PAPER NO. 251 PERFORMANCE OF MASONRY BUILDINGS DURING 8™ OCTOBER HAZARA-KASHMIR EARTHQUAKE IN PAKISTAN By PROFESSOR DR. M. ILYAS AND S. H. FAROOQ Professor Dr. M. Ilyas, and S. H. Farooq Paper No. 251 PERFORMANCE OF MASONRY BU ILDINGS DURING 8™ OCTOBER HAZARA-KASHMIR EARTHQUAKE IN PAKISTAN Professor Dr. M. Ilyas*, and S. H. Farooq** ABSTRACT An earthquake measuring 7.6 on the Richter scale struck Mansehra, Muzaffarabad, Garhi Habib Ullah, Balakot, Bagh, Battagram, Battal, AHai, Naran valley, Neelurn valley, Jhelum valley, Islamabad, Lahore etc. on 8lh October 2005 at 0852 PST. The epicenter of the earthquake was located near Muzaffrabad. As per official figures, about 74000 are dead, 70000 are injured and 2.5 million families have been displaced. The heaviest damage was observed in Muzaffarabad, Bagh, Allai and Balakot area where entire villages were destroyed. The local traditional stone / block / Brick masonry structures in the area were not designed to withstand the earthquake of such magnitude. This caused considerable damage including major cracks to complete collapse in l oad bearing members. Unreinforced masonry (URM) structures were damaged commonly due to poor construction practice of load bearing walls. The damage level depended on the distance from surface faulting. Most of the destroyed villages were subjected to the full intensity earthquake vertical and shear motion with negligible attenuation since they were very near to the ruptured zone. This paper attempts to evaluate the behavior of masonry structures based on the type of masonry used in places like Balakot, Bagh, Muzaffarabad and several other places. Quite a few masonry buildings had used earthquake resistant features like lintel bands and corner reinforcements. The cr acking and failure patterns of such buildings have also been examined and recommendation for future type of structur es will also be proposed in order to educate the local population to adopt suitable earthquake resistant construction practice in the area which could ensure least life as well as property damage. Key Word: Seismic activity, Stone/block/brick Unreinfo rced Masonry, Structural Damages, Crack Pattern 1- Introduction The epicenter of the earthquake was 34.493°N, 73 629E, about 90 km NE of Islamabad. The focal depth was reported to be 26 krn (USGS). Earthquakes in the northern mountainous areas of Pakistan and adjacent parts of India and Afghanistan are the result of the movement of the Indian plate sub-ducting north beneath the Eurasian plate at a rate of 40 rnm/year (USGS) as evident from and the area affected by this earthquake is a foreland of Hindu-Kush ranges including the highest peaks in the world. The epicenter and contour showing slip on the fault surface are shown in Fig. 1 (b). The traditional masonry structures had no earthquake resistant features and suffered considerable damage. Unreinforced masonry structures are the most vulnerable during an earthquake. Normally they are designed for vertical loads and since masonry has adequate compressive strength, the structures behave well as long as the loads are vertical. When such a masonry structure is subjected to lateral inertial loads during an earthquake, the walls develop shear and flexural stresses. A masonry wall can also undergo in-plane shear stresses if the inertial forces are in the plane of the wall. Shear failure in the form of diagonal cracks is observed due to this. However, catastrophic collapses take place when the wall experiences out-of-plane flexure failure. Masonry buildings with light roofs such as tiled roofs are more vulnerable to out-of-plane vibrations since the top edge can undergo large deformations. Studying types of ma sonry construction, their performance and failure patterns helps in improving the design and detailing aspects. After the 8 1″ October Kashmir-Hazara earthquake the authors visited the affected areas twice to study the damages to masonry buildings. This paper present the damages observed and the performance of masonry structures during the earthquake to determine the causes of failure. ‘Civil Engineering Department. University of Engineering & Technology, Lahore, Pakistan “Research Assistant Civil Engineering Department, University of Engineering & Technology, Lahore, Pakistan 103 Professor Dr. M. llyas, and S. H. Farooq Paper No. 251 • Poor quality of construction, like the use of weak materials, poor workmanship, inadequate skill in bounding units, improper connection between the members, etc., results in the failure of the structures in the damaged structures. • Failure of connections between wall and wall, roof and wall and foundation and wall may cause failure of structure. Heavy weight of roof and poor connections with other elements may result in severe damages. • Mostly in stone masonry huts, the poor maintenance of timber roof failed as a result of termite attacks. Moreover, the affected timber components of the roof were supporting thick mud layers, which enhanced the damage due to its heavy self weight. • Ground conditions were not taken into acc ount during construction of the structures which caused major damage. The slope instability, due to earthquake shaking, was identified as another major cause of collapse in many structures. In such cases, deep pile foundations would have avoided the failure. 5- Recommendation / Suggestion for Future Construction of Structures. After visiting the affected areas following suggestions / recommendations are rendered to be adopted for future construction and to minimize the devastating effects of any future earthquake in the area which seismically active zone:- 5.1- During an earthquake, the loss of human lives is mainly due to the collapse of kucha type of structures. These structures can be regarded as non-engineered as their design does not follow the standards to resist the lateral earthquake forces. Pakistan as well as most of the earthquake-prone developing countries has a serious problem with these non-engineered structures. Unfortunately, this problem is increasing rather than decreasing because of growing population, poor economic conditions, scarcity of wood, cement and steel, lack: of understanding of earthquake features, etc. 5.2- It was observed during this visit that a number of masonry structures were damaged due slope failure and improper foundations. It is strongly recommended to carry out proper soil investigation and proper footing type according to soil investigation. Construction on unstable slopes should be avoided; otherwise it is necessary to stabilize the slope before constructing any structure. Mat/Raft foundation should be made mandatory for residential buildings or pile foundations and unstable slopes will be the most appropriate solution. 5.3- The properly engineered, having good construction material, well constructed and designed structures have performed well during this earthquake. The construction of properly designed light weight single storey or double storey buildings will be safe in the area and construction of multistory buildings without proper seismic design should be avoided. 5.4- Horizontal lintel band should be provided to reduce the effects of lateral forces and to make the box type of structure and to reduce the unsupported length for less slenderness effect. Proper reinforced connection should also be provided to improve the seismic behavior of the masonry structures. 5.5- The building must be regular and symmetrical in shape. The geometric and mass centroids must coincide to avoid torsional moment. Further, shear walls must be symmetrically placed. 5.6- Reinforcing bars should be provided at the corners and the junctions of the walls. Connection between wall and roof should be made carefully. Corners and junctions of the walls should be strengthened by providing wood planks, steel bars, wire mesh, etc. Cantilevers, free standing walls and free standing columns must be avoided besides irregular geometry of the structure. 107 Professor Dr. M. llyas, and S. H. Farooq Paper No. 251 7- Acknowledgement The authors are thankful to University of Engineering & Technology, Lahore, Pakistan and Higher Education Commission, Pakistan for providing help and assistance for the above research work. 8- References • Structural Masonry by Arnold W. Hendry • Civil Engineering Material by Nail Jackson and Ravindra K. Dhir • Brickwork by John Carruthers • Handbook of B/ick Masonry Construction by Mulligan • Calvi, G., Magenes, G., 1994, Experimental results on unreinforced masonry shear walls damaged and repaired, 10th IB2MaC, Calgary, Canada, 509-518. • Jabarov, M., Kozharinov, S., Lunyov, A., 1980, Strengthening of damaged masonry by reinforced mortar layers, 7th WCEE, Istanbul, vol. 6, 73-80 • Residential Masonry by John L. Feirer and Gilbert R. Hutchings 108

Filename: Paper251.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 519 KB
Categories: Volume 0029- 2006
Author: Professor Dr. M. Ilyas and S. H. Farooq