If won’t address Pakistan’s troubling land ownership policies, which ensure that the land less struggle to access water (land ownership, it has been said, is a proxy for water rights). It won’t make Pakistan’s water any cleaner, dirty water kills more than 600 Pakistani children a day. And it won’t reduce the bloat in Pakistan’s water sector bureaucracy, which makes water policymaking highly inefficient. And yet unless Pakistan miraculously manages to halt the effects of climate change or to make billions upon billions of cubic metres of water appear out of thin air, there really is no other choice. Particularly because of what may lie in store down the toad. Back in 2009, the Running on Empty study projected that by 2025, Pakistan’s water shortfall could be five times the amount of water that could then be stored throughout the Indus River System’s vast reservoirs. It estimated that the shortfall in 2025 would comprise almost two thirds of the entire Indus River System’s current annual average flow. Based on the IMF’s new estimate, it’s likely that these projections would be even more alarming if calculated again today. In effect, in the absence of immediate action, Pakistan could face the not-too-distant prospect of becoming a water-starved wasteland. And that’s a thought that should be keeping us all up at night. (Courtesy of Dawn 29-06-2015)

Filename: 59-60-NIGHTMARE-SCENARIOS.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 115 KB
Categories: Volume 0046 No 01-02