Paper No. 693 TO LOOK INTO THE POSSIBILITY OF USING PENETRATION GRADE ASPHALT BINDER IN STONE MATRIX ASPHALT (SMA) FOR HIGHWAYS AND HEAVY TRAFFIC ROADS IN PAKISTAN Shamim Zafar 428 Zafar Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 429 TO LOOK INTO THE POSSIBILITY OF USING PENETRATION GRADE ASPHALT BINDER IN STONE MATRIX ASPHALT (SMA) FOR HIGHWAYS AND HEAVY TRAFFIC ROADS IN PAKISTAN Shamim Zafar Material Specialist, NESPAK ABSTRACT The pavement failures in the form of fatigue cracking/rutting and thermal cracking is a common issue fac ed throughout the world. It is believed that heavy traffic and the in-service temperature are the main causes of these failures. The International Pavement Research/Construction Agencies, especially in Europe and America had developed new methodologies an d technologies for construction of highways and heavy traffic roads to cope with these problems. These new technologies are the Superior Performing Asphalt Pavements (Superpave) and Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA). The new technologies have adopted performance grade system for asphalt binder rather than the penetration grade which was used throughout the world for decades in addition to introducing some advance testing and gradation for aggregates. The properties of performance grade asphalt binder are related to the condition under which it is used and are selected to meet the expected climatic conditions. The performance grade system for asphalt binder is based on the mean high and low temperature which the pavement experiences during its service life. This switch over to performance grade asphalt binder from penetration grade was a major change in the methodology of production of asphalt binder. As such it was not so easy and took years of research before finally adopting the new system of performance grade asphalt binder. With continued research and work on the use of Performance Grade Asphalt Binder, many asphalt technologist and pavement specialist still believe that the selection of a PG binder does not guarantee the total pavement performance, other factors e.g properties of aggregates and the mix are equally important for durable pavement structure. It is believed that fatigue cracking is the result of pavement structure / load of traffic and permanent deformation or rutting is directly related to shear strength of the mix, which is controlled by aggregate properties. Pavement low temperature cracking is the only distress directly related to binder properties. This indicates that selection of proper aggregates with appropriate properties of binder is of p rime importance in mix design and future performance of the pavement. 430 Zafar Due to heavy load of traffic, Pakistan is also a victim of road failures in the form of fatigue cracking and rutting and to some extent thermal cracking. It is need of the time to focus on to new technology of Superpave or Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA). Superpave provides a cost effective alternative for both conventional and SMA pavements. However many case studies in Europe and America have revealed that the SMA mixes have performed equa lly good or better than Superpave mixes. According to some agencies SMA is providing a better alternative than Superpave for worst case loading. The high percentage of coarse aggregate resulting in stone-on- stone contact in SMA Mix with high percentage of asphalt binder seems to be more durable than the Superpave mixtures as the aggregate is the main load bearing component. This paper emphasizes on the need to investigate possibilities of using locally and commercially available aggregates and penetration grade asphalt binders with SMA gradation to produce a mix as per the criteria outlined in SMA Mix design method AASHTO MP 8 and AASHTO PP 41 as it is not possible to introduce performance grade system for asphalt binders in Pakistan at this very stage. OBJECTIVES The objectives of the study to be undertaken are threefold: 1. To evaluate whether the aggregates from Taxila, Sargodah and from some others sources in Pakistan can be used to design rut resistant stone matrix asphalt mixture by using locally and commercially available penetration grade asphalt binders. 2. To analyze and compare the properties of SMA Mix by using different NMAS with penetration grade asphalt binders generally used in Pakistan. 3. To make trial sections on different ongoing proje cts or on sections of different highways to study the behavior of SMA mix with penetration grade asphalt binder under heavy traffic if the laboratory experiments give positive results. INTRODUCTION The roads failure in the form of fatigue cracking and rut ting and to some extent thermal cracking are increasing day by day in Pakistan. It is believed that heavy traffic and the in -service temperature are the main causes of these failures. Thermal cracking is primarily controlled by the properties of the binder used in the mix and fatigue cracking/rutting is affected by aggregate grading and properties of the mix. Marshal Method of mix design is followed for all asphalt mixes in Pakistan. The Marshall Method was successfully used for decades but failures in the form of fatigue cracking/rutting have become a serious problem due to increase in load of traffic. Germany, in 1961, had developed an asphalt mix known as Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA) to wrestle with the problems of fatigue cracking and rutting. It provided a good rutting and skid resistance and it is being used in Europe for almost 40 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 431 years. Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA) is also being used in America since 1991 and now it is considered a more durable paving option than Superpave mixes. Several case studies have also reported that SMA mixtures have performed equally good or better than Superpave Mixes. Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA) consists of coarse aggregate, fine aggregate, mineral filler and asphalt content with or without modifier. The main features of SMA are as follows: The coarse aggregate in SMA is 70% or more, providing a stone to stone contact. It has a gap gradation rather than dense gradation as present in conventional mixes. Performance Grade Asphalt is used as compared to Penetration Grade. The asphalt content is also on higher side as compared to other asphalt mixes. Asphalt Binder can be modified or unmodified and a stabilizing agent in the form of cellulose fiber is added to stiffen the asphalt and to avoid fat spots on pavement surface. The high asphalt content provides a highly durable mixture which is compacted easily and is resistant to fatigue and reflective cracking. The thickness of SMA layer is comparatively less than conventional mixes making it cost effective. The d istinguishing features of Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA) are the coarse aggregate properties/gradation and the performance grade system for asphalt binders. The properties of aggregates as outlined in SMA Mix design method “AASHTO MP 8” are compatible with the properties of locally available aggregates in Pakistan, but the fact that production of performance grade asphalt will take years for start up, cannot be ignored. Under these circumstances, to pace with modern technology it will be wise enough to conduct a study to use penetration grade asphalt binder in SMA Method of Mix Design and study the properties of the mix as per the criteria outlined in AASHTO PP 41 (Standard Practice for Designing Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA). A BRIEF REVIEW ON INTERNATIONAL STUDIES FOR STONE MATRIX ASPHALT As mentioned earlier, Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA) was developed in Germany in 1960’s. Inspired by the success of SMA in Europe, an AASHTO led European Asphalt Study Tour introduced SMA in America in 1990. With its excellent performance, the use of Stone Matrix Asphalt (SMA) in the United States has significantly increased. The technical basis for SMA is a stone skeleton with stone -on-stone contact unlike the traditional dense graded asphalt mixes where aggregate tends to float in 432 Zafar the mix with little or no contact with larger particles. The stone-on-stone contact between high quality aggregates resists shear forces created by the applied loads. The properties of aggregate are of prime importance and play a vital role in producing SMA Mix that is more durable than the traditional mixes. Studies undertaken to establish the properties of aggregates are shape, texture, angularity and resistance to degradation. The rut resistant nature of SMA is dependent upon the internal friction an d cohesion. Internal friction in -turn depends upon particle shape, surface texture, gradation of aggregate, density of the mix and quantity of asphalt binder used. Cohesion is the binding force and is basic property of asphalt mixes. Cohesion increases with increasing asphalt binder up to a maximum point and then decreases. Generally 19mm and 12.5mm nominal aggregate sizes are used in SMA mixes. Typical SMA mixes retain 70% of the coarse aggregate on or above 2.36mm sieve with some fine aggregate ie passin g from 2.36mm sieve. Passing on sieve #200 is generally on higher side i.e. 8 to 10 % and cellulose fiber is added to prevent drain- down in the mixture due to high asphalt content which can result in fat spots on pavement surface. Specified Properties of SMA Materials (AASHTO MP 8-03) COARSE AGGREGATES Test Method Specified Values Los Angeles Abrasion (AASHTO T 96) 30 % maximum Flat and Elongated Particles (ASTMD4791) 20%(3:1)&5%(5:1) Water absorption (AASHTO T 85) 2.0 % maximum Soundness loss (AASHTO T 104) 15% Crushed Content (Coarse Aggregate Angularity (ASTMT5821) 100/90% Deleterious Materials ( AASHTO T 112) 0.2 % FINE AGGREGATES Soundness Loss (AASHTO T 104) 15% Fine Aggregate Angularity (Uncompacted Void) (AASHTO T 304) 40 to 45 % minimum Sand Equivalent (AASHTO T 176) 40 to 50 % minimum Liquid Limit (AASHTO T 89) 25% Plasticity Index (AASHTO T 90) NP ASPHALT BINDER (AASHTO T 320) PG Grade (6 % min.) CELLULOSE FIBER 0.4 % maximum Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 433 Properties of SMA Mix (AASHTO MP 8-03) PROPERTIES SMA MIX Grading Gap Graded Bitumen used 6 % minimum Air Voids 3 to 5 % VMA 17 % minimum TSR*1 (Moisture Susceptibility Test) 0.70 % Drain-down 0.3 % Stability 1 400 Ibs minimum (635kg) (Ref: FHWA) Laboratory Compaction Method 50 Blows by Marshall Hammer*2 or 100 Gyrations*3 VGA in Mix %*4
Filename:
TO-LOOK-INTO-THE-POSSIBILITY-OF-USING-PENETRATION-GRADE-ASPH.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
883 KB
Categories:
0071st Annual Issue 2011
