221 Paper No. 283 MANAGEMENT OF FLOOD 2010: LESSONS LEARNT AND IMPROVEMENT STRATEGIES Rab Nawaz 222 Rab Nawaz International Workshop on Floods in Pakistan-2010 223 MANAGEMENT OF FLOOD 2010: LESSONS LEARNT AND IMPROVEMENT STRATEGIES Rab Nawaz Secretary, Irrigation & Power Department THE EVENT Key Features of Flood 2010 • Unprecedented Super Flood. • Extremely Long Duration of Peaks. • Two Peaks Over a Two Week Period. • Continuous Rainfall and Hill Torrents Flooding. • Flood Received After a Very Long Dry Spell. Sequence of Events: • Torrential rains in the catchment areas of Swat, Kabul and Indus River during last week of July and First fortnight of August. • Exceptionally High Flood hit Kalabagh Barrage on 30-7-2010. Left Guide Bund (LGB) breached on 29-7-2010. Breaching section activated on 30-7-2010 to save the barrage. • Flood Peak reached Taunsa barrage on 02-08-2010. Spur 5 came under direct attack of the flood waters and saved by hectic efforts. • Left Marginal Bund (LMB) however could not sustain the pressure of exceptionally high flood and breached on 02-08-2010. • The breach in LMB was the main cause of the extensive damages and inundations in Muzaffargarh District via TP link / Muzaffargarh canal. • The super flood, after crossing Taunsa, engaged the protection bunds in DG Khan, Rajanpur and Rahimyar Khan Districts with discharges of 1.20 Million cusecs. • The situation became more critical due to continuous heavy rainfall and high flows in hill torrents. THE IMPACTS Physical Impact • Damages to Irrigation Network (Muzaffargarh, Rajanpur, DG Khan) including breaches in the main canals namely T.P Link Canal, Muzaffargarh Canal, D.G Khan Canal, Rangpur / Taliri Canal. • Breaches in the Left Guide Bank of Jinnah Barrage and breaches in the Left Marginal Bund of Taunsa Barrage • Damages to Flood Protection and drainage Structures (Bahawalpur (Guddu Barrage,), DG Khan (Jampur, Kot Mithan), Multan, Sargodha, Faisalabad and Lahore. 224 Rab Nawaz SUMMARY OF BREACHES & CUTS Sr. No Name of Zone Breaching Section Breaches Cuts made by Deptt. Cuts made by Public 1 SARGODHA 1 1 – – 2 D.G.KHAN 1 45 12 20 3 P.M.O. BARRAGES – 10 1 4 Bahawalpur – 11 – – GRAND TOTAL: 2 67 12 21 FINANCIAL IMPACT (Rs. In Million) S. No. Name of Irrigation Zone No. of Works Type of Work Estimated Cost 1 Sargodha 161 1269.190 2 DG Khan 140 1100.000 3 PMO Barrages 20 637.000 4 Bahawalpur 29 176.240 5 Multan 11 12.353 6 Lahore 1 2.490 7 Faisalabad 3 2.172 Total: 365 Flood Protection Bunds and Irrigation Infrastructure 3199.445 International Workshop on Floods in Pakistan-2010 225 FLOOD MANAGEMENT CHALLENGES Flood 2010: Challenges • Weakened flood bunds due to infrequency of floods resulting in extreme damage caused due to drying of embankments, cracking and rodent holes. • This infrequency also induced lowering of guard in terms of institutional preparedness. • Outdated flood management plans and SOPs and lack of any ‘Plan B” in the event of a breach. • Balanced view of the holistic flood scenario not brought out by hyper active electronic media. • Timely relief cuts could have considerably reduced the damage but could not be made due to active resistance by locals. • Three departmental machines were burnt / damaged by mobs and staff was manhandled at number of places. Most flood management actions could be implemented only with assistance from Army. • Lack of leadership and coordination at District and Tehsil level. • Overall governance and law and order / respect for authority and laws remained conspicuous by their absence during the entire flood emergency which undermined effective flood management. RESTORATION STRATEGY CATEGORIES OF REPAIR/RESTORATION WORKS CATEGORY DESCRIPTION COST (RS. MIL.) Immediate Works Canal and embankment breaches 1,000 Medium Term Strengthening of weak canal banks, repair of barrage support structures and buildings 2,200 Long Term Strengthening and improvement of flood protection works on new bench marks. i. Strengthening and raising of existing bunds. ii. Proving wetting channels along the bunds. iii. Provision of Second Defence Bunds. iv. Improving the drainage capacity to provide relief in case of breaches. TBD 226 Rab Nawaz Restoration Strategy: • Immediate works were carried out under emergency provisions. • Wherever feasible, Departmental Machinery was used for breach closing. • All emergency works were Supervised by Third Party Monitoring Consultants. • LMB breach of Taunsa was closed on war footing basis on August 25, 2010. • Breaches of Muzaffargarh and TP Link were plugged and channels were made operational by September 15, 2010. • Damages to the distribution system would be repaired by end March 2011 and channels, being non-perennial in nature, would be opened during Kharif 2011. • Repair works to the distributaries and minors being done through Departmental machinery while repair works to smaller minors and On Farm systems being done through farmer participation. • Longer term works related to protection and drainage works will be taken up after establishment of new bench marks and comprehensive evaluation. LESSONS LEARNT & OPPORTUNITIES • Flood protection works should be given due importance in resource allocation irrespective of the infrequency of floods. • Establishment of new bench-marks in terms of protection works heights and strengths and a fresh drainage plan for quick draining of flood waters from affected areas. • Governance at local level is non-existent during emergencies. Need for a fresh look at our district and tehsil administration system to bring back the ability for effective leadership and coordination during emergencies. • Regular updating of SOPs, regular drills for disaster management, regular capacity building/training of managers for flood protection, barrage management and public handling during crisis. • A code of conduct for media during natural disasters to harness their outreach for effective management. • Promotion of spirit of Self Reliance in emergency relief and post disaster rehabilitation. • Build back better and safer structures. • Invest in disaster preparedness and effective management of relief and early recovery when it happens. • Better regulation of riverine/khadir areas and a proper regulatory and enforcement mechanism. • Build water storages to mitigate the impact of super floods. International Workshop on Floods in Pakistan-2010 227 • Improve institutions and governance at district and tehsil level for effective leadership during crisis. • Build positive synergies between an active media and positive spreading of message among masses during crisis. 228 Rab Nawaz Historic and Current Flood Peaks Peak Discharges at Jinnah 1947-2010 Peak Discharges at Jinnah 1947-2010 Peak Discharges at Jinnah International Workshop on Floods in Pakistan-2010 229 Peak Discharges at Taunsa 1958 -2010 Back Peak Discharges at Taunsa KEY FEATURES OF FLOOD 2010 Duration Duration of Flood Stage (Hours) Barrage High Very High Exceptional High Kalabagh 131 85 30 Taunsa 116 97 27 230 Rab Nawaz

Filename: 14-Management-of-Flood-2010-Rab-Nawaz-11pt.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 296 KB
Categories: Volume 0032- 2010
Author: Rab Nawaz