Mid Term Symposium on Means of Transportation – Present and Future 139 EFFECT OF HEAVY AXLE LOADING ON PAVEMENT PERFORMANCE ON NATIONAL HIGHWAYS NETWORK IN PAKISTAN By Dr. Shafeeq Ahmed1 and Dr. Shahab Khanzada2 ABSTRACT This study explores the damaging influence of traffic overloading, over inflated truck tires and properties of unbound pavement layers on the performance of flexible pavements. Field data pertaining traffic loading, pavement geomaterials and clima tic conditions from Pakistan was analyzed as a case study using the Mechanistic-Empirical (M-E) design framework based on GAMES (General Analysis of Multi – layered Elastic Systems). Results were presented in terms of Relative Damage Factors (RDFs). Based on the analysis of results it was found that the performance of flexible pavements is sensitive to not only traffic loading and tire inflation pressure, but also significantly to the stiffness of unbound pavement layers. The damaging influence of increase in tire pressure keeps on magnifying with each axle load increment. The flexible pavement performance against distresses such as fatigue cracking and rutting is significantly affected by the stiffness of unbound base course and subgrade, respectively. The Design RDF for the Legal axle load (118 kN) and the mean observed axle load (145 kN) on single axle with dual tires, with mean observed tire pressure of 896 kPa was 5.80 and 11.95, respectively. The damage factors derived in this study can be readily used for network level pavement management. Keywords Traffic overloading, unbound aggregates, Mechanistic -Empirical Desig n, Relative Damage Factor, pavement performance. 1. INTRODUCTION Flexible pavements with hot mix asphalt -concrete (AC) surfacing constitutes the majority of road pavements around the world predominantly due to its low initial/maintenance cost, easy and qu ick construction, superior riding quality and skid resistance, etc. Flexible pavements are considered to be the most complex among the civil engineering structures. The design and performance considerations of flexible pavements includes a multitude of pot entially influencing variables including the complex behavior of pavement geomaterials in each layer, resting on a variety of subgrade soils, under dynamic traffic loads and in an array of climatic conditions. Deficient knowledge or inadequate assembling and/or inappropriate handling of these variables in the design as well as construction stages may adversely affect the performance of flexible pavement structures. More so due to the phenomenal demand shift towards road transportation options , the enhanced pavement serviceability and longevity demand by the society and the worldwide tendency of funds depletion for construction of new and maintenance of large portfolios of existing ageing road networks, pavement technologists and researchers are concentratin g more towards coherent design systems to respond to those demands and for optimal use of resources. The recent advancement in support technologies – particularly, more sophisticated laboratory and in – situ instrumentation, and much efficient computers now available for general use have indeed facilitated the development of analytical or Mechanistic -Empirical (M -E) design systems which are capable of analyzing variabilities in all the design inputs/conditions (Huang 2004). ____________________________________________________________________________________________________ 1. Director (Highway Research & Training Centre), National Highway Authority, Islamabad. 2. Chief Research Officer (Highway Research & Training Centre), National Highway Authority, Islamabad. Dr. Shafeeq Ahmed and Dr. Shahab Khanzada Paper No. 326 140 2. ROAD TRANSPORTATION IN PAKISTAN Road transportation network in Pakistan is not only the lifeline for the country’s own economic and social development, i t is also an integral part of the greater Asia road network and thus opens -up enormous prospects for trade, cultural exc hange and peace in the entire region. Pakistan’s road transport system caters to around 92 percent and 96 percent of nationwide passenger and freight traffic, respectively (NHA 2009). The road network comprises of 259,618 kilometers (km), including 179,290 km. of paved and 80,323 km of unpaved roads. Out of the total road network approximately 12,500 km are classified as National Highways and are being administered by an independent federal road agency, the National Highway Authority (NHA). The se roads comp rise only around 4 % of Pakistan’s total road network; however, they connect all the major cities and industrial centers around the country and carry more than 80 percent of the country’s gross commercial traffic. Therefore the analysis parameters in this study primarily relates to the National Highway system of Pakistan. In one of the latest study (JICA 2006) the traffic volume on the country’s busiest 1800 kms intercity road from the port city of Karachi in the south to Peshawar in the north -west [historically known as grand trunk (GT) road was found to be ranging between 7000 – 23000 vehicles per day with an annual growth rate of around 4%. Composition of cars, buses and trucks was found to be 37%, 24% and 39%, respectively. The truck classification study in Pakistan indicated that 2-axle trucks (with single rear axle on dual tires assembly) dominate the truck types with a share of about 70% in the entire truck fleet in the country (Kamal et al, 2009). More than 90% of trucks carry the pay loads far in exc ess of standard axle / legal loads. In order to check and prevent premature failures, the Government of Pakistan has fixed a legal load limit of 118 kN on a single axle with dual tires. A limit of 828 kPa tire inflation pressure has also been fixed accor dingly. However, it has been observed in various studies that even these upper limits – beyond the standard axle load of 80 kN and 551 kPa tire pressure – are rarely being followed (e.g., Kamal et al. 2009, JICA 2006, NTRC 1995). These studies reveal that i n practice, the load on this axle ranges from 98 kN to as high as 195 kN. In one of the recent study the mean axle load has been observed to be 145 kN. Similarly, the mean tire inflation pressure has been observed to be 896 kPa (NTRC. 1995). In recent yea rs the newly constructed as well as rehabilitated pavements have shown accelerated deterioration and premature failure causing not only waste of public money but also safety hazard and inconvenience to the road users. The recent road condition survey condu cted by NHA (2009), reveals that more than 60% of the network exhibit pavement surface cracking, including more than 23% high severity cracks (crack opening > 10 mm). The survey also indicates that more than 30% of the network has developed permanent defor mation (rutting) of various magnitudes. The Remaining Service Life (RSL) data indicate that nearly 46% of the entire network has RSL of not more than 2 years. The quality of the road infrastructure in Pakistan has severe capacity constraints that obstruct the facilitation and efficient movement of goods to their destination. Poor road maintenance is due to factors such as insufficient funding and overloading of freight vehicles. A 2004 -2005 survey of pavement condition on the federal network revealed that 37 percent of the road network was in poor to very poor condition. The maintenance requirement of these roads is significant and toll revenues and roughly half of the government’s expenditures on these roads. Provincial roads, which are the primary feeder roads for the National Highway Network, are at the bottom of the road hierarchy system. As a result, the government gives more priority for National Highway investment than provincial road investment. The National Highway Authority responsible to maintain approximately 12,000 Km of main highways and motorways through toll rev enues is under pressure to keep -up the maintenance requirements of the country main economic routes. Each year brings revenue deficits t o account for compounding maintenance backlog of highways and motorways. Mid Term Symposium on Means of Transportation – Present and Future 141 3. PAKISTAN’S TRUCKING FLEET The trucking sector carries 96 percent of the total freight traffic. While there are a total of 216,119 registered trucks, the Government of Pakistan (GoP) estimates that only 200,500 of these (93 percent) actually operate on roads. Sixty -five to seventy percent of the total truck fleet consists of single or double-axle trucks. The trucking sector is characterized by the presence of a small fleet of own ers who generally own less than five vehicles. The trucking sector is highly competitive, characterized by low barriers to entry, many small operators, and low freight rates. To maintain high revenues, trucks are overloaded, which damages road quality and increases the demand for higher road investment. Lack of enforcement of regulations on safe operation, crew hours, truck modification, and trailer manufacture increase the risk of accidents. According to the GoP’s Trucking Policy, by 2007, inefficiencies of the trucking sector were estimated at US$2.62 billion/year, consisting mainly of: (i) US $ 1.04 – 1.57 billion/year in extra fuel costs and diesel subsidies , (ii) US $ 0.52 – 0.61 billion/year in additional road user costs , and (iii) a US$0.44 billion/y ear contribution to the infrastructure deficit (The World Bank 2012). The trucking fleet is largely out -dated by several decades and run on underpowered engines. High import tariffs on high capacity multi -axle trucks protect local manufacturers producing low capacity and low-powered trucks and hence prevent the trucking sector from improving its fleet. Over the past 20 years, revenues per km accruing to operators have decreased in real terms by 1.4 percent on average per year. While it might seem unfair to compare Pakistan with these more developed countries, it is with them that Pakistan competes on global markets. Transport time is often lost by trucks needing repairs due to overloading. 4. LEGAL AXLE LOAD LIMITS The pe rmissible load limits for different types of freight vehicles (Trucks) on our National Highways were subject to series of revisions since the year 2000. Each revision entails approximately 20% of increase in loading limits on our national highways. The dam aging effect has been phenomenal as compared to standard axle load of 8 -tons to which our roads are being designed and is an internationally accepted norm. The damage caused by excessive load relative to the standard axle follows a damaging effect which is exponential. The exponent of the damaging effect is 4.5 which means that if an axle weighs 16 tons which is double to a standard axle of 8 -tons would damage the pavement 22 times compared to standard axle. The axle load limits initially enforced by NHA and all the subsequent increase in the permissible limits and new suggested ones have been evaluated technically in terms of its damaging effect on our pavements. Equivalent Axle Load Factors (EALF’s) i.e. in terms of damage to pavements have been computed for different truck loads by AASHTO and UK’s Road Note procedures’s and are shown in Figure-1 and Figure -2 below respectively. The graphical presentation below compares the load limits with revisions to this date and it is quite clear that further relaxat ion in permissible axle loading will drastically reduce pavement life on our national network (S. Khanzada 2013). Dr. Shafeeq Ahmed and Dr. Shahab Khanzada Paper No. 326 142 Figure-1: Enhanced Damaging Effect (AASHTO) Due to Revisions in NHA’s Legal Load Limit Figure-2: Enhanced Damaging Effect (UK Road Note) Due to Revisions in NHA’s Legal Load Limit. It can be seen from the graphical presentation above that the bars in red colour show the newly suggested permissible load limits. The consequence of this relaxation would translate to pronounce damage to our pavements with escalating maintenance cost. For the last few years, NHA is already facing financial deficit for maintenance needs of its network. The figure below (taken from AMP 2011 – 2012) shows that 66% of our roads are in fair condition. This implies that two thirds (2/3) of our roads have approache d terminal serviceability levels and needed to be upgraded to better levels of serviceability (i.e. Good) if the assets are to be maintained. Mid Term Symposium on Means of Transportation – Present and Future 143 5 RESEARCH APPROACH 5.1 Damage impact analysis Damage impact analysis of flexible pavements due to overloadin g, over inflated truck tires and properties of unbound pavement layers has been conducted using the M -E design framework in this study. In the M -E approach, flexible pavements are modeled as layered elastic systems with infinite lateral dimensions, resting on an elastic subgrade layer of infinite depth. Elastic theory implies that each of the pavement layers and the subgrade can be described by their corresponding elastic modulus “ E” and Poisson’s ratio “ µ”. Each layer is assumed to be homogeneous and isotr opic. Tire loads are commonly assumed as circular loads of uniformly distributed vertical stress, equal to tire inflation pressure. The radius of the circular load is given by the following equation (Papagiannakis and Masad 2008): (1) ) i( p a where, a = contact radius in meter (m), p = vertical load in kN and i = tire inflation pressure in kN/m2. Critical pavement responses (e.g., stress, strains and deflections) are calculated using theory of elasticity. The analysis parameters employed in this study are discussed in more detail below. 5.2 Pavement Response model A recently developed analysis t ool for layered elastic system capable to assist in M -E design of pavement structures in Japan has been used for this study. The tool named General Analysis of Multi – layered Elastic System (GAMES), provides an excellent combination of analysis features and computation speed for linear elastic layer system and has been found to produce comparable results with a range of other analysis softwares which are used worldwide (Maina et. al. 2008, JSCE 2005). Critical responses analyzed in this study were horizontal tensile strain (εt) at the bottom of the asphalt – concrete layer and vertical compressive strain (εc) at the top of the subgrade layer as shown in figure-3. These responses were computed for various loading conditions using GAMES. Strains at each point (dots) in the figure were computed and the maximum strain responses were later used as inputs in the distress models (also known as transfer functions for damage analysis). Figure 3: Locations of critical strains under one wheel (with dual tires) of a Single Axle AC Surface Compacted Subgrade Unbound Granular base Unbound Granular Subbase Dr. Shafeeq Ahmed and Dr. Shahab Khanzada Paper No. 326 144 5.2 Pavement distress models The number of load repetition to failure ( Nf) due to maximum εt corresponding to bottom -up cracking failure and εc corresponding to permanent deformation or rutting failure, were computed for a range of loading conditions using the distress functions proposed by Japan Road Association (JRA). The JRA distress models are basically modified and calibrated version of Asphalt Institute (AI) models (Asphalt Institute 1999). Many different versions of AI models were extensively used in the past for the pavement performance studies. However, capitalizing on the recent advancement in the field of flexible pavement engineering in Japan, the current models suggested by JRA have been used for this study. Moreover, the overall results shown in the later part of this paper were also found to be in agreement with th e actual pavement deterioration trends in Pakistan as highlighted in the introduction above, which suggests that the models are generally fit to be used for the Pakistani conditions. In the M-E design system proposed by JRA, a pavement section is consider ed to be failed when either 20% of the lane area is cracked and/or the pavement structure exhibits 15 mm of rut depth (JRA 2001). The equation predicting the allowable number of load repetition to fatigue cracking ( Nff) is a function of tensile strain (εt) and asphalt concrete mix stiffness (modulus) “E” according to: 3 a . 0.8542 a . 3.291 c 5– f f E 1 1 . 6.617 . C . 1 a N (2) where, 10 C M (3) 0.69 – 100 VFA 4.84 M (4) And VFA is volume of voids filled with asphalt binder (%). A typical VFA value of 73% as suggested by NHA General Specifications (1998) has been used in this analysis. 3 a and 2 a . 1 a are calibration constants: /1 a . a K 1 a (5) Where Ka is a correction coefficient for asphalt concrete layer thicknesses (hac) and is expressed as: e . 7.83 10 x 8.27 1 a K (hac) 0.11–0.11– (6) The values of 3 a and 2 a . 1 a are equal to 5.229×10 4, 1.344 and 3.018, respectively. The equation predicting the allowable number of load repetition to permanent deformation or rutting ( ) is a function of vertical compressive strain (εc) at the top of the subgrade and is expressed as: ) 2 s 4.477 – ( c . ) 9 – ( ] ) 10 ( [ x (1.365 . 1 s fd N 1 (7) Where 2 s and 1 s are calibration constants equal to 2.134 x 104 and 0.819, respectively. Mid Term Symposium on Means of Transportation – Present and Future 145 5.3 Pavement Layer Properties Table-1 shows the properties of each layer, assumed for this analysis. The pavement section represents typical design thicknesses and material properties (i.e. generally strong section in the table) utilized in Pakistan for the National Highway design traffic of about 25 million Equivalent Standard Axle Loads (ESALs) over a design life of 10 years, in accordance with AASHTO pavement design method. The elastic moduli of pavement materials have been wor ked out from the typical California Bearing Ratio (CBR) test values, which is the common test being performed in Pakistan, both in the laboratories and field. The correlations proposed by AASHTO design guide have been used for this purpose. Table-1:Pavement Layer Properties Layer Thickness (cm) Modulus (MPa) Poisson Ratio AC Surface 5 225 – 6850 0.35 AC Base 10 0.35 Aggregate Base 25 Strong layer = 193 Weak layer = 120 0.40 Gran. Sub base 35 Strong layer = 117 Weak layer = 70 0.40 Subgrade – Strong layer = 72 Weak layer = 31 0.45 5.4 Axle Load and Tire Inflation Pressure The primary focus of this study was to assess the damaging impact of legal axle load and the observed excess axle load. However, in order to make this study more useful for pavement designers and road administration agencies for rational and economical design of flexible pavements, the analysis variables were enhanced to include a wide range of load and tire pressures as shown in Table-2. Table-2: load and tire pressure conditions Analysis Conditions Range Axle load 58 kN – 176 kN Tire inflation pressure 551 kPa – 965 kPa 5.5 Seasonal variations in Climate One of the major advantages of the M -E design approach is the ability to consider climatic condition directly into the design process. The interaction of climatic factors with pavement materials significantly affects the performance of flexible pavements. Particularly, the sensitivity of asphalt concrete mix stiffness (modulus) to temperature variation has been well recognized (AASHTO 2002). Mean monthly air temperatures data, derived from the 60 years` (1931-1990) historical climate data of Pakistan (Khan 2010), has been used in this analysis. The mean monthly pavement temperatures were obtained using the following relation which was originally presented by AI (1999) and also adopted by JRA (2001): 3 10 ) 10.16 z ( 9 2.54 – 10.16 z 2.54 1 M M ap (8) where, Mp : mean monthly Pavement Temperature (oC) Ma : mean monthly air Temperature (oC) z : depth below the surface (cm). Dr. Shafeeq Ahmed and Dr. Shahab Khanzada Paper No. 326 146 The temperature at the upper third point of the AC base layer has been used in this analysis (Huang 2004). A number of AC Temperature -Stiffness (moduli) correlation are available in literature. For this study the stiffness values were worked-out using the correlation established by Scott Wilson pavement engineering, Nottingham, UK (S cott Wilson 1998). Table -3 shows the mean monthly air and mean monthly pavement temperatures and their corresponding AC moduli. Table-3: AC stiffness (moduli) corresponding to mean monthly temperatures in Pakistan Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Mean Monthly air Temp (oC) 10 13 17 23 28 31 30 29 27 23 12 10 Mean Monthly Pavement Temp (oC) 15 18 22 29 35 38 37 36 34 29 17 15 Modulus of AC Layer (MPa) 6850 5290 3560 1450 480 225 300 380 660 1450 5790 6850 6 ANALYSIS OF RESULTS 6.1 Interpretation of results The influence of truck traf fic overloading and unbound pavement layers analyzed in this study is presented in terms of Relative Damage Factors (RDFs). RDF can be expressed as the damage caused to a pavement structure by a set of input conditions (i.e. axle loading, tire inflation pr essure, material properties and climate) relative to the damage produced by Standard conditions. In this study the standard load and tire pressure were assumed to be the same as suggested by AASHTO guide (i.e. 80 kN load on single axle with a set of dual t ires, inflated to 551 kPa each).The RDFs, corresponding to fatigue cracking and permanent deformation or rutting can be expressed as: N N RDF i f f s f f f (9) and, N N RDF i d f s d f d (10) where, RDFf is the relative damage factor for fatigu e cracking, RDF d is the relative damage factor for rutting. N s f f and N s d f are number of repetition for fatigue cracking and rutting under standard axle loading conditions, respectively. N i f f and N i d f are allowable numbers of repetition for fatigue cracking and rutting under any arbitrar y loading conditions, respectively. The large r value between the two RDF values is selected as the Design RDF. Mid Term Symposium on Means of Transportation – Present and Future 147 6.2 Effect of axle load and tire inflation pressure The results show that the performance of flexible pavement is sensitive to not only axle load but also to tire inflation pressure as pres ented in Figure -4 to Figure -7. Figure -4 shows the effect of axle overloading and tire inflation pressure (Tp) on Asphalt Concrete (AC) fatigue life with Mean Monthly Pavement Temperature (M.M.T). It was observed that the RDF fs for axle loads between 60 – 90 kN, under all Tp range remained under 2.5.However, the RDF f sharply increases beyond the 90 kN axle loads. This figure also shows that for any fixed axle load, increasing the Tp resulted in increased RDFfs. This implies that fatigue performance is highly sensitive to Tp. The phenomenon can be observed even at the standard axle load (80 kN), where the RDF f increases from 1.0 to 1.66. However, the damaging impact widens for higher axle loads, e.g. at the Legal axle load (118 kN) and the observed axle load (145 kN), the RDF f increases by 2.3 and 4.6 points, respectively (for Tp ranging from 551 kPa to 965 kPa). Figure-5 shows that while the Tp has minimal effect on rutting performance, the axle load has significant effect. This figure also indicates that for the axle load ranging between 60 – 98 kN, the RDFd remained around 2.0. However, it keeps on increasing until a maximum value of 17.0 at the axle load of 176 kN. The difference in RDF d s for each individual load increment remained under 1.0, for all Tp`s, which substantiate the observation that Tp has minimal impact on the rutting performance. Figure-6 shows the Design RDFs for all loads and Tp ranges. The Design RDFs reveal that pavement performance in Pakistan is more sensitive to fatigue failure compared to rutting failure. This result confirms the actual in-service condition of pavements in Pakistan, as revealed by surveys conducted by NHA and mentioned in section-1. Figure-7 summarizes the effect of axle load and Tp on the design life Figure-5 : Relative Damage Factors for Rutting Failure (RDFd) Figure 3 Relative Damage Factors for Rutting Failure (RDFd) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Axl e Load (kN) RDF d (M . M . T) Ti re Pressures 551 kPa 689 kPa 828 kPa 896 kPa 965 kPa 0 5 10 15 20 25 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Axl e Load (kN) RDF f (M . M . T) Ti re Pressures 551 kPa 689 kPa 828 kPa 896 kPa 965 kPa Figure-4 : Relative Damage Factors for Fatigue Failure (RDFf) Figure 2 Relative Damage Factors for Fatigue Failure (RDFf) Figure-6 : Representative Design RDFs for all loads and Tp ranges Figure 5 Representative Design RDFs for all loads and Tp ranges 0 5 10 15 20 25 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Axl e Load (kN) Desi gn RDF (M . M . T) Ti re Pressures 551 kPa 689 kPa 828 kPa 896 kPa 965 kPa Figure-7 : Effect of axle load and Tire pressure on design life Fig.6 Effect of axle load and Tire pressure on design life 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Axl e Load (kN) Pavement Li fe (years) Ti re Pressures 551 kPa 689 kPa 828 kPa 896 kPa 965 kPa Dr. Shafeeq Ahmed and Dr. Shahab Khanzada Paper No. 326 148 of the pavement structure. The effect on pavement life expectancy due to tire pressure can be observed even at the standard axle load of 80 kN, where the pavement life drops from 10 to 6 years when the Tp was increased from 551 kPa to 965 kPa. At the legal and observed axle loads, the pavement life may be expected to be between 1.5 to 3 years and between 0.8 to 1.2 years, respectively, depending on Tp. 6.3 Effect of stiffness of unbound aggregate layers Figure-8 and Figure -9 show the influence of stiffness of unbound geo -material and subgrade on AC fatigue and pavement rutting performance, respectively. It was observed that AC fatigue performance is significantly affected by the stiffness of unbound base course and to a lesser extent by subbase layer`s stiffness (figure-8). On the other hand, figure-9 reveals that the pavement rutting performance is almost entirely dependent on the stiffness of subgrade. It may be observed that for weak subgrade, the RDF d raises to a large value of 88.32 at 176.58 kN axle load and 828 kPa Tp. Finally, figure -10 shows the design RDFs at 828 kPa (legal Tp) under various stiffness of geo-materials : 7 CONCLUSIONS In this study, the damaging influence of traffic overloading, tire inflation pressure and stiffness of unbound pavement layers on the performance of flexible pavement was analyzed. Conclusions drawn from this study may be summarized as follows: 1) The performance of flexible pavement is sensitive not only to axle loading but also significantly to tire inflation pressure. The damaging influence of increase in tire pressure keeps on magnifying with each axle load increment. Figure-8 : Effect of geo -materials stiffness on pavement fatigue performance Figure 5.9 Effect of geo -materials stiffness on pavement fatigue performance 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Load (kN) RDF f at Tp 828 kPa General y Strong Structure W eak Subgrade W eak Sub-Base W eak Base Course 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Load (kN) RDF d at Tp 828 kPa General y Strong Structure W eak Subgrade W eak Sub-Base W eak Base Course Figure-9 : Effect geo-materials stiffness on pavement rutting performance (Tp 828 kPa) Figure 5.10Effect geo-materials stiffness on pavement rutting performance(Tp 828 kPa) Figure-10 : Design RDFs under various geo -material conditions (Tp 828 kPa) Figure 5.11 Design RDFs under various geo -material conditions (Tp 828 kPa) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Load (kN) Desi gn RDF at Tp 828 kPa General y Strong Structure W eak Subgrade W eak Sub-Base W eak Base Course Mid Term Symposium on Means of Transportation – Present and Future 149 2) With a mean o bserved tire pressure of 896 kPa, the Design RDF for the legal axle load (118 kN) and the mean observed axle load (145 kN) on single axle with dual tires was found to be 5.80 and 11.95, respectively. 3) The flexible pavement performance against distresses such as fatigue cracking and rutting is significantly affected by the stiffness of unbound base course and subgrade. 4) The damage factors derived in this study can be readily used for network level pavement management. 5) The damaging effect of loads and further relaxation on permissible legal load limits needs no further emphasis. Our road pavements are being punis hed to phenomenal limits which defy all standard design procedures. The trucking industry is further pushing NHA for relaxations in the axle loading limits. This will escalate our maintenance needs for which resources are stretched to the limits. 6) Strict control of axle loading need to be enforced to sa feguard our fragile economy to preserve our future investments. National policy towards this issue should be formulated for zero tolerance. 7) Gradual replacement of ailing trucking fleet should be encou raged through import of multi-axle turbo-diesel trucks on subsidized rates. REFERENCES 1) AASHTO. : Guide for Design of Pavement Structures , American Association of State Highway and Transport Officials, Washington, DC, II-20, 1993. 2) AASHTO. : Guide for the Mechanistic -Empirical Design of new and rehabilitated pavement structures, American Association of State Highway and Transport Officials, Washington, DC, II -20, 2002. 3) Asphalt Institute, Thickness Design of Asphalt Pavement for Highway and streets . Manual Series No. 1, 9th edition, (ISBN: 9781934154014), 1999. 4) Huang. Y. H. : Pavement Analysis and Design , 2 nd edition, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliff, N.J., 2004. 5) Japan Road Association. : Pavement Design and Construction Guide, (in Japanese) 2001. 6) JICA and NIPPON KOEI CO. LTD. : Pakistan Transport plan study, 2006. 7) JSCE. : GAMES, Gene ral Analysis of Multi -layered Elastic Systems , Japan Society of Civil Engineers, (in Japanese) 2005. 8) Kamal M. A. and Luqman Sarwar. : Pakistan highway pavement wear & degradation: a study of traffic and axle overloading, International Journal of Logistics and Transport, Thailand, 2009. 9) Khan S. U. : Climate Classification of Pakistan , BALWOIS, 4 th International Conference, Ohrid, Republic of Macedonia. 2010. 10) Maina J. W., Denneman. E. and De Beer. M.: Introduction of New Road Pavement Response Modeling Software by means of Benchmarking . 27th South African Transport Conference, Pretoria South Africa, 2008. 11) NHA, General Specifications, National Highway Authority, Pakistan,1998. Dr. Shafeeq Ahmed and Dr. Shahab Khanzada Paper No. 326 150 12) NHA. : Annual Maintenance Plan F.Y. 2008-2009, National Highway Authority, Pakistan, 2009. 13) NTRC. : Axle Load Study on National Highways , National Transport Research Center, Pakistan, 1995. 14) Papagiannak is A. T. and Masad E. A. : Pavement Design and Materials, John Wiley & sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey. (ISBN-13: 978-0-471-21461-8), 2008. 15) Shahab Khanzada, : Requirement of Important Policy For Trucks, Construction Machinery In 2013 – 14 Budget, Report for Chairman NHA, 2013. 16) Scott. Wilson Pavement Engineering, Indirect Tensile Stiffne ss Testing , 10 Faraday Building Nottingham Science & Technology Park University Boulevard Nottingham, NG7 2QP, Nottingham, UK. 1998. 17) The World Bank, Pakistan Strategic Environmental, Poverty and Social Assessment of Trade and Transport Sector Reforms: Report No. 71812-PK, December 2012.
Filename:
137-138-139-150-Effect-of-Shafeeq-Ahmed.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
877 KB
Categories:
Volume 0037- 2015
Downloads:
13
