Symposium on “Emerging Phenomenon of Untimely Rains / Floods – 2011 in Pakistan” 79 UNPRECEDENTED 2011 RAINS / FLOODS IN PAKISTAN AND ACTIONS NEEDED By Engr. Zafar Iqbal1 Abstract Pakistan is facing many risks emanating from a number of natural and man- made hazards and flood is the most devastating natural disaster among these hazards . Floods have caused enormous losses to human lives, property, infrastructure, and has affected the overall economic growth in past six decades. The catchment areas of main rivers of the country did not receive heavy precipitation during Monsoon Season 2011, hence, none of the major rivers attained danger flood level. That is why no serious riverine flooding was observed during 2011- Flood Season. However, the torrential monsoon rains of 2011 hit the Sindh Province, especially the southeastern parts of the province, which were historical events of about 150 years return period. The rains/floods affected an area of about 6.812 million acres (23 Districts in Sindh, 12 in Punjab and 1 in AJK) affecting 38,700 villages, claiming about 516 lives, damaging 1,598,629 houses and cropped area of about 2.311 million acres and population of about 9.303 million had been affected. Key words: Unprecedented rains, Pakistan, Monsoon, 2011-flood season, damages. 1. Introduction The rains started in 2nd week of August and continued till mid September with short intervals. The first spell of heavy rainfall started from 10th August and continued till 17th August 2011 with short intervals, which caused more than 300mm precipitation in Districts Badin, Mirpurkhas, Hyderabad, Tando Muhammad Khan, Shaheed Benazirabad (Nawabshah), Sanghar and generated surface run- off of more than 14000 cusecs in LBOD System against its designed discharge capacity of 4440 cusecs. Average rainfall recorded was 8- 10 times more than the land drainage capaci ty of LBOD and Kotri Barrage Drainage System. The 2nd spell of monsoon rains started from 29th August 2011, which caused averagely 200 mm and in some areas more than 400 mm rains were recorded. The cumulative rainfall recorded in the region was averagely 600 mm. The LBOD System (already flowing full) attained its maximum water level and overtopped at several locations, which badly affected the abadies, standing crops, private and public infrastructure of Districts Mirpurkhas, Badin, Shaheed Benazirabad (Nawabshah) and Sanghar, Tando Muhammad Khan, Umerkot, Tharparker, Tando Allayar Khan and adjoining areas. As the land was already saturated, hence, the 2nd spell rains caused more damages to abadies, private and public infrastructure, besides standing crops. The continued rains created flood like situation in the entire lower parts of Sindh. 2. Seasonal Rainfall Forecast for Monsoon Season 2011 issued by PMD Pakistan Meteorological Department predicted 10% below Normal monsoon rains during the period from July t o September 2011. The official prediction of seasonal monsoon rainfall by Pakistan Meteorological Department, issued on 13th June, 2011, is reproduced hereunder ; “Pakistan Summer Monsoon rainfall is invariably affected by the global, regional and local climatic conditions prevailing prior to the season. Analysis of their combined effect indicates that total amount of rainfall averaged over Pakistan during monsoon season (July – September) 2011 will remain 10% below normal”. However, there are chances of about 10% above normal rainfall in northern parts of Pakistan including Punjab, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa provinces and Kashmir. At occasions, the interaction of easterly and westerly systems may result in heavy downpour causing localized urban/flash flooding. This outlook is prepared at 80% confidence interval and meant for the planning purpose. The area weighted normal rainfall of Pakistan for monsoon season is 137.5 m. m. ____________________________________________________________________________________________________ 1. Office of the Chief Engineering Advisor / Chairman, Federal Flood Commission, Islamabad, 44000, Pakistan. Engr. Zafar Iqbal Paper No. 299 80 3. Floods / Rains 2011 The catchment areas of main rivers of the country did not receive heavy precipitation during Monsoon Season 2011, hence, none of the major rivers attained danger flood level. That is why no serious riverine flooding was observed during 2011- Flood Season. However, the torrential monsoon rains of 2011 hit the Sindh Province, especially the southeastern parts of the prov ince, which were historical events of about 150 years return period. The rains started in August and continued till mid September with short intervals. The first spell of heavy rainfall started from 10th August and continued till 17th August 2011 with shor t intervals, which caused more than 300 mm precipitation in Districts Badin, Mirpurkhas, Hyderabad, Tando Muhammad Khan, Shaheed Benazirabad (Nawabshah) and Sanghar, generated runoff of more than 14, 000 cusecs in LBOD System against its designed discharge capacity of 4 ,440 cusecs. Average rainfall recorded was 8- 10 times more than the land drainage capacity of LBOD and Kotri Barrage Drainage System. The 2nd spell of monsoon rains started from 29th August 2011, which caused averagely 200 mm and in some areas more than 400 mm rains were recorded. The cumulative rainfall recorded in the region was averagely 600 mm. The LBOD System (already flowing full) attained its maximum levels and overtopped at several locations, which badly affected the abadies, standing crops, private and public infrastructure of Districts Mirpurkhas, Badin, Shaheed Benazirabad (Nawabshah), Sanghar , Tando Muhammad Khan, Umerkot, Tharparker, Tando Allayar Khan and adjoin areas. As the land was already saturated, hence, the 2nd spell rains caused more damages to abadies, private and public infrastructure, besides standing crops. The continued rains created flood like situation in t he entire lower parts of Sindh. The rains / floods affected an area of about 6.812 million acres (23 Districts in Sindh, 12 in Punjab and 1 in AJK) affecting 38,700 villages, claiming about 516 lives, damaging 1,598,629 houses and cropped area of about 2.311 million acres and population of about 9.303 million has been affected. 4. Strategy for restoration/rehabilitation and improvement works Irrigation and Power Department, Government of Sindh with the help of donor agency (Asian Development Bank) has estimated damages occurred to irrigation, drainage and flood protection infrastructure and their restoration/reconstr uction cost as Rs 6.00 billion. Irrigation and Power Department, Government of Sindh has evolved strategy for restoration/rehabilitation and improvement works in the following two (2) categories; 4.1 Emergent Nature Restoration Works: The following activities have been planned to be carried out before start of Monsoon Season 2012 ; • Procurement of earth moving machinery under Chinese Loan worth US $ 32 Million and Provincial Share of Rs 1.60 Million ; • Restoration of Existing main drains and sub-drains including rehabilitation of banks ; • Re-sectioning of Dhoro Puran and rehabilitation of banks including removal of encroachments near Jhudo Town ; • Bank protection with stone pitching of vulnerable sections, bridges and crossings ; • Construction of Temporary pumping station to drain out rain / storm water from stagnant areas ; • Identification of encroachments along existing Dhoras and their removal ; • Identification of obstacles along road network and railways crossings etc. • Engagement of Consultants and detailed design works for Master Planning as Long- Term Measures. Symposium on “Emerging Phenomenon of Untimely Rains / Floods – 2011 in Pakistan” 81 4.2 Long-term Measures: • Remodeling and enhancing the discharge capacity of existing drainage network on the basis of 20 years frequency period ; • Construction of additional drains including towns / cities to discharge into existing Dhoras ; • Construction of an independent natural Dhoras Network and Syphons across Main Drain fro diversion of flows into Dhora Puran (Shakoor Dhand) in order to off-load LBOD System. • Construction of out-fall structure along KPOD to control tidal impact and sea water intrusion. • Remodeling of weirs and increasing size of inlets and culverts etc. • Diversion of storm -water to Dhands of Thar desert such as Kakao, Kalankar and abandoned Dhoro Puran and like others. • Identification of natural depressions, their strengthening and construction of raised plat forms to settle displaced people. • Other essential necessary works. 5. Meteorological Causes of 2011-Rains / Floods During Monsoon Season 2011, the Area Weighted Rainfall all over the country was recorded as 236.5 mm against the Normal figure of 137.5 mm (72% increase). Sindh received 444 mm against the average/normal rainfall of 127.5 mm. Punjab experienced 349 mm rainfall against the average normal figure of 236 mm. Similarly, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa got 249 mm rainfall against the average normal rainfall of 225 mm, whereas Balochistan received averagely 82 mm rains against average figure of 59 mm. In the month of July, 2011, the country received below normal monsoon rains. However, in 2nd week of August a strong weather system entered in the southeastern parts of Sindh Province from the Indian states of Rajasthan and Gujarat and gained further strength with the passage of time, which caused heavy downpours. The four weeks of continuous rains created severe flood situation in Sindh, especially southeastern parts of the province. The abadies, private and public property and standing crops in Sindh province were badly damaged. The unprecedented monsoon rains from 10 th August to 2 nd September 2011 caused loss of human lives, standing crops, houses, infrastructure, etc. The highest ever recorded monsoon rains in Sindh displaced hundred thousands of people, besides destroying million of acres of cropped land. The District Badin received record breaking rainfall of 615 millimeters during the monsoon spell breaking earlier recorded 121 millimeters in Badin in 1936. The area of Mithi also received record rainfall of 1,290 millimeters against the previous maximum rainfall of 114 millimeters in 2004. The heavy rainfalls recorded in Sindh province in the months of August and September 2011 are given in Table-1. Table-1 Torrential rainfall recorded in August and September, 2011 in Sindh City Rainfall in mm August 2011 September 2011 Total Mithi 530* 760* 1290* Mirpur Khas 263.1* 603* 866.1* Shaheed Benazirabad 275.2* 353.2* 628.4* Badin 331.2* 284.1 615.3* Chhor 276 268 544* Dadu 134.1 348.1 482.2* Padidan 251.2 172 423.2* Hyderabad 162.2 244.2 406.4 Karachi 61.2 212.2 273.3 * Indicates new record. Source: PMD Engr. Zafar Iqbal Paper No. 299 82 6. Country-Wide Losses / Damages due to 2011 Rains / Floods The 2011-rains/floods affected an area of about 6.812 million acres (23 Districts in Sindh, 12 in Punjab and 1 in AJK) affecting 38,700 villages, claiming about 516 lives, damaging 1,598,629 houses and cropped area of about 2.311 million acres and population of about 9.303 million has been affected. Province wise detail of losses / damages is given in Table-2. District -wise detail of flood damages caused due to 2011 Rains/Floods in Sindh Province is also given in Table-3. Table-2 COUNTRY-WIDE LOSSES/DAMAGES DUE TO RAIN/FLOOD 2011 Province/ Region Villages Affected Persons Affected Area Affected (Acres) Cropped Area Affected (Acres) Persons Died Persons Injured Cattle Heads Perished Punjab 335 26393 136758 125513 1284 4 17 Nil Sindh 38347 9275568 6674859 2184951 1596807 497 753 116529 Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Balochistan Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil FATA 15 671 439 310 534 3 Nil 1209 Gilgit- Baltistan Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil Nil AJ and K 3 170 4 Nil 4 12 Nil Nil G. Total 38700 9302802 6812060 2310774 1598629 516 770 117738 Table-3 LOSSES/DAMAGES IN SINDH PROVINCE DUE TO RAIN/FLOOD 2011 District Villages Affected Persons Affected Area Affected (Acres) Cropped Area Affected (Acres) House Damaged Persons Died Persons Injured Cattle Heads Perished T.M Khan 2835 585411 390997 78038 72935 17 24 187 Sh. Benazir Abad 4104 900000 – 290000 200000 41 82 22646 T. Allahyar 1609 569829 369685 81645 70163 3 5 197 Mirpur Khas 3178 705151 819833 171522 118110 61 230 12280 Thatta 901 178011 225738 64293 15693 23 15 131 Hyderabad 681 377992 113333 26227 20644 17 27 32 Badin 6395 1021301 984805 375,718 382562 73 10 10060 Matiari 415 109629 160970 83739 32803 25 28 1101 Umerkot 3769 821,581 927966 108303 122103 31 7 18824 Tharparker 2284 907179 51782 12647 178356 28 9 30623 Shikarpur 0 0 0 20218 0 0 0 Khairpur 2075 384137 323924 182891 29023 25 65 327 Dadu 1454 325000 187811 97,248 18594 19 51 161 Jamshoro 614 97350 30,086 39,133 43950 16 11 83 Sanghar 5182 1237432 927201 356473 213928 39 93 19040 Jacobabad 0 0 0 3594 0 0 0 Karachi 0 4 0 0 5 25 8 9 N’ Feroze 437 671499 698434 73660 31455 26 50 512 Ghotki 1361 172067 258661 68,679 31630 11 19 1 Kamber 543 145030 150600 4192 7439 6 15 219 Kashmore 102 12610 40240 14532 1620 4 3 4 Larkana 408 54355 12793 5396 5794 6 1 92 Sukkur 0 0 0 26803 1 0 0 G. Total 38347 9275568 6674859 2184951 1596807 497 753 116529 Source: Sindh Provincial Disaster Management Authority House Damaged Symposium on “Emerging Phenomenon of Untimely Rains / Floods – 2011 in Pakistan” 83 7. 2011-Rains / Flood Damages Need Assessment The post rains/flood damages need asses sment report-2011 related to Irrigation, Drainage and Flood Protection Infrastructure as received from PID Sindh indicates that around Rs. 6.00 billion would be required for restoration of Irrigation Drainage and Flood Control Structures damaged during 2011-Flood season. Sector wise summary of damages assessment for Sindh province is given in Table-4 below. Table-4 SECTOR WISE SUMMARY OF DAMAGES ASSESSMENT FOR SINDH Currency Exchange Rate; 1US$= Rs 87.00 Structure Description Divisions Canal / Water Channels Drains and Appurtenant Structures Flood Protection Embank- Ments Building etc Others Division Wise Total (M.Rs) US Dollars Rohri 189 – 83 65 – 337 3.9 Nasrat 229 – – 21 – 250 2.9 Dad 155 – 13 13 – 181 2.1 Hala Irr 41 – 110 10 – 161 1.9 Nasir 318 – – 21 64 403 4.6 Barrage 50 – – 58 – 107 1.2 Khairpur West 298 – – 35 – 333 3.8 Khairpur East 362 – – 40 – 402 4.6 Mirpur 117 15 – 40 – 172 2.0 Ghotki 154 33 – 75 – 263 3.0 Tubewell – 15 – 120 – 135 1.5 Jamrao 245 370 – 13 – 628 7.2 Mithrao 159 – – 28 – 187 2.1 Thar 173 85 10 51 – 318 3.7 Drainage Sang – 233 – 32 – 264 3.0 Warah 72 – 16 15 – 102 1.2 Saifullah Magsi 41 – 11 6 – 57 0.7 Shahdad Irr 46 – – 30 – 76 0.9 Rice Canal 102 – 13 4 – 119 1.4 Northern Dadu 24 – 32 – – 55 0.6 Southern Dadu 60 – 132 27 – 219 2.5 Shahbaz Irr 5 – 4 1 – 9 0.1 Akram Wah 118 – – 43 – 161 1.8 Fulleli 190 – – 26 – 216 2.5 Guni 129 – – 24 – 153 1.8 Drainage Badin 0 702 – 19 – 721 8.3 Structure Wise Total 3,278 1,453 422 812 64 6,029 69.3 8. Actions Needed Provincial Irrigation Departments and Federal Line Agencies may execute the remaining 2010- Floods damages rehabilitation/remodeling works on top priority basis, so as to ensure completion well before the start of monsoon season 2012. All urgen t nature new flood projects as well as O and M works of flood protection infrastructure may be completed on priority basis before start of Flood Season 2012. Engr. Zafar Iqbal Paper No. 299 84 SIDA / PID Sindh may carry out the restoration and strengthening work of irrigation, drainage and flood protection infrastructure damaged during Monsoon Season 2011 on fast track basis to make the system ready for next monsoon season. The encroachments in flood plains and waterways / drains may be removed by the PID Sindh / SIDA with the help of Districts Administration in order to enhance the discharge capacity of drains and minimize the loss of human lives and damages to the property in future floods. SIDA/PID Sindh may also carry out feasibility studies for long-term measures / permanent solution of drainage problem in order to avoid 2011 like situation in future. The following options may be given due consideration, while formulating proposal ; • Remodeling and enhancing the discharge capacity of existing drainage network on the basis of torrential rains experienced during Monsoon Season 2011; • Construction of additional drains, wherever needed; • Construction of an independent natural Dhoras Network and Syphons across Main Drain for diversion of flows into Dhora Puran (Shakoor Dhand) in order to off-load LBOD System. • Construction of out -fall structure along Kadhan Pateji Outfall Drain ( KPOD) to control tidal impact and sea water intrusion. • Remodeling of weirs and increasing size of inlets and culverts etc. constructed across drains; • Diversion of storm -water to Dhands of Thar desert such as Kakao, Kalankar and abandoned Dhoro Puran etc. • Identification of natural depressions, their strengthening for enhancing their storage capacities and identification of accessible high elevation areas for settlement o f rain/flood affectees in future floods. References: The information provided in the paper has been received from the following key stakeholder organizations: 1. Pakistan Meteorological Department, Islamabad. 2. Water and Power Development Authority, WAPDA house, Lahore. 3. National Disaster Management Authority, Islamabad. 4. Irrigation Department, Government of the Punjab, Lahore. 5. Irrigation and Power Department, Government of Sindh, Karachi. 6. Irrigation Department, Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Peshawar. 7. Irrigation and Power Department, Government of Balochistan, Quetta. 8. Public Works Department, Gilgit-Baltistan, Gilgit. 9. Directorate of Irrigation and Small Dams, Government of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, Muzaffarabad. 10. Director, Irrigation and Hydel Power, Civil Secretariat, FATA, Peshawar.
Filename:
79-84-299-Unprecedented-2001-rains-Zafar-Iqbal.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
85 KB
Categories:
Volume 0034- 2012
Downloads:
1
