Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 195 USING LOCALLY AVAILABLE FLY ASH FOR MODIFYING CONCRETE PROPERTIES Syed Ali Rizwan1, Shamas–ur–Rehman Toor2, Husnain Ahmad3 ABSTRACT This paper suggests the possible use of fly ash, a bye-product produced in our thermal power plants operating on coal as fuel for improvement of concrete quality. In the present investigation, locally available finely divided fly ash has been used for modification Presently, it is being used extensively in concrete in modern countries and is considered as waste material in general. Behavior of fly ash modified concrete in comparison to normal concrete having same mix proportions, aggregates, net water-cement ratio and similar curing conditions has been studied in short terms up to the age of 56 days during which the specimens were subjected to normal water curing method. Tests were carried out for compressive strengt h at 3, 7, 14, 28 and 56 days, 24 hours %age water absorption at the age of 56 days and durability (resistance of concrete against N/2 sloutions of both nitric acid and hydrochloric acid for one month) of concrete were also carried out at the age of 56 days. It was seen that the compressive strength of concrete modified with the available type of fly ash was less than the normal concrete. But so far as the durability and %age water absorption are concerned, fly ash plays an important role here. 24 hours %age water absorption decreases with increase in fly ash content an admixture and as a cement replacement in concrete. But so far as durability is concerned, 20% replacement of fly ash with cement appears to be more effective than it is with 40%. The purpose of investigation was to introduce the use of fly ash in concretes to the Engineers and Architects in Pakistan. Keywords: Fly ash, Modified concrete, Curing method, Durability of concrete, Acid resistance, Chemical resistance, %age water absorption. INTRODUCTION Fly ash is a byproduct of burning finely divided coal in electrically generating power plants. It is captured from exhaust gases of power plants by electrostatic precipitation which enables the relatively clean air to escape from smoke. Fly ash is rich in oxides of silica, alumina and iron. Chemically speaking, “fly ash looks for lime” when mixed with cement in presence of water. 100 kg of Portland cement when mixed with water liberates12-20 kg of free lime (CaO) during hydration. Fly ash with its chemically active silica and alum ina readily reacts with this free lime to form additional cementitious compounds. When used in concrete, fly ash acts like cement, and actually replaces a percentage of the Portland cement used. Fly ash generally replaces around 15% of cement in much of the concrete 1 Syed Ali Rizwan is a Professor of Civil Engineering, Univer sity of Engineering and Technology (UET) Lahore- 54890, Pakistan., M.ASCE. Email: syedalirizwan@hotmail.com His research focusses mainly on design, repair, maintenance and load testing of structures, concrete admixtures and space structures. 2 Shamas–ur–Rehman Toor is a Graduate in Civil Engineering, University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Lahore-54890, Pakistan. Email: shamastoor@hotmail.com 3 Husnain Ahmad, Executive District Officer, Information Technology Department, City District Government Lahore. Email: husnainahmad@hotmail.com Rizwan, Toor, Ahmad 196 used today, but we can do much better by using it to replace up to 50% or more to be known as High Volume Fly Ash Concrete (HVFAC) It is well known that modification of cons truction materials always aims at some predetermined and carefully selected objective. The choice of admixtures to be used also depends upon the objective of modification which may either be for strength, architectural finishes or durability or a combination of these. Modification with Fly ash usually results in cement savings, increased workability, increased strength after 56 days, increased cohesion of mix, increased frost and chemical resistance and reduced permeability of concrete etc which makes a high performance concrete. When fly ash is added to the mix, the silica in fly ash reacts with these large crystals and transforms them into a strong cement paste that binds concrete together. This eliminates the micro cracking and creates concrete that is much less permeable, and therefore more durable. USES OF FLY ASH IN CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY Concrete manufacturers, engineers, architects, developers and contractors all have an interest in specifying or using fly ash on a routine basis to improve the quality of concrete and to increase cost effectiveness. PRE–MIX PRODUCERS A pre–mix producer has several reasons for using fly ash in concrete: 1. Fly ash can compensate for fines not found in some sands and, thereby, enhance pumpability and concrete finishing. 2. Fly ash will result in a more predictable and consistent finished product which will ensure customer acceptance. 3. Fly ash offers flexibility in mix design providi ng a greater range of mixes – from “flowable fill” at about 1 MPa to high strength 50+ MPa concrete –produced by the same batch plant without exotic equipment. (1 Mpa = 145 psi) 4. Fly ash improves the flowability of concrete wh ich translates into less wear and tear on the entire producer’s equipment from batching facilities to trucks. 5. Fly ash enables the producer to customise designs to each customer’s needs, thus providing the producer who uses it with a competitive advantage. ENGINEERS AND ARCHITECTS Engineers and architects will find that fly ash provides the following benefits: 1. It enables them to provide the client with a superior and more durable finished concrete. 2. Fly ash produces a high strength concrete that accommodates the design of thinner sections. 3. Fly ash permits design flexibility accommoda ting curves, arches and other pleasing architectural effects. 4. The addition of fly ash to the mix is a built-in insurance for later-age strength gain in concrete. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 197 5. Fly ash ensures that the concrete will qualify as a durable building material. 6. Fly ash contributes to the aesthetic appearance of the concrete. DEVELOPERS, CONTRACTORS, OWNERS Fly ash concrete provides the following advantages to developers, contractors and owners: 1. The workability of fly ash concrete generally ensures that the speed of construction is faster which translates into a quicker return on investment. 2. Fly ash in the mix accommodates more creative designs. 3. Since fly ash concrete is not as vulnerable to deterioration or disintegration as rapidly as concrete without fly ash, it ensures low-maintenance buildings which will retain their value over the long-term. Fly ash definitely enhances quality of concrete construction and returns real benefits to every member of the building team. CASTINGS In order to study the parameters, mentioned in the Abstract, for both normal and locally available fly-ash modified concretes, the castings were made using both conventional 1:1.5:3 and 1:2:4 concrete mix proportions by weight havi ng net water-cement ratio (W/C) of 0.6 (called ‘control concrete’)at a room temperature of 340C and relative humidity of 55 %. Locally available Haro sand with a fineness modulus of 2.60 on ASTM Sieve 100 (BS sieve 100) and Margallah crushed stone (Lime stone or calcium carbonate) having a fineness modulus of 6.6 on sieve 100 was used (in market language 3/4” down). Fly ash was added to the same mixes of concrete as an admixture and as a cement replacement of 20% and 40% as per ACI [1,2,3] Procedures. It was mixed with sand firstly (in presence of 50% of total water content) and then other ingredients were mixed and water was subseque ntly added after 2-3 minutes of initial mixing. Workability tests were done. Based on literature survey [4,5,6,7] the castings included 100x100x100 mm (4”x 4”x 4”) cubes for compression testing and 50x50x50 mm (2”x 2”x 2”) cubes for %age water absorption and durability tests. The coarse aggregates had an apparent specific gravity of 2.63. The total mixing time in a pan type mixer was about 4 minutes. Table 1 and 2 give the bulk densities of constituent materials and workability test results respectively. Rizwan, Toor, Ahmad 198 Table-1: Bulk Densities of Constituent Materials Material Loose State (Kg/m3)/(lb/ft³) Rodded State (Kg/m3)/(lb/ft³) Haro Sand 1433.8/89.61 1586.0/99.12 Coarse aggregate ( 19 mm down) 1418.3/88.64 1595.6/99.72 Cement 1435.4/89.71 — Fly ash 409.9/25.625 — Some properties of locally available fly ash used in this investigation are given in Table-2 while Table-3 gives the results of workability tests. Table-2: Properties of Locally Available Fly Ash Specific Gravity %age Voids Fineness Modulus % LOI (Loss on Ignition) 2.5 83.57 0.74 3.685 Table 3: Results of Workability Tests Type of test Type of mix W/C Ratio Normal concrete 20% modified concrete 40% modified concrete 1:1.5:3 0.6 89 / 3.5 95 / 3.75 102 / 4.0 Slump test (mm / in) 1:2:4 0.6 0 / 0 38 / 1.5 60 / 2.375 1:1.5:3 0.6 0.99 1.0 1.0 Compacting factor test 1:2:4 0.6 0.85 0.94 0.97 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 199 CURING OF SPECIMENS For curing, all the specimens were kept in water for 28 days after demoulding at the age of 24 hours. During these 24 hours, specimens in moulds were kept in the laboratory at an average temperature of 32o at 55% relative humidity. After this time period, they were taken out of water and kept at normal laboratory conditions and tested at specified ages. Table-4 gives the compressive strength results. Table-4: Compressive Strength Results on 4”x 4”x 4”cubes at 28 days Type of Mix Time (Days) Normal Concrete (MPa) / (psi) 20% Modified Concrete (MPa) / (psi) 40% Modified Concrete (MPa) / (psi) 3 14.22 / 2065 11.57 / 1680 9.64 / 1400 7 17.36 / 2520 14.22 / 2065 15.20 / 2205 14 21.70 / 3150 16.40 / 2380 18.32 / 2660 28 26.52 / 3850 21.00 / 3045 22.18 / 3220 (1:1.5:3) 56 27.49 / 3990 26.00 / 3780 23.15 / 3830 3 13.74 / 1995 10.85 / 1575 10.61 / 1540 7 17.36 / 2520 14.95 / 2170 14.47 / 2100 14 19.05 / 2765 16.39 / 2380 16.88 / 2450 28 24.35 / 3535 20.73 / 3010 20.73 / 3010 (1:2:4) 56 30.38 / 4410 28.21 / 4095 25.80 / 3745 24 hours water absorption of control concrete and that modified with varying percentages of locally available fly-ash has been studied and is reported in table 5. Table-5: Results of 24 Hour % Water Absorption Test at the Age of 56 Days 24 hours %age water absorption Type of mix Normal concrete 20% modified concrete 40% modified concrete 1:1.5:3 4.85 4.16 3.74 1:2:4 4.01 3.56 3.11 The Strength – Age relationships have also been plotted and are shown in Figures-1 and 2. Rizwan, Toor, Ahmad 200 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 0 7 14 21 28 35 42 49 56 Age (Days) Fig. 1 Age ~ Strength Relationship [ 1:1.5:3 ] Compressive Strength (psi) 0% FLY ASH 20% FLY ASH 40% FLY ASH 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 5000 0 7 14 21 28 35 42 49 56 Age (Days) Fig. 2 Age ~ Strength Relationship [ 1:2:4 Mix ] Compressive Strength (psi) 0% FLY ASH 20% FLY ASH 40% FLY ASH Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 201 Because concrete has pH values in the alkaline range so it was recommended in literature(8) to test its durability for chemical resistance against acids which were selected considering the results of an earlier investigations by some researchers [9,10].. The reagents were HCL and HNO3. Table 6 gives the details of commercially available acids used in the investigation. Table-6: Properties of Commercially Available Acids used in Investigation Type of test solution Density (g/cc) Purity (% ) 1 N Solution of 100% strength (g/l) 1 N Solution of given purity (g/l) N/2 Solution of given purity (g/l) HCl 1.14 28.61 36.5 127.58 63.79 HNO3 1.39 67.18 63 93.78 46.89 In chemical resistance tests specimens of the normal and modified concretes discussed above were earlier treated by N/20 and N/10 acid solutions which resulted in no appreciable weight and volume losses. Therefore it was decided to test them for N/2 acid normality. It was observed that a strong chemical reaction took place immediately after acid solutions came into contact with three different types of concrete specimens and CO2 was liberated after observing severe efflorescence for N/2 Normality of acids only. Table 7 gives the weight loss after 28 days treatment with the above mentioned reagents when the age of specimens was 56 days. Table–7: Weight Loss of Specimens after 28 Days Immersion in various Reagents at the Age of 56 Days Reagent Type of mix Strength of solution Type of concrete Initial.wt. (grams) Dry wt. after 28 days (grams) Weight Loss (%) N/2 Normal 302 257 15.07 N/2 20% modified 294 251 14.54 1:1.5:3 N/2 40% modified 307 254 17.26 N/2 Normal 315 271 14.02 N/2 20% modified 319 275 13.71 HCl 1:2:4 N/2 40% modified 303 254 15.97 N/2 Normal 281 240 14.48 N/2 20% modified 319 286 10.34 1:1.5:3 N/2 40% modified 279 233 16.52 N/2 Normal 319 283 11.28 N/2 20% modified 294 267 9.34 HNO3 1:2:4 N/2 40% modified 311 268 13.83 Rizwan, Toor, Ahmad 202 pH value changes within reagent solutions during a weeks’ use in a treatment cycle of 28 days (four weekly acid solution changes)have also been monitored by using pH sticks.. HCL showed low weakness and HNO 3 showed more weakness in terms of an increased pH value. These are presented in Table-8. Table-8: pH Variations for One Weekly Change of Reagent Reagent Type of mix Type of Concrete Value at Day 1 Value at 28 Days Normal 1 4 10 % 1 5 HCl 1:1.5:3 20% 1 5 Normal 1 5 10% 1 5 HNO3 1:1.5:3 20% 1 5 Normal 1 5 10 % 1 4 HCl 1:2:4 20% 1 5 Normal 1 5 10% 1 5 HNO3 1:2:4 20% 1 4 CONCLUDING REMARKS 1. Use of fly ash in concrete results in economical-high performance concrete. 2. The results are only for the materials and mix proportions used. For other mix proportions, same results may not be applicable. 3. Compressive strength of concrete decreases with an increase in %age of this type of fly ash as a cement replacement in concrete at early ages. However, at the age of 56 days, difference between compressive strength of normal and modified concrete is much less than it is at the age of 7 days for both mix proportions suggesting that long term strength of such modified concrete will be more than control concrete. 4. 24 hours %age water absorption of concrete re duces with increase in %age of fly ash in concrete. This trend is same for both mix proportions (1:1.5:3 and 1:2:4) investigated. 5. Permeability, durability and cohesion of concrete in general are improved. 6. Percentage weight loss in acid resistance test s is less for concrete having 20% fly ash than for 40% of fly ash. This trend is same for both mix proportions (1:1.5:3 and 1:2:4) investigated at water-cementitious materials ratio of 0.6. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 203 7. HCl proves to be stronger acid than HNO 3 because it causes more loss in weight. 8. Workability of concrete is also increased when fly ash is added to it. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: The research reported here has been sponsored by University of Engineering and Technology (UET) Lahore-Pakistan. Thanks are due to Engr. Azhar Ali Bhatti, Director Design, Izhar Group of Companies, Tipu Block,New Garden Town, Lahore, for providing fly ash used in the research work reported here. SELECTED REFERENCES 1. ACI – 211 “Proportioning of Normal Weight Concrete Mix Proportions”. 2. ACI – 212 “Concrete Admixtures”. 3. ACI – 548 “State of the Art Report on Polymer Modified Concrete”. ACI – 548.3 R-95. 4. Hielenz,R.C “ Mineral Admixtures – History and Background ”, Concrete International Journal, August 1983, pp (34-68). 5. Cook,J.E “ Fly ash in Concrete-Technical Considerations”, Concrete International Journal. Sept 1983, pp (51-60). 6. Swamy, R.N “Fly ash Concrete – Po tential without Misuse”, ACI Journal of Materials and Structures, 1990,No 23, pp (397-411). 7. Melhotra,V. M, Corret G.G and Langley,W.S “ Structural ConcreteImparting High Volume of ASTM class F-fly ashes”, ACI Materials Journal,Title No 88-448,September-October 1989, pp (507-513). 8. Ohama, Y and Miyake, M. “Resistance of Polymer-Modified Concrete to Inorganic Acids” National Symposium on Binder Economy and A lternate Binders in Road and Building Construction,1981, Japan 9. Rizwan,S.A., Hameed, A. and Ahmad,K. “Latex Modified High Performance Concrete” Proceedings of 6th International Sym posium on High Strength/High Performance Concrete,Volume-2, pp 1313-1324,University of Leipzeig, June 2002,Germany. 10. Rizwan,S.A., and Hameed, A. “ Comparative Response of SBR Latex Modified Concrete” 6th International Congress on Changes to Concrete Construction, July 2002, Congress Proc copy titled “Sustainable Construction”, pp 162-169,University of Dundee, Scotland, U.K.
Filename:
642.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
114 KB
