Paper No. 690 QUALITY MANAGEMENT FOR TAUNSA BARRAGE REHABILITATION PROJECT S.M.A. Zaidi, Malik Ahmad Khan & Javed Asad 316 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 317 QUALITY MANAGEMENT FOR TAUNSA BARRAGE REHABILITATION PROJECT S.M.A. Zaidi1, Malik Ahmad Khan2 & Javed Asad3 1. SYNOPSIS The safety and durability of any constructed product depends on the efforts made to ensure the conformance of the finished product to the design and technical requirements prescribed for the product. This ensures quality which in general terms is defined as “The totality of features and characteristics of a product or service, that bears on its ability to satisfy a given need”. In brief quality can be defined as “The degree to which the project fulfills the requirements. Quality Management Quality management is the process of creating and following polices and procedures in order to ensure that a project meets the defined needs that it was intended to meet. In construction processes, the quality of constructed structures has to be properly managed to achieve safe and durable structures. Quality management has the following general attributes: i. Quality Planning ii. Quality Assurance iii. Quality Control iv. Compliance of Non Conformance Report (NCR‟s) v. Quality Audits This paper presents the Quality Management system used for construction of Taunsa Barrage Rehabilitation Project works, for sharing the quality aspects of the project works with our professional community. This presentation can also be considered as a case study. 2. INTRODUCTION Taunsa Barrage is one of the most important diversion structures built across the Indus River and its tributaries. The Barrage serves a gross commanded area of about 2.351 million acres through the Muzaffargarh and D. G. Khan Canals, off – taking from left and right flanks of the Barrage respectively and also diverts water 1 Project Manager, Punjab Barrages Consultants and Associate, National Development Consultants 2 Chief Resident Engineer, Taunsa Barrage Project 3 Principal Quality Engineer, Taunsa Barrage Project 318 Zaidi, Khan, Asad into the Chenab River through the Taunsa Panjad (T -P) link Canal on the left for mitigating serious shortages in Panjnad Canals. In addition to regulation of irrigation supplie s and flood flows, Taunsa Barrage also provides an arterial road bridge, a railway bridge, oil and gas pipelines and EHV transmission lines crossings over Indus River. The barrage soon after its construction in 1958 ran into multiple problems of: i. Tendency of river to revert to its old course on the right with a severe curvilinear approach causing excessive sedimentation in the DG Khan canal; ii. Excessive retrogression of d/s water levels caused:- ripping off skin concrete of the downstream floor damage to friction blocks thereby adversely affecting the hydraulic efficiency of the structure, limitation on pond level; choking and malfunctioning of large number of pressure pipes, i.e. breakdown of subsurface flow monitoring system, and defects in the hoisting mechanism and mechanical installations. Works done under this project were aimed at mitigating the serious threats posed by above elements to the safety of the structure and ensuring sustainability of the canal systems being fed from this Barrage and to provide protection to the other vital national assets 3. THE PROJECT The project comprised two International Competitive Bidding (ICB) Contracts, first Contract was for Civil Works (ICB -01) and 2nd Contract for M&E works (ICB – 02). ICB-01 Contract included: i. Construction of a subsidiary weir (sub-weir). ii. Rehabilitation/strengthening of existing barrage and its components iii. Construction of guide banks iv. Construction of silt excluder v. Construction of a diversion channel vi. Remodeling of D.G. Khan canal Head Regulator vii. Gate Equipment for Sub Weir viii. Remodeling of existing Fish Ladders Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 319 ICB-02 Contract covered M&E works for Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation and Modernization Project financed by the World Bank. It comprised: Renovation of the Barrage gates and hoists and improvements in the operating and control system for the Barrage and canal headworks as under: o Rehabilitation of 31 gates of the main weir, (bay Nos. 31 -61), plus 4 right under sluice gates No. 62 -65 (replacement), plus Gate No. 8 in the navigation bay. o 19 gates for the three canals off taking from the Barrage (Replacement of 7 gates each of D.G. Khan Canal and T.P. Link Canal and rehabilitation of 5 gates of Muzaffargarh canal. Procurement of necessary equipment for operation and maintenance. and Automation of gates operation and communication 4. DEFINITIONS 4.1 Quality Planning Quality planning is basically the process of identifying the quality standards that are relevant to the project and determining how to satisfy them. 4.2 Quality Assurance Quality Assurance constitutes all steps and actions taken and specifications/standards prescribed to set the requirements of the capabilities of the product required for acceptance. 4.3 Quality Control Quality control constitutes the action and steps taken to ensure that the standards and specifications prescribed under quality assurance programme are achieved. Such steps are inspections, field and laboratory tests and submiss ion of necessary reports. 4.4 Non Conformance Reports (NCR) A non conformance report (NCR) is the intimation of the occurrence of non conformance of a product/process with reference to the capability standards set under quality assurance programme which h as to be mitigated by carrying out instructions under quality assurance and rectification of the non conformance. 4.5 Quality Audit Quality audit process constitutes monitoring, reporting and review of quality assurance and control report to assess the ex tent of success of quality assurance / quality control efforts and compliance reports of NCR‟s. 320 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 4.6 Project Quality Management System Taunsa Barrage Rehabilitation Project established and maintained a documented Quality Management System to the requirements of the ISO 9001-2000 Standards. Quality System basically consists of Organization resources; Taunsa Barrage Rehabilitation Project Quality Plan and management procedures; The Supervision Consultant‟s Quality Assurance Program; Approved Specifications; Approved Method Statements and Quality Inspection Plans (QIP) for permanent works Approved Health, Safety and Environment (HSE) Programme Quality Control and Quality Assurance records. The quality management system procedures are listed as Annex-A. 5. REFERENCES AND QUALITY ASSURANCE (QA) STANDARDS 5.1 Standard References Indicated in the Contract Documents for the Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation and Modernization Project Contracts ICB-01 & ICB-02. 5.2 Contract References Employer‟s participation for review, approval, monitoring and other QA activities were indicated in the contract documents. Supervision Consultants participation in review, approval, monitoring and other QA activities is indicated in the Particular Conditions of the Contract and the Contract for Consultancy Services. 5.3 Quality System References For ICB-01 Contract:- i. General Conditions of Contract Part 1 (FIDIC) Clauses 36 & 37. ii. Technical Specifications a. SP-9 Approval of Materials and Equipment. b. SP-10 Contractor‟s Quality Assurance Plan. For ICB-02 Contract i. General Conditions of Contract Part 1 (FIDIC) Clauses 36 & 37. ii. Method of Performing the Work – volume-I of Contract Agreement. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 321 iii. SP-9 Approval of Materials and Equipment. iv. SP-10 Contractor‟s Quality Assurance Plan. v. Technical Specifications items o 1.6 Standards o 1.7 Materials o 1.8 Test of Materials o 1.18 Inspection and Testing o 2.5 Commissioning Tests and Inspection 6. QUALITY PLANS Taunsa Barr age Rehabilitation Project was a large project involving very heavy qualities of earthwork, stones, concrete, sheet piling, regulating gate works and other allied works. Naturally the quality management had a very important role in the sustainability of the project works. To ensure a proper quality management, the Engineer and Contractor both prepared their quality assurance programme and plan respectively and implemented with honesty and zeal. The details of these programmes/plans are too bulky/voluminous to form a part of this paper. However a brief introduction to the contents of Engineer‟s quality assurance plan (EQAP) and construction project quality plan (PQP) appears below and is followed by the actual steps and actions taken for ensuring good quali ty management by honouring the engineer and contractor‟s programme and plan. The project was executed under two Contracts ICB-01 and ICB-02. 7. PROJECT ORGANIZATION The hierarchical interrelationships between the Employer, the Consultants and Contractor are identified in Annex-B. Synthesis of the tasks and responsibilities between staff are defined in the Project Responsibilities Matrix (Annex-C) 7.1 Operative Modalities 7.1.1 General The elements described in the following paragraphs addressed the rol e of the Supervision Consultants in relation to the requirements of the project contracts. 7.2 Management Responsibility The Supervision Consultants being the Engineer were made responsible for Quality Assurance / Control. The Consultants Chief Resident E ngineer was responsible for Quality activities performed in support of the Employer at the site. 322 Zaidi, Khan, Asad The Supervision Consultant‟s QA Specialist provided supervision and support in relation to QA/QC tasks at site. 7.3 Authorization and Project Quality Policy The Employer was authorized to exercise the duties and authorities as owner of the Project. The Supervision Consultant monitored, reviewed and provided a detailed resume of the contractor‟s engineering, procurement, Contract Administration and construction activities during implementation of the project. Major tasks undertaken are as follows: 7.4 Engineering Review the contractor‟s planning documents, data and verify his basis of preparation; Monitor submission of documents and review in a timely m anner the contractor‟s documents and compliance with the contract specifications; Provide timely notice to PMO of events or trends, which could have potential negative impacts on the project and proposed solutions; Be cognizant of and pro -active in continued review of the project for design improvements, which may result in long term benefits including cost reductions, schedule improvements and/or better operatability, maintainability, etc. 7.5 Procurement Respond to any major design or plan chang e requests submitted by the contractor; Attend any model tests or final workshop inspections for the plants to be installed in the project; Monitor procurement and expediting activities performed by the contractor; Witness In-works performance, Commissioning and reliability tests for major items of plant. Assess, approve/reject final test reports. 7.6 Construction Maintain the necessary presence until the site is cleared by the contractor. Develop an effective working relationship with the contractor, so that clear and appropriate lines of communication are established and maintained throughout the construction, commissioning and testing phase of the project; Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 323 Review, comment and monitor the contractor‟s performance with respect to the prescribed procedures, for example: o Project Execution Management Plan, o Traffic Management Plan o Environmental Management Plan. o Canal Closure Programme o Monitor and make the contractor ensure compliance with design specifications and standards. o Communication Plan In order to provide PMO with documentation that shows work was performed in accordance with adequate quality control procedures: Certify on satisfaction the contractor‟s requests for payment with reference to the contract requirement; Review and comment on the contractor‟s. „As Built‟ Documentation before final acceptance; To provide products, which meet the Employer‟s valid requirements on time a management system policy, was implemented by the Engineer with the following objectives: i. Monitor quality compliance with the standards prescribed in the Contract, codes and statutory regulations; ii. Satisfy the appropriate requirements of ISO 9002 Standards; Promote quality and service standards as being the responsibility of each and every employee in accordance with the contractor‟s approved PQP; Establish and maintain a high degree of quality awareness at every level in the Organization, and encourage individual initiative in achieving performance and quality project delivery; Respond in a timely and constructive manner to Contractors quality issues and monitor that appropriate remedial action is taken; Monitor observance of the Project Schedules; Revise the allocated Budgets where necessary and advise the Employer of overruns that may occur due to additional quality requirements for the project; Monitor compliance with safety plan in relation to the establishment of a safe work site in accordance with the approved HSE plan; 324 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 1. Monitor resolution of environmental issues such as: Disposal of waste materials such as oil, rubber tires, batteries, wood cardboard and paper, among others, Implementation of sanitary facilities and disposal of sanitary waste, Availability of potable drinking water, Contamination of off project water sources, Control of dust and noise, Others related to the environments as prescribed in the Environment Management Plan of the project. 2. Monitor training and performance of contractor‟s QA/QC personnel; 3. Monitor and measure quality performance and provide appropriate feed back to relevant employees; 4. Ensure that where quality control and audit process were established, their operation was always supportive of the construction activities while fulfilling their special assurance role; To meet these objectives a systematic method of managing requirements of the contract was established. It was ensured that personnel concerned with quality, safety, productivity, environment and management were fully familiar with the EQAP, PQP and associated procedures. All personnel employed on this project performed their duties in accordance with the requirements of quality plans and in compliance with the Taunsa Barrage Rehabilitation Project QA/QC procedures and any specific project instructions. 7.6.1 Quality Management Representative The contractor with concurrence of the Engineer appointed a Quality Assurance Manager (QAM) as Contractor‟s Representative for the project quality system implementation. The contractor‟s QA Manager was represented and supported by Field Engineers/ Inspectors who assumed responsibilities in his temporary absence or when overtime or shift work was involved. Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer interfaced directly with the Contractor‟s QAM for QA issues that developed, and generated reports to keep PM informed of major issues and trends that developed and needs for correction through periodical reports. 7.7 Design Control The basic, conceptual, tender level and detailed design of all the comp onent structures was done by the Consultants design office at Lahore and all the Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 325 construction drawings were also prepared and issued for construction from Lahore. Necessary quality standards were maintained. However some supplementary and shop drawings e tc were initiated prepared by the contractor and submitted to the Engineer for approval. Supervision Consultant‟s Project Manager at Lahore reviewed all submittals by the contractor relating to the design and construction activities, as required for compliance with the applicable technical standards and Employer‟s Requirements for the Taunsa barrage Rehabilitation Project. Principal submittal categories are: Conceptual Design: Construction Schedule, General layout Drawings of major project features, Project Procedures manual, Project Quality Assurance Manual Detailed Design / Drawings Construction Drawings, Shop Drawings, Fabrication drawings, Method Statements, Catalogue clips. During Construction Progress reports and Schedule updates, Monitor inspection and documentation of construction activities: Excavation, placement of fill, concrete work, foundation preparation and treatment, erection and testing of electrical and mechanical equipment, Approve milestones for the purposes of payment, Monitor quality control testing and results, Approve sources of materials, Approve waste disposal locations, Approve details for quality control of water Approve outline of Environmental Management plan and monitor implementation, Organize and document reports of weather station, Project signs, Monitor HSE arrangements 326 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Project Completion Monitor and certify Substantial Completion, Approve request for moving out of site and final cleanup, Final Inspection and certification of final completion, Review closeout submittals, Review Taking over submittals. 7.8 Document and Data Control Supervision Consultant monitored implementation of the document and data control procedures for the project established in the Project Quality Plan, and appropriate control of its own documents, data and correspondence based on the specific coding established for the project. 7.9 Construction Process Control Supervision Consultants‟ chief Resident Engineer and assigned st aff at site monitored implementation of the EQAP, during the different stages of construction in accordance with the approved and updated PQP & PIP. It was ensured that the contractor‟s operations personnel are thoroughly aware and committed to the quality requirements involved in each part of the work and that the appropriate hold points for verification of the QC and testing personnel are being followed, as established in the approved applicable specifications, work method statements and QIPs. Supervision Consultant‟s staff was fully involved during construction as part of the Quality Assurance process, in addition to QA and QC activities by the Contractor, for verification that appropriate quality related procedures are implemented. The Consultant‟s Chi ef Resident Engineer interfaced closely with the Contractor‟s QA Manager, as needed, in the execution of the work and the Employer was kept informed of the quality of the work. The Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer and staff performed the following main tasks: i. Review of the Construction Schedule and monthly evaluation of physical, economic and financial progress against the established schedule and budgets; ii. Attend weekly meetings with the Contractor regarding progress of the work; iii. Monitor the Quality of all the Permanent Works and verification of compliance with the Employer‟s Technical Requirements, Drawings, Specifications, Work Method Statements and that the work is carried out by the Contractor in a healthy, safe and appr opriate manner in accordance with highest international engineering standards and practices; Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 327 iv. Prepare and issue Non Conformance Report (NCR) to Contractor when necessary; v. Monitor implementation of QC procedures and test results and quality of work manship and that the materials used in the Works are in accordance with the Contract requirements, including environmental protection requirements; vi. Ensure that the equipment and staff provided and used by the Contractor are adequate to construct the W orks and maintain the program; vii. Participate in field verification activities and monitor results of testing related to Taking -Over Certificate Performance Certificate and Final Acceptance of the Works. viii. Supervision Consultant‟s Resident Staff prepared the following reports as follows: a. Daily reports of the work performed by the Contractor at each location. Reports were submitted to the Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer on the following day and remained in the project files as documentation for the project. The daily reports included information regarding resources used and work performed at each location, and comments regarding quality measures and Contractor‟s personnel observed and any difficulties encountered. b. A weekly report was prepared by the Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer with respect to progress and other quality related issues and sent by email or fax to the Supervision Consultant‟s Project Manager at Lahore, with copy to the Employer. The report included weekly summary of progress versus weekly schedule presented by the Contractor and summary of the quality control testing results presented by the Contractor‟s quality control unit. c. The monthly report summarized the activities performed by th e Contractor in each area, progress of the work with respect to the approved schedule and summary of the quality attained on the project during each period, including actions taken to recover delays and status of resolution of NCR and quality control summaries. 7.10. Inspection and Testing A specific Project Procedure “Inspection and Testing” was developed for this project and included in the Contractor‟s PQP. 328 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Supervision Consultant‟s resident staff at the site ensured that appropriate Quality Control Plans – QCP, Operating Procedures (Method Statements) and work instructions were established to define the responsibilities and the methods necessary to carry out inspection and tests for verification of conformance of the works to the requirements and were known to the contractor‟s operations personnel. All the inspectors and testing process was not only witnessed by the Engineer‟s staff, all the tests were performed jointly by the quality staff of engineer and contractor in a common laboratory. Conformance was verified through the QCP and documented inspection and testing of: i. Goods, equipment, materials purchased or supplied by the Contractor received at Site before incorporating permanent works. ii. Verification, identification and recording of infor mation in order to allow the immediate recall and replacement in the event of non compliance to specified requirements; iii. Materials and products, during the construction activities (in -process), according to the quality control plans. The Contractor‟s QC staff provided the Supervision Consultant‟s staff with weekly and monthly summaries of QC test results on concrete and earthwork materials, including statistical controls, tables and graphs of test results. Supervision Consultant‟s staff had full access to all the QC testing information as required for quality audits. The Contractor presented weekly and monthly summaries of the materials test results, which were discussed in weekly meetings held by Supervision Consultant‟s Resident Staff with contractor‟ s QA/QC personnel. Two types of Quality Control and Quality Assurance reports were presented by the Contractor to the Supervision Consultant‟s resident staff as follows: a. Monthly Quality Control and Quality Assurance Reports: The Contractor provided a written quality control and quality assurance report each month using summary formats decided upon to adequately document the quality control and quality assurance process. b. Periodic Quality Control and Quality Assurance Reports: The Contractor also pr epared written quality control and quality assurance reports at the end of each quarter; iv. The Employer with support from the Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer reviewed the monthly reports of test results presented by the Contractors QC s taff. He also monitored testing performed in the field by the QC staff to verify that they were following acceptable standard practices. He monitored that test results were reported timely and that appropriate forms were used to record all inspection and/ or testing activity and that records of inspections and Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 329 testing of the works were collected, filed and maintained by the Contractor‟s QAM in the Site Office and in the Laboratory. 7.10.1. Control of Inspection, Measuring & Test Equipment (IMTE) A speci fic Project Procedure, “Inspection, Measuring and Test Equipment Control”, was developed for the Project as part of the PQP. Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer through his quality control staff monitored implementation of these procedures as approved and in accordance with the established standard practice. He ensured that the testing equipment was calibrated regularly and that the Checks/ Calibrations were performed by skilled personnel of QC staff. 7.10.2. Inspection and Test Status Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer ensured that the inspection and test status of each part of the work were identified by suitable means, indicating the conformance or non -conformance of the product with regard to inspection and test performed, as established in the PQP. 7.11. Control of NCR Supervision Consultants Chief Resident Engineer monitored Contractor‟s activities to verify that corrective actions were taken to resolve quality issues in accordance with the procedures indicated in the PQP . A specific Project Procedure, “Control of Non-Conformances” developed and implemented. Two types of NCR were considered: i. Management System NCRs, regarding deficiencies in the implementation/ application of the procedures; ii. NCRs related to products, materials, equipment, sections of work etc. The NCRs were identified by the Consultant‟s QA/QC staff, during the internal System Inspection and Audits. Non conformances were notified to the Contractor‟s QA Manager, who reported directly to the Contractors Project Manager supported with the technical staff‟s investigation report on the potential problems and proposed solutions to resolve the situation in each case. The Supervision Consultants reviewed the proposed solutions to NCRs and ensured that app ropriate actions were implemented to correct the deficiencies and to prevent their recurrence. 7.11.1. Corrective and Preventive Actions Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer ensured that the corrective and preventive actions for non conforma nces were implemented and recorded in accordance with the approved PQP. 7.11.2. Handling, Storage, Packaging, Preservation and Delivery Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer ensured that adequate care was exercised by the contractor to contro l the activities related to handling, 330 Zaidi, Khan, Asad storage and preservation of the materials/ products at the Site in order to prevent damages or deteriorations and to avoid dispatch of non conforming materials from the storage areas. 7.12 Control of Quality Records A quality record is an item of objective evidence generated during the construction process on a project which demonstrates that the specified quality has been achieved for that work activity to which the record relates. A documented procedure is prepared to ensure that the identification, collation, indexing, access, filing, storage, retrieval, maintenance and disposition of quality records is undertaken at all project stations/offices. Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer ensured that the Contractor‟s personnel used adequate care for the management (identification, collection, record, and maintenance) of the quality records originated by the QA/QC personnel or by external testing units. The Project Quality records and Internal/ external aud it reports were filed in the Site office and summaries and reports were prepared in accordance with acceptable standard practice to demonstrate conformance to the Contract Specifications and effective operation of the Quality System. 7.13. Personnel Training and Management / Competency, Awareness for Training The Project Manager ensured that the following were implemented: Determine the necessary competence for personnel performing work affecting quality; Provide training for satisfying these requirements; Evaluate effectiveness of the training given at suitable intervals; Ensure that all personnel of the Consultant are aware of the relevance and importance of their actions for achieving quality objectives; and Maintain records of educati on, training, skills and experience of all personnel. Documented Procedures were prepared for the foregoing items. Supervision Consultant‟s Resident Engineer managed implementation of the training program for all personnel performing activities affecting quality by the Contractor. 7.14. Statistical Techniques Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer reviewed the Contractors QA/QC reports, summarized results of testing using statistical evaluation of the processes/ works, materials supplied, NCR, m aterials incorporated in the works in accordance with acceptable standard practice. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 331 The concrete manual lays down a confidence level of 85% on quality tests. Considering the importance, sensitivity and complexity of the project, a 100% confidence limit w as prescribed and ensured. In the case of uncertainties, core testing and NDE method were resorted too. 7.15. Internal Quality Audits The Consultant prepares a documented Procedure for the conduct of Internal Quality Audits, at planned intervals, by the Q uality System Manager! Quality Assurance Engineer to verify that all activities in various departments of the Consultants are being carried out in accordance with the QMS and approved guidelines and procedures. Any deviations and nonconformities are identi fied and suitable Corrective Action Requests (CARs) are raised. An Audit Report is prepared, signed, and distributed to all concerned. After a reasonable interval of time the QSM/QAE makes a follow-up visit to verify that the required corrective actions an d preventive actions were taken by the concerned department/section. Similarly, periodic Quality Audits of the Contractor’s organization are carried out to verify that his work activities are all in compliance with the Contract Specifications, approved Met hod Statements and Procedures and his own Project Quality Assurance Plan duly approved by the Consultant. 7.16. Equipment / Plants Management Supervision Consultant‟s Chief Resident Engineer monitored Contractor‟s implementation of equipment maintenance program and efficiency of availability of the equipment for the project work and required corrective actions and gave specific advice to the Contractor as needed. 8. SOURCE APPROVALS 8.1 For Civil Works The first step in the quality assurance/control (QA/QC) activities exercised on the project was the source approval of the materials intended to be used on the project by the Contractor. Source approval was granted for construction materials including steel reinforcement, aggregates, stone, cement, PVC wa ter stops, and admixtures etc on the basis of prescribed tests, factory capabilities and will tests conducted by factory laboratory. After the source approval, regular tests were conducted in the laboratory established at the site for aggregates, concrete, bricks. For materials such as cement, steel reinforcement, samples were taken periodically from the consignments delivered at site as provided in the technical specifications of the project. These materials were got tested from Central Materials Testing Laboratory (CMTL) WAPDA, University of Engineering & Technology, Lahore, PITAC, Lahore and Deptt of earth sciences Punjab University Lahore. List of source approvals is presented in the following Table. 332 Zaidi, Khan, Asad SOURCE APPROVAL OF CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS FOR CIVIL WORKS S.# Material Approved Source /Name of the Supplier 1 Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) Maple Leaf, Askari, D.G Khan, Fauji, Kohat and Bestway Cement Factories 2 Fine & Coarse Aggregates Sakhi Sarwar, Sanghar and Kohar Quarries, DG Khan District 3 Steel Reinforcement 1. M/S Fazal Steel (PVT) Ltd, Islamabad 2. M/S Pak Steel, Islamabad 4 PVC Water Stops M/S Decora Industries, Lahore 5 Admixtures for Concrete Water Reducing Agent (SIKA) Curing Compound (SIKA) Super Plasticizer (SIKA) Non Shrink Grout Joint Filler Bonding Compound Air Entraining Agents M/S Imporient Chemical (PVT) Ltd, Lahore (SIKA Distributors) and FosRoc 6 Interlocks Sealants(Igas-R Black) for Sheet Piles M/S Imporient Chemical (PVT) Ltd, Lahore (SIKA Distributors) 7 PVC Water Stops M/s Khawaja Rubber Store, Lahore 8 Vibrating wire piezometer M/s Roctest, Canada 9 Epoxy for Rawl Bolts (Lokfix) M/s FOSROC, USA through Local Distributors 10 Joint Sealant for Construction Joints (Thioflex 600) M/S FOSROC, USA through Local Distributors 11 Sheet Piles Interlocks Sealant (BELTAN) M/S ARCELOR, 12 Joint Filler M/s Mughal Brothers 13 Granulated Ground Slag Thatta Cement Company, Attock Cement and Zeel Pak Cement factories 14 Slag Cement Thatta Cement Company 15 Filter Blanket Material Zinda Pir Quarry 16 Steel Reinforcement M/s Hyundai Corporation Korea (INI Steel Company, Pohang) Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 333 9. FREQUENCY OF TESTS FOR CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS PRESCRIBED FOR QUALITY ASSURANCE 9.1 For Civil Works The testing frequency for various construc tion materials prescribed and used under the Project are contained in the following tables: TESTING FREQUENCY FOR SOILS/EARTHWORK Sr. No. Test Designation Testing Frequency 1 Grain Size Analysis / Gradation Tests ASTM C-136 & D-422 1 per 10,000 cft 2 Hydrometer ASTM D-442 1 per 50,000 cft 3 Liquid Limit ASTM D-4318 1 per 50,000 cft 4 Plastic Limit ASTM D-4318 1 per 50,000 cft 5 Shrinkage Limit ASTM D-427 1 per 50,000 cft 6 Specific Gravity ASTM D-854 1 per 50,000 cft 7 Moisture Density Relationship ASTM D-1557 1 per 50,000 cft 8 Moisture Density Relationship ASTM D-698 1 per 50,000 cft 9 Field Density: Compacted Fill ASTM D-1556 1 per 20,000 cft 10 Field Density: Structural Back fill ASTM D-1556 1 per 2,000 cft 11 Field Density: Gravel Base ASTM D-1556 1 per 5,000 cft 12 Relative Dry Density ASTM D-4253 and D- 4254 1 per 5,000 cft TESTING FREQUENCY FOR CEMENT Sr. No. Test Designation Testing Frequency 1 Compressive Strength ASTM C 348 and C 349 1 per 200 tons or 1 per month if consumption is < 200 tons 2 Initial and Final Setting Time (on Pure Paste) ASTM C 191 1 per 200 tons or 1 per month if consumption is < 200 tons 3 Autoclave Expansion ASTM C 151 1 per 200 tons or 1 per month if consumption is < 200 tons 4 Blaine‟s Specific Surface Area ASTM C 204 1 per 200 tons or 1 per month if consumption is < 200 tons 5 Chemical Analysis ASTM C 114 1 per 1000 tons or 1 after 3 months if consumption is < 1000 tons 334 Zaidi, Khan, Asad TESTING FREQUENCY FOR STEEL REINFORCEMENT For each delivery of steel the supplier‟s certificate was submitted. In addition six (6) samples per diameter were taken at random for determining the mechanical properties for a given lot or for 200 ton if the lot exceeded 200 tons. of the same type and from the same factory/source. If any characteristic gave an unsatisfactory result, a new set of six (6) samples from the same lot or batch was put to tests on the characteristic in question. If the results of the new tests were all satisfactory, the reinforcing bars were accepted. If this was not the case, the bars were considered defective and were not allowed to be incorporated in the project works. Sr. # Tests Designation 1 Size and weight ASTM A 615 2 Elongation ASTM A 615 3 Bending test ASTM A 615 4 Tensile strength and yield strength ASTM A 615 TESTING FREQUENCY FOR FINE AGGREGATE Sr. No. Test Designation Testing Frequency 1 Sieve Analysis ASTM C-136 1 for 5,000 cft 2 Materials Passing # 200 Sieve ASTM C-117 1 for 5,000 cft 3 Unit Weight ASTM C-29 1 for 10,000 cft 4 Specific Gravity ASTM C-128 1 for 10,000cft 5 Absorption ASTM C-128 1 for 10,000cft 6 Moisture Content ASTM C-566 1 for 10,000 cft 7 Soundness ASTM C-88 1 for 50,000 cft 8 Clay Lumps & Friable Particles ASTM C-142 1 for 20,000 cft 9 Sand Equivalent ASTM C-2419 1 for 20,000 cft 10 Organic Impurities ASTM C-40 5 per source for initial approval. 1 per month after approval per source or 50,000cft 11 Light Weight Particles ASTM C-123 1 for 50,000 cft Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 335 Sr. No. Test Designation Testing Frequency 12 Petrographic Analysis ASTM C-295 3 no. per source for initial approval. Once every 3 months after approval per source if and as required by the Engineer 13 Mortar Bar Test for Potential Alkali Silica Reactivity ASTM C-227 As required by the Engineer. TESTING FREQUENCY FOR COARSE AGGREGATE Sr. No. Test Designation Testing Frequency 1 Sieve Analysis ASTM C-136 1 for 5,000 cft 2 Materials Passing # 200 Sieve ASTM C-117 1 for 5,000 cft 3 Unit Weight ASTM C-29 1 for 10,000 cft 4 Specific Gravity ASTM C-127 1 for 10,000cft 5 Absorption ASTM C-127 1 for 10,000cft 6 Moisture Content ASTM C-566 1 for 5,000 cft 7 Soundness ASTM C-88 1 for 50,000 cft 8 Clay Lumps & Friable Particles ASTM C-142 1 for 50,000 cft 9 Los Angeles Abrasion ASTM C-131 1 for 20,000 cft 10 Light Weight Particles ASTM C-123 1 for 50,000 cft 11 Petrographic Analysis ASTM C-295 3 no. per source for initial approval. Once every 3 months after approval per source if and as required by the Engineer. 12 Mortar Bar Test for Potential Alkali SILICA Reactivity ASTM C-227 As required by the Engineer. 336 Zaidi, Khan, Asad TESTING FREQUENCY FOR CONCRETE Compressive Strength ASTM C-39 1 for 2,000 cft per class per batch plant Slump ASTM C-143 1 for 2,000 cft per class per batch plant Air Content ASTM C-231 1 for 2,000 cft per class per batch plant Temperature ASTM C-1064 1 for 2,000 cft per class per batch plant Field Density ASTM C-138 1 for 2,000 cft per class per batch plant A set of minimum three cylinders was moulded from each pour of concrete irrespective of the above volumes and tested at prescribed periods. TESTING FREQUENCY FOR ADMIXTURES Air Entrainment ASTM C-260 As required Admixtures (water reducing) ASTM C-494 As required Admixtures plasticizers/ retarders, accelerators ASTM C-494 As required Curing Compound ASTM C-309 As required 9.2 For Mechanical and Electrical Works Technical Specifications of the project prescribed that materials shall be new and of first class quality, suitable for the purpose, free from defects and imperfections, and of the grades and types listed in the Contract Agreement, or their equivalents. However, while selecting the materials the Contractor shall keep in view the water analysis results and may propose materials having better qualities to resist the chemicals present in water. Certified material test reports were furnished in triplicate to the Engineer as soon as possible after the tests were made. The test certificate identified the component for which the material was to be used and contained all information necessary to verify compliance with the Specifications. M/s China National Electric Wire & Cable Import & Export Corporation (CCC) with Jiajiang Hydraulic Machinery Works (JHMW) as their nominated sub contractor were allotted the ICB-02 contract for rehabilitation and mode rnization of gates. According to the Contract, items manufactured by the Contractor had to under go a pre-shipment inspection by the Employer‟s Representative. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 337 9.2.1 Jiajiang Hydraulic Machinery Works As a specialized hydroelectric equipment manufacture r in China, JHWM has contracted with over 30 national hydro -power projects of large to medium size in China including three gorges dam. The Factory possesses "CERTIFICATE OF CONFORMITY OF QUALITY SYSTEM CERTIFICATION' according to STANDARD "GB/T 19001-1994 IDT IS09001-1994". JHMW is also an international supplier of gate equipment and cranes, The JHMW has successfully completed following International Contracts. Masjed Hydropower Project in Iran, 1997-1999; Pak Phanang Water Conserveyed in Thailand1995-1997. Ghazi Barotha Hydropower Project. Pakistan 1997-2002. AITEK dam of SYNAS Project in Kazakhstan, 2002-2004. Merowe dam in Sudan, 2004 to date. Myanmar Paunglaung HPP, 1999-2002 Quality Policy of JHMW To satisfy customer with every product; To abide by standards and enforce principles rigorously; To upgrade all members' quality is crucial to quality improvement. 1. Testing at Source As part of QA arrangement following three pre -shipment inspection visits to JHMW in Sichuan Province of China were made by project teams. i. November 07 to 12, 2006 ii. January 09 to 19, 2007 iii. July 12 to 20, 2008 A list of items inspected during these visits is given below i. Items inspected during first visit a. Gate leaf for under sluices gate (1) b. Embedded parts for Bulkhead gate for # 62 under sluice gate (1) c. Embedded parts for Bulkhead gate for standard weir gate (1) d. Side beam of weir gate (1) e. Weir gate roller guard details (1) f. Slide sealing place details for weir gate (1) g. Under sluice gate roller guard details (1) 338 Zaidi, Khan, Asad h. Under sluice gate rocker assembly (1) i. T.P. Link fixed wheel gate (1) j. Under sluice gate roller train detail (1) ii. Items inspected during third visit were mainly related to electrical systems and other equipments. Being too large in number, details are not being included. a. Hoist Assembly for under sluice gates (1) b. Roller Trains (6) c. Rocker Assembly (1) iii. Items inspected during third visit were mainly related to electrical systems and other equipments. Being to large in number, details are not being included. Following Pre-shipment Inspection tests were conducted: Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 339 Pre-shipment Inspection Tests ICB-02 contractor has conducted following Inspection test in Jiajiang (JHMW), China. Sr.No Carried out Date Results 1 T.P Link Canal Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 2-17 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 67-76 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 111-115 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 158-160 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 165-168 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 174-176 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 206-211 End beam/gate leaves Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 3-19 Roller train Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 51-53 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 79-80 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 87-109 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 117-121 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 2007.01.06 Pass Page 197-206 2 T.P Link Canal Gate Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 46-62 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 120-141 2006.11.08 2006.11.08 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 215-222 Hoist Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 264-295 End beam/gate leaves Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 33-49 Roller train Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 60-77 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 128-149 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 216-222 Hoist Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 264-307 3 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 63-64 Undersluice Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 142-156 Rubber Sealing Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 201-204 Hoist Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 301-383 Weir Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 153-195 Rubber Sealing Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 150-152 Hoist Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 312-425 4 End beam/gate leaves Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 20-30 Roller train Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 54-58 Rocker Assembly Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 81-85 Roller guard Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 111-114 Side sealing plate Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 122-126 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 207-213 Hoist Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 243-257 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 18-38 Gate leaves Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 77-100 Roller train Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 116-118 Rocker Assembly Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 161-163 Roller guard Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 169-171 Side sealing plate Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 177-179 Guide frame for bulk head gate Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 209-211 Hoist Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 231-244 5 Hoist of Undersluice Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 225-229 Hoist of Weir Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page226-230 6 Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 41-45 Undersluice Gates Gate leaves Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 Pass Page 101-109 Guide frame for bulk head gate Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 212-214 Weir Gates End beam/gate leaves Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 31-32 Guide frame for bulk head gate Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.08 2007.01.06 Pass Page 214-215 7 Hoist of Weir Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 259-262 T.P Link Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2006.11.07 Pass Page 39-40 Hoist of Undersluice Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China 2007.01.07 Pass Page 260-262 Performance Inspection Anti-corrosion Inspection Roller guard/Side sealing plate /Rocker Assembly Weir Gates T.P Link Canal Gate Purchased Products Certificate and test report Weir Gates Material Inspection Welding Inspection Undersluice Gates Weir Gates Undersluice Gates Manufaturer/Jiajiang, China Pass Description of Inspection Remark Rocker Assembly Roller guard Roller train Undersluice Gates Dimension Inspection Heat treatment Inspection Rocker Assembly Roller guard Side sealing plate T.P Link Canal Gate Guide frame for bulk head gate T.P Link Canal Gate Guide frame for bulk head gate Page 181-200 Guide frame for bulk head gate Gate leaves/Roller train Guide frame for bulk head gate Roller guard/Side sealing plate /Rocker Assembly Side sealing plate Guide frame for bulk head gate Gate leaves 340 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 10. QUALITY CONTROL DATA FOR CIVIL WORKS 10.1 Quality Control Manual To support and stream line/facilitate t he implementation of quality control activities, the project consultants prepared a Quality Control Manual and issued it for use by the supervisory staff on September 19, 2005, as the quality of constructed project structures had to be maintained to the pr escribed Quality Assurance standards to achieve safety and durability of the constructed works. This manual was prepared with an aim to provide a brief and handy compendium of technical provisions for construction of civil works under the project along wi th some explanatory additions, for reference and use by the supervisory staff who were expected to keep this manual with them, when on duty, which was possible because of its small volume. However, contents of this manual were only for guidance and were n ot to vitiate the Contract provisions original or amended, i.e. this manual was not to be considered as legal instrument. The inspection personnel were advised to keep the following famous quotes in view while performing their duties. A structure is as strong as its weakest point or for that matter as eye - leasing as its most ugly part. A job is as good or as bad as the consciousness or lousiness of the craftsman doing it. A lousy inspector gets a lousy job. 10.2 Summary of Quality Tests Following Table depicts an abstract of tests conducted on various construction materials used for project works, jointly by the quality staff of the Engineer and the Contractor in the field and a common laboratories. Test Conducted in Field Laboratory Sr. # Tests Actually conducted No. Required 1 Gradation of Coarse Aggregate 1186 1012 2 Gradation of Fine Aggregate 587 518 3 Unit Weight of Coarse Aggregate 680 516 4 Unit Weight of Fine Aggregate 449 324 5 Sp. Gravity of Coarse Aggregate 537 494 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 341 Test Conducted in Field Laboratory Sr. # Tests Actually conducted No. Required 6 Sp. Gravity of Fine Aggregate 329 278 7 Sand Equivalent 370 329 8 Los Angles Abrasion 410 292 9 Absorption of Coarse Aggregate 537 494 10 Absorption of Fine Aggregate 329 278 11 Brick Testing 214 As per Requirement 12 Cylinder Testing 31593 31050 13 Cylinder Casting 32256 31800 14 Soundness of Coarse Aggregate 63 85 15 Soundness of Fine Aggregate 69 66 16 Atterberg Limits 71 As per Requirement 17 Temperature 9182 9106 18 Slump of Concrete 8084 8007 19 Cylinder Moulding 32592 31800 20 Field Density/Compaction Tests 3986 As per Requirement 342 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 10.3 Weather Data TAUNSA BARRAGE EMERGENCY REHABILITATION AND MODERNIZATION PROJECT MONTHLY WEATHER REPORT (A SAMPLE PAGE) Temperature Sr. No. Date Max (Co) Min (Co) Weather Condition Humidity % Remarks 1 1-Apr-2007 36 17 Sunny 66 2 2-Apr-2007 35 19 Sunny 87 3 3-Apr-2007 37 18 Rainy 89 4 4-Apr-2007 35 18 Rainy 87 5 5-Apr-2007 37 20 Rainy 88 6 6-Apr-2007 37 18 Sunny 86 7 7-Apr-2007 38 22 Sunny 74 8 8-Apr-2007 37 22 Sunny 76 9 9-Apr-2007 40 21 Cloudy/Sunny 87 10 10-Apr-2007 42 21 Sunny 85 11 11-Apr-2007 44 22 Sunny 74 12 12-Apr-2007 44 22 Fog, Clear 84 13 13-Apr-2007 43 24 Fog, Clear 87 14 14-Apr-2007 46 24 Sunny 74 15 15-Apr-2007 46 28 Sunny 74 16 16-Apr-2007 47 29 Sunny 78 17 17-Apr-2007 45 23 Sunny 74 18 18-Apr-2007 41 24 Sunny 80 Max. Temp. Co: Min. Temp. Co: Average Temp. Co: 19 19-Apr-2007 42 24 Sunny 86 20 20-Apr-2007 44 24 Sunny 81 49 17 33 21 21-Apr-2007 45 24 Sunny 83 22 22-Apr-2007 46 25 Sunny 79 23 23-Apr-2007 44 25 Sunny 82 24 24-Apr-2007 46 23 Fog, Clear 76 25 25-Apr-2007 47 25 Sunny 80 26 26-Apr-2007 49 22 Fog, Clear 83 27 27-Apr-2007 48 25 Sunny 86 28 28-Apr-2007 49 22 Fog, Clear 89 29 29-Apr-2007 49 25 Sunny 93 30 30-Apr-2007 48 27 Sunny 91 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 343 10.4 Production of Concrete April 2007 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 45,000 1-Apr-07 2-Apr-07 3-Apr-07 4-Apr-07 5-Apr-07 6-Apr-07 7-Apr-07 8-Apr-07 9-Apr-07 10-Apr-07 11-Apr-07 12-Apr-07 13-Apr-07 14-Apr-07 15-Apr-07 16-Apr-07 17-Apr-07 18-Apr-07 19-Apr-07 20-Apr-07 21-Apr-07 22-Apr-07 23-Apr-07 24-Apr-07 25-Apr-07 26-Apr-07 27-Apr-07 28-Apr-07 29-Apr-07 30-Apr-07 Days Production in CFT Plant # 1 Plant # 2 Plant # 3 May 2007 0 8,545 17,091 25,636 34,182 42,727 51,273 59,818 1-May-07 2-May-07 3-May-07 4-May-07 5-May-07 6-May-07 7-May-07 8-May-07 9-May-07 10-May-07 11-May-07 12-May-07 13-May-07 14-May-07 15-May-07 16-May-07 17-May-07 18-May-07 19-May-07 20-May-07 21-May-07 22-May-07 23-May-07 24-May-07 25-May-07 26-May-07 27-May-07 28-May-07 29-May-07 30-May-07 31-May-07 Days Production in CFT Plant # 1 Plant # 2 Plant # 3 June 2007 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 45,000 1-Jun-07 2-Jun-07 3-Jun-07 4-Jun-07 5-Jun-07 6-Jun-07 7-Jun-07 8-Jun-07 9-Jun-07 10-Jun-07 11-Jun-07 12-Jun-07 13-Jun-07 14-Jun-07 15-Jun-07 16-Jun-07 17-Jun-07 18-Jun-07 19-Jun-07 20-Jun-07 21-Jun-07 22-Jun-07 23-Jun-07 24-Jun-07 25-Jun-07 26-Jun-07 27-Jun-07 28-Jun-07 29-Jun-07 30-Jun-07 Days Production in CFT Plant # 1 Plant # 2 Plant # 3 344 Zaidi, Khan, Asad The sample histograms shown above, present the monthly production of batching plants during the quarter Apr - Jun 2007. The total production of three Batching plants during the quarter (April to June 2007) stood at 3,025,514 Cft. The maximum daily production of three batching pl ants was recorded 64,777Cft on 19 May, 2007. Average daily production of these plants was 33,740 cft. The above record is for a sample quarter. Similar records were produced and are available for the whole construction period. 10.5 Tests Conducted on concrete Sample data sheets of cylinder tests conducted on various grades/types of concrete used for construction of project follow: 10.6 Results of Tests Conducted on Soil for Earthwork Excavation and Filling Sample data sheet for Field Density Test Results at various locations are presented below April 2007 FDD g/cc % M.C MDD g/cc % OMC Obtd. Reqd. 2/4/2007 1.596 11.7 1.75 13.6 91.2 90 2/4/2007 1.586 10.9 1.75 13.6 90.6 90 2/4/2007 1.612 12.8 1.75 13.6 92.1 90 31/03/07 1.609 11 1.75 13.6 92 90 31/03/07 1.58 10 1.75 13.6 90.3 90 31/03/07 1.469 10 1.75 13.6 83.9 90 1/4/2007 1.635 13.2 1.75 13.6 93.4 90 1/4/2007 1.593 11.4 1.75 13.6 91 90 1/4/2007 1.607 12.6 1.75 13.6 91.8 90 1/4/2007 1.618 14.2 1.75 13.6 92.5 90 1/4/2007 1.629 13.4 1.75 13.6 93.1 90 1/4/2007 1.661 12 1.75 13.6 94.8 90 1/4/2007 1.624 13.4 1.75 13.6 92.8 90 1/4/2007 1.634 11.2 1.75 13.6 93.4 90 2/4/2007 1.546 8.9 1.75 13.6 88.3 90 2/4/2007 1.547 10.7 1.75 13.6 88.4 90 2/4/2007 1.567 15.7 1.75 13.6 89.5 90 2/4/2007 1.609 12.4 1.75 13.6 91.9 90 2/4/2007 1.463 18.9 1.75 13.6 83.6 90 2/4/2007 1.543 15.7 1.75 13.6 88.2 90 2/4/2007 1.582 17 1.75 13.6 90.4 90 2/4/2007 1.61 14.3 1.75 13.6 92 90 2/4/2007 1.606 13.4 1.75 13.6 91.8 90 2/4/2007 1.544 16.4 1.75 13.6 88.2 90 2/4/2007 1.533 10.8 1.75 13.6 87.6 90 2/4/2007 1.474 16.4 1.75 13.6 84.2 90 2/4/2007 1.506 14.2 1.75 13.6 86.1 90 3/4/2007 1.549 11 1.75 13.6 88.5 90 3/4/2007 1.503 12 1.75 13.6 85.9 90 3/4/2007 1.515 12.4 1.75 13.6 86.5 90 3/4/2007 1.442 11 1.75 13.6 82.4 90 3/4/2007 1.447 16 1.75 13.6 82.7 90 3/4/2007 1.615 12.7 1.75 13.6 92.3 90 3/4/2007 1.605 11.9 1.75 13.6 91.7 90 3/4/2007 1.631 14.6 1.75 13.6 93.2 90 3/4/2007 1.612 13.2 1.75 13.6 92.1 90 3/4/2007 1.597 16.6 1.75 13.6 91 90 3/4/2007 1.643 13.4 1.75 13.6 94 90Panel B Sand Pass507 2743 2853 Final Panel C D/S Sheet Piles Sand Pass 506 2193 2233 Final Panel A Sand Pass 505 2233 2380 Final Panel A Sand Pass 504 2233 2380 Final Panel C D/S Sheet Piles Sand Pass 503 2763 2843 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 502 2763 2843 Final Panel A Sand Pass 501 2453 2520 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 500 2446 2523 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 499 2446 2523 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 498 2446 2523 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 497 2446 2523 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 496 2453 2513 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 495 2453 2513 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 494 2453 2513 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 493 2453 2513 Final Panel F Sand Pass 492 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Pass 491 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Fail 490 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Pass 489 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Pass 488 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Fail 487 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Fail 486 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Pass 485 2173 2233 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 484 2173 2233 Final Panel F Sand Fail 483 2383 2453 Final Panel C Flat Portion Sand Pass 482 2383 2453 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 481 2313 2380 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 480 2313 2380 Final Panel C Flat Portion Sand Pass 479 2383 2454 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 478 2383 2454 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 477 2383 2454 Final Panel C Slope Sand Fail 476 2383 2454 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 475 2383 2453 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 474 2383 2453 Final Panel C Slope Sand Pass 473 2383 2453 Final Panel C Flat Portion Sand Pass 472 2233 2313 Final Panel C Flat Portion Sand Pass 471 2233 2313 Final 470 2233 2313 Final Panel C Flat Portion Sand Pass CompactionLaboratory RemarksLayer # Location Description of Soil Field SUMMARY OF FIELD DENSITY TESTS FOR SUB-WEIR LEFT SIDE Date Area Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Sr. No. PBC ToFrom Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 345 June 2007 FDD g/cc % M.C MDD g/cc % OMC Obtd. Reqd. 1/6/2007 1.605 13.9 1.729 13.6 92.6 90 1/6/2007 1.624 14.2 1.729 13.6 93.7 90 1/6/2007 1.612 13 1.729 13.6 93 90 1/6/2007 1.584 13 1.729 14.2 91.6 90 1/6/2007 1.611 14.2 1.729 14.2 93.2 90 1/6/2007 1.628 16 1.729 14.2 94.2 90 1/6/2007 1.618 14 1.729 14.2 93.6 90 2/6/2007 1.584 13 1.714 13.8 92.4 90 2/6/2007 1.611 14.2 1.714 13.8 94.4 90 3/6/2007 1.629 13 1.734 13.6 94 90 3/6/2007 1.586 13 1.734 13.6 91.5 90 3/6/2007 1.612 13.5 1.734 13.6 93 90 3/6/2007 1.628 12.4 1.729 14.2 94.2 90 3/6/2007 1.588 14.8 1.729 14.2 91.9 90 3/6/2007 1.485 11 1.729 14.2 85.9 90 3/6/2007 1.507 10.2 1.729 14.2 87.2 90 3/6/2007 1..629 14 1.734 13.6 94 90 3/6/2007 1.638 14.5 1.734 13.6 94.5 90 3/6/2007 1.647 13.7 1.734 13.6 95 90 3/6/2007 1.598 10.8 1.729 14.2 92.4 90 3/6/2007 1.618 12.8 1.729 14.2 93.6 90 3/6/2007 1.6 13.5 1.734 13.6 92.3 90 3/6/2007 1.621 12.7 1.734 13.6 93.5 90 3/6/2007 1.599 14 1.714 14.2 93.3 90 3/6/2007 1.576 12.3 1.714 14.2 92 90 3/6/2007 1.569 14 1.734 13.6 90.5 90 3/6/2007 1.569 14.5 1.734 13.6 90.5 90 3/6/2007 1.577 13.9 1.734 13.6 91 90 3/6/2007 1.586 12.5 1.734 13.6 91.5 90 3/6/2007 1.605 10.5 1.734 13.6 92.6 90 3/6/2007 1.56 13 1.734 13.6 90 90 4/6/2007 1.649 15.2 1.729 14.2 95.4 90 4/6/2007 1.628 14 1.729 14.2 94.2 90 5/6/2007 1.621 13.5 1.734 13.6 93.5 90 5/6/2007 1.595 13 1.734 13.6 92 90 5/6/2007 1.586 12.5 1.734 13.6 91.5 90 5/6/2007 1.603 12.5 1.734 13.6 92.5 90 5/6/2007 1.612 12 1.734 13.6 93 90Panel D, E Sand Pass1102 3697 3733 403.25 B/W Panel & C/W Sand Pass 1101 3697 3733 403.25 Panel D, E Sand Pass 1100 3474 3628 412 B/W Panel & C/W Sand Pass 1099 3474 3628 412 B/W Panel & C/W Sand Pass 1098 3474 3628 412 B/W Panel & C/W Sand Pass 1097 3628 3745 412 B/W Panel & C/W Sand Pass 1096 3628 3745 412 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1095 3333 3573 403.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1094 3333 3573 403.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1093 3333 3573 403.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1092 3333 3513 404.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1091 3333 3513 404.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1090 3333 3513 404.75 Panel D 125, 126 Sand Pass 1089 3673 3733 397.25 Panel D 125, 126 Sand Pass 1088 3673 3733 397.25 Panel C 125, 126 Sand Pass 1087A 3673 3733 397.25 Panel C 125, 126 Sand Pass 1087 3673 3733 397.25 U/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1086 4243 4300.5 409.25 U/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1085 4243 4300.5 409.25 Panel E & D Sand Pass 1084 3493 3613 402.13 Panel E & D Sand Pass 1083 3493 3613 402.13 Panel E & D Sand Fail 1082 3493 3613 402.13 Panel E & D Sand Pass 1081 3493 3613 402.13 Panel B 144, 145 Sand Pass 1080 3493 3613 402.13 Panel E & D Sand Fail 1079 4243 4300.5 402.13 Panel A 144, 145 Sand Pass 1078 4243 4300.5 414.25 Panel B 144, 145 Sand Pass 1077 4243 4300.5 414.25 Panel A 144, 145 Sand Pass 1076 4243 4300.5 414.75 Panel A 144, 145 Sand Pass 1075 4243 430.5 414.75 Panel D 123 ~ 124 Sand Pass 1074 3553 3673 401.53 Panel D 123 ~ 124 Sand Pass 1073 3553 3673 401.53 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1072 3343 3583 403.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1071 3343 3583 403.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1070 3343 35883 404.75 D/S Curtain Wall Sand Pass 1069 3343 3583 404.75 Panel D, E, F Sand Pass 1068 4273 4300 404.17 Panel D, E, F Sand Pass 1067 4273 4300 404.17 1066 4273 4300 404.17 Panel D, E, F Sand Pass CompactionLaboratory RemarksLayer # Location Description of Soil Field SUMMARY OF FIELD DENSITY TESTS FOR SUB-WEIR LEFT SIDE Date Area Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Sr. No. PBC ToFrom 346 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 10.7 Summary of Inspection Requests Sample summarized data for inspection requests for guide banks, sub weir and curtain walls are contained in the following tables: Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 347 348 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 349 11. QUALITY AUDIT AND GRAPHICAL PRESENTATION OF DATA The data contained in the preceding sections, indicates that the quality assurance and control tes ts conducted are more than the number prescribed by Specifications. Brief analysis of each type follows: 11.1 The Los Angeles Abrasion Tests Results The Los Angeles Abrasion tests results (for a sample period) for coarse aggregates, are presented graphica lly in Figure 1. The plot shows that the loss of weight has always been very much less than the permissible limit of 40%. The average loss comes to only 26%, confirming the good quality of the coarse aggregate. Source: Sakhi Sarwar & Sanghar Location: Stock Pile Material Description:Coarse Aggregate From: To: Name Max Allowed Value (%) Achieved Values (%) Signature GRAPHICAL ANALYSIS OF LOS ANGELES ABRASION TEST RESULTS 1-Aug-06 30-Jun-07 PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTSDESCON CGGC - JV Average Achieved Value (%) PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 200 210 220 230 240 250 260 270 280 290 300 310 320 330 340 350 360 370 380 390 400 410 420 LAB TEST NUMBER Loss % Figure 1: Los Angeles Abrasion Test Results 11.2 Sand Equivalent Tests Results for Fine Aggregate The plot of sand equivalent tests results for fine aggregates (Figure 2) indicates that sand equivalent values for all tests have been above the permissible base value of 80% except in only 5 out of 169 tests. The average values come to 82.25%. Failing consignments were rejected and removed from the site. 350 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Source: Khumbi Nallah Location: Stock Pile Material Description:Fine Aggregate From: To: PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF SAND EQUIVALENT TEST RESULTS 12-Sep-05 30-Jun-07 PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTSDESCON CGGC - JV Average Achieved Value (%) Name Min Allowed Value (%) Achieved Values (%) Signature 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100 200 225 250 275 300 325 350 375 400 LAB TEST NUMBER Value % Figure 2: Sand Equivalent Test Results for Fine Aggregate 11.3 Soundness Tests for Coarse Aggregate The values of percentage weight loss for coarse aggregate after 5 cycles of sodium sulphate treatment is only 1.1% (max), 0.2% (min) and 0.7% on the average against a permissible value of 12%, establishing the soundness of coarse aggregates used (Figure 3). Source: Sakhi Sarwar Location: Stock Pile Material Description:Coarse Aggregate From: To: Name Max Allowed Value (%) Achieved Values (%) Signature Average Achieved Value (%) COMULATIVE STATUS OF SOUNDNESS TEST RESULTS (Coarse Aggregate) 1-Oct-05 31-May-07 PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTSDESCON CGGC - JV PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70 72 74 76 78 80 LAB TEST NUMBER Value % Figure 3: Soundness Tests for Coarse Aggregate Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 351 11.4 Soundness Tests for Fine Aggregate The plot of these tests in Figure 4 indicates that the weight loss after soundness test has been 2.5% (max), 1.6% (min) and 2% o n the average, against a permissible value of 12% establishing the soundness of the fine aggregates used. Source: Khumbi Nallah Location: Stock Pile Material Description:Fine Aggregate From: To: PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF SOUNDNESS TEST RESULTS (Fine Aggregate) 1-Oct-05 31-May-07 PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTSDESCON CGGC - JV Average Achieved Value (%) Name Max Allowed Value (%) Achieved Values (%) Signature 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70No. Of Tests Value % Source: Khumbi Nallah Location: Stock Pile Material Description:Fine Aggregate From: To: Average Achieved Value (%) Name Max Allowed Value (%) Achieved Values (%) Signature PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF SOUNDNESS TEST RESULTS (Fine Aggregate) 1-Oct-05 30-Jun-07 PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTSDESCON CGGC - JV 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70 72 74 76 78 80No. Of Tests Value % Figure 4: Soundness Tests for Fine Aggregate 11.5 Gradation Charts of Fine Aggregate The gradation charts (for a sample period) prepared from the sieve analyses of fine aggregates plotted in Figures 5 indicate that the aggregates used were well graded. The red lines in the figures 5 to 7 represent maximum and minimum envelope curves while the actual gradation of sand is in between these two envelopes. 352 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Khumbi Nallah Location: Stock Pile Material Description: Sand Lab No. 568 ~ 572 From : To: Name DESCON CGGC - JV PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTS Signature COMULATIVE PARTICLE DISTRIBUTION CHART Source: 26-May-07 31-May-07 PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 #200 #100 #50 #40 #30 #16 #10 #8 #4 #3/8'' 1/2'' 3/4'' 1'' 1/1/2'' 2'' 2/1/2 3'' 4''#20 0.074 0.15 0.3 0.42 0.59 1.18 2 2.4 4.76 9.52'' 12.7 19.1 25.4 38.1 50.8 63.5 76.2 4''0.84 Khumbi Nallah Location: Stock Pile Material Description: Sand Lab No. 583 ~ 587 From : To: PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE PARTICLE DISTRIBUTION CHART Source: 16-Jun-07 25-Jun-07 Name DESCON CGGC - JV PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTS Signature 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 #200 #100 #50 #40 #30 #16 #10 #8 #4 #3/8'' 1/2'' 3/4'' 1'' 1/1/2'' 2'' 2/1/2 3'' 4''#20 0.074 0.15 0.3 0.42 0.59 1.18 2 2.4 4.76 9.52'' 12.7 19.1 25.4 38.1 50.8 63.5 76.2 4''0.84 Figure 5: Gradation Chart of Fine Aggregate 11.6 Specific Gravity Tests for Coarse and Fine Aggregates The results for 328 tests plotted in Figure 6 indicate that the specific gravity of the coarse aggregates was observed to be 2.70 (max), 2.610 (min) and 2.650 on the average against a prescribed value of 2.60 establishing the denseness of the aggregates. Similarly the results for 166 tests plotted in Figure 8 indicate that the Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 353 specific gravity of the fine aggregates has been observed to be 2.73 (max), 2.59 (min) and 2.65 on the average against a prescribed value of 2.60 establishing the denseness of the aggregates. Source: Sakhi Sarwar & Sanghar Location: Stock Pile Material Description:Coarse Aggregate From: To: Name Min Allowed Value Achieved Values Signature COMULATIVE STATUS OF SPECIFIC GRAVITY TEST RESULTS (Coarse Aggregate) 5-May-05 31-May-07 PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTSDESCON CGGC - JV Average Achieved Value PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project 2.500 2.550 2.600 2.650 2.700 2.750 2.800 2.850 2.900 400 410 420 430 440 450 460 470 480 490 500 510 520 530 540 550 560 570 580 590 600 LAB TEST NUMBER Value Source: Khumbi Nallah Location: Stock Pile Material Description:Fine Aggregate From: To: PBC IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF SPECIFIC GRAVITY TEST RESULTS (Fine Aggregate) 8-May-07 30-Jun-07 PUNJAB BARRAGES CONSULTANTSDESCON CGGC - JV Average Achieved Value Name Min Allowed Value Achieved Values Signature 2.500 2.550 2.600 2.650 2.700 2.750 2.800 2.850 2.900 301 311 321 331 341 351 361 371 381 391 LAB TEST NUMBER Value Figure 6: Specific Gravity Tests for Coarse and Fine Aggregates 11.7 Compressive Strength Results for Class D Concrete The graphical presentation of compressive strength results for 28 days for class D concrete in Figure 7 are always higher than the prescribed values, thus 354 Zaidi, Khan, Asad showing the good quality of concrete. Due to lean mix, the 7 days strength of some samples is a bit less but after 28 days more than required strength was achieved. IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF COMPRESSIVE STREN GTH TEST RESULTS UPTO MAY, 20 0 7 (CLASS- D) PBC 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % Average Achieved Strength (7 DAYS) 7Days (Achieved Strength) AFTER 07 DAYS 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % 28 Days (Achieved Strength) Req.Str. Average Achieved Strength (28 Days) AFTER 28 DAYS IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF COMPRESSIVE STREN GTH TEST RESULTS f o r Ju n e- 20 0 7 (CLASS- D) PBC 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % Average Achieved Strength (7 DAYS) 7Days (Achieved Strength) AFTER 07 DAYS 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % 28 Days (Achieved Strength) Req.Str. Average Achieved Strength (28 Days) AFTER 28 DAYS Figure 7: Compressive Strength Results for Class D Concrete Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 355 11.8 Compressive Strength Results for Class AA Concrete Graphical presentation of compressive strength results for 7 and 28 days for class AA concrete in Figure 8 shows higher than the prescribed strength values, thus establishing the good quality of concrete. IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF COMPRESSIVE STREN GTH TEST RESULTS Upt o m a y , 20 0 7 (CLASS- AA) PBC 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % Average Achieved Strength (7 DAYS) 7Days (Achieved Strength) AFTER 07 DAYS 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % 28 Days (Achieved Strength) Req.Str. Average Achieved Strength (28 Days) AFTER 28 DAYS IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF COMPRESSIVE STREN GTH TEST RESULTS FOR Ju n e- 20 0 7 (CLASS- AA) PBC 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840 860 880 900 920 940 960 980 1000 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % Average Achieved Strength (7 DAYS) 7Days (Achieved Strength) AFTER 07 DAYS 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 450 470 490 510 530 550 570 590 610 630 650 670 690 710 730 750 770 790 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % 28 Days (Achieved Strength) Req.Str. Average Achieved Strength (28 Days) AFTER 28 DAYS Figure 8: Compressive Strength Results for Class AA Concrete 356 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 11.9 Compressive Strength Results for Class BB Concrete Graphical presentation of compressive strength results for 7 and 28 days for class BB concrete in Figure 9 shows higher than the prescribed strength values, thus establishing the good quality of concrete. IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF COMPRESSIVE STREN GTH TEST RESULTS UPTO m a y , 20 0 7 (CLASS- BB) PBC 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 300 320 340 360 380 400 420 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % Average Achieved Strength (7 DAYS) 7Days (Achieved Strength) AFTER 07 DAYS 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 300 310 320 330 340 350 360 370 380 390 400 410 420 430 440 450 460 470 480 490 500 510 520 530 540 550 560 570 580 590 600 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % 28 Days (Achieved Strength) Req.Str. Average Achieved Strength (28 Days) AFTER 28 DAYS IRRIGATION AND POWER DEPARTMENT GOVT. OF PUNJAB Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation And Modernization Project COMULATIVE STATUS OF COMPRESSIVE STREN GTH TEST RESULTS f o r j u n e- 20 0 7 (CLASS- BB) PBC 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 440 460 480 500 520 540 560 580 600 620 640 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % Average Achieved Strength (7 DAYS) 7Days (Achieved Strength) AFTER 07 DAYS 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 490 500 510 520 530 540 550 560 570 580 590 600 610 620 630 640 650 660 670 680 690 700 710 720 730 740 750 760 770 780 790 800 Lab Test NO. Compressive Strength % 28 Days (Achieved Strength) Req.Str. Average Achieved Strength (28 Days) AFTER 28 DAYS Figure 9: Compressive Strength Results for Class BB Concrete Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 357 12. QA/QC ACTIVITIES PERFORMED BY ICB-02 CONTRACTOR Mechanical and Electrical works were covered under ICB-02 Contract. Under this contract, rehabilitation of 31 weir gates and 1 navigation lock gate including raising of gate by 1 ft., replacement and repair of Canal Gates, hoisting arrangement, counter weights and superstructure were c overed. The works done at the site was put to following Quality checks by the Consultants during the reporting period: i. Visual & measurement checks, tensile test & chemical composition test of material. ii. Straightness of grooves facing, side seals pl ates & roller guard and gate guide shoes. iii. Alignment of gate leaf, rocker assembly, roller train & guide, rope drums & hoist. iv. Welding visual & measurement checks, dye penetrant test (DPT) & ultrasonic test (UT) v. Painting appearance checks & dry film thickness (DFT) test by Elecometer. vi. Rise in temperature measured at various parts/points of hoist. vii. Electrical parameters (voltage, ampere & phase sequence) & insulation test of three phase induction motor & trial test run of gates operations Details of the quality assurance/control activities ICB -02 works for rehabilitation of main weir gates and upstream navigation lock gate no. 8 are as follows: Mechanical Works 1) Side sealing plate Description Straightness Flatness Chipping Concreting Location WG-31 OK OK OK OK At site WG-32 OK OK OK OK At site WG-33 OK OK OK OK At site WG-34 OK OK OK OK At site WG-35 OK OK OK OK At site WG-36 OK OK OK OK At site WG-37 OK OK OK OK At site NL-08 OK OK OK OK At site 358 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 2) Facing of rocker assembly base Description Straightness Flatness Depth machined Grinding Location WG-31 OK OK OK OK At site WG-32 OK OK OK OK At site WG-33 OK OK OK OK At site WG-34 OK OK OK OK At site WG-35 OK OK OK OK At site WG-36 OK OK OK OK At site WG-37 OK OK OK OK At site NL-08 OK OK OK OK At site 3) Assembly of rocker assembly Description Straightness Flatness Movement Junction gap Location WG-31 OK OK OK OK At site WG-32 OK OK OK OK At site WG-33 OK OK OK OK At site WG-34 OK OK OK OK At site WG-35 OK OK OK OK At site WG-36 OK OK OK OK At site WG-37 OK OK OK OK At site 4) Gate leaf Description Dimension Welding Paint Sealings Location WG-31 OK OK OK OK At site WG-32 OK OK OK OK At site WG-33 OK OK OK OK At site WG-34 OK OK OK OK At site WG-35 OK OK OK OK At site WG-36 OK OK OK OK At site WG-37 OK OK OK OK At site NL-08 OK OK OK OK At site Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 359 5) Roller guard Description Straightness Clearance Chipping Concreting Location WG-31 OK OK OK OK At site WG-32 OK OK OK OK At site WG-33 OK OK OK OK At site WG-34 OK OK OK OK At site WG-35 OK OK OK OK At site WG-36 OK OK OK OK At site WG-37 OK OK OK OK At site NL-08 OK OK OK OK At site 6) Sill beam Description Straightness Flatness Level Concreting Location NL-08 (U/S) OK OK OK OK At site NL-08 (D/S) OK OK OK OK At site 7) Bracket for bulkhead gates 7.1) Installation of bracket Description Straightness Flatness Verticality Weld joint Location WG-31 OK OK OK OK At site WG-32 OK OK OK OK At site WG-33 OK OK OK OK At site WG-34 OK OK OK OK At site WG-35 OK OK OK OK At site WG-36 OK OK OK OK At site WG-37 OK OK OK OK At site 7.2) Concreting of bracket Description Chipping Drilling Concreting Pouring Location WG-31 OK OK OK OK At site WG-32 OK OK OK OK At site WG-33 OK OK OK OK At site WG-34 OK OK OK OK At site WG-35 OK OK OK OK At site WG-36 OK OK OK OK At site WG-37 OK OK OK OK At site 360 Zaidi, Khan, Asad 13. QUALITY REPORTS The Contractor and Consultants generated monthly and quarterly quality reports, which contained periodical data and review of quality processes. These reports were submitted to the Government (owner) and the World Bank (Financiers). 14. OVERALL ASSESSMENT Looking at the preceding narration in an overall perspective, we find that the Quality Assurance and Quality Control planning , the plans and their implementation has been quite good and in line with International Standards (ISO 9001-2000). State of the Art systematic control has yielded high quality works. All the project works were done in full conformance with the prescribed standards, drawings and specifications and no significant quality incident occurred. However as a routine measure any deficiencies observed by the supervisory staff in preparation stage were notified through necessary field memos verbal instructions and letters and pursued till rectification to ensure quality. The quality control data was put to internal audit and the works quality was found to be very good in all aspects. The project works were visited by a large number of professionals from various organizations like Pakistan Engineering Congress, FWO, Engineers of 2nd Corps Multan, World Bank teams, Panel of Experts and others, who appreciated the works quality. The project also provided training and experience of this special type of works after 35 years, all through domestic resources. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 361 362 Zaidi, Khan, Asad PMO CONTRACTOR Project Manger (Lahore) PMO Taunsa PBC CONSULTANTS Project Manage (Lahore) CONTRACTOR Site Manager (Taunsa) CONTRACTOR QA Manager & staff (Taunsa) PBC CONSULTANTS Chief Resident Engineer (Taunsa) PBC CONSULTANTS QA Engineer & staff (Taunsa) MONITORING AND SURVEILLANCE OF PQP AT SITE SUBMITTALS TAUNSA BARRAGE EMERGENCY REHABILITATION AND MODERNIZATION PROJECT ORGANIZATION AND FLOW OF Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 363 364 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Figure 10: Location plan of the Barrage Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 365 Figure 11: Layout of the Barrage 366 Zaidi, Khan, Asad Figure 3: Upstream View of the Barrage Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 367 Figure 12: Main Existing Barrage and Sub-Weir - Plan and Cross Section 368 Zaidi, Khan, Asad

Filename: QUALITY-MANAGEMENT-FOR-TAUNSA-BARRAGE-REHABILITATION-PROJECT.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 2 MB
Categories: 0071st Annual Issue 2011
Author: Malik Ahmad Khan & Javed Asad, S.M.A. Zaidi
Downloads: 2