PAPER NO. 256 DISPUTE RESOLUTION UNDER ENGINEERING CONTRACTS BY BALAL A. KHAWAJA Balal A. Khawaja Paper No. 256 DISPUTE RESOLUTION UNDER ENGINEERING CONTRACTS (Balal A. Khwaja) B.Sc. (Civil Engg.), LL.B, LL.M (London) Advocate Supreme Court DISPUTE – A NECESSARY INGREDIENT IN A CONTRACTUAL SITUATION A well-known author on constructi on disputes has described the inevitability of conflicts and disputes under an engineering contract in the following words: “Many involved in the construction industry believe that conflict is inevitable and that this is promoted by the standard forms of contract used. However, it is axiomatic that the potential for conflict is inherent in any contractual situation. This potential for conflicts, disputes and claims always exists and it is beneficial to recognize this from the beginning of any contractual relationship.” It thus being undisputable that disputes are inseparable from engineering contract’s administration and implementation, as indeed from any type of contracts, procedures have to be developed and made part(s) of the contracts to deal with these disputes efficiently and without causing undue inconvenience or prejudi ce to the pa rties to the contract. A bird-eye view of the current standard engineering contracts formats will bring into focus the multi-dimensional effo rts being made by the industry towards the development of a dispute resolution mechanis m which will have the obviously desirable attributes of efficiency, neutrality and opera tional flexibility. We find that well-known formats such as FIDIC, ICE, NEC, JCT all have, over the years, e ndeavoured to evolve their respective dispute resolution provisions on this basis and these have regularly been amended in successive editions in the light of the experience gained through their use in the earlier editions. The unmistakable directio n of this effort has been towards ready availability, neutrality and cap acity to provide quick and ge nerally acceptable solutions. The days of keeping dispute resolution cl auses away from engineering contracts a popular device to obstruct efficient resolution of the usual issues that invariably crop up during the contract implementation phase, are gone and will hopefully never come back. WHAT IS A DISPUTE? As soon as we mention the word dispute we impliedly acknowledge the need for a precise and clear definition of the said te rm. As is commonly understood, a dispute is taken to be a disagreement or argument between two parties. It emanates from unresolved issues which, in turn, mean assertion of a material proposition by one party and its denial by the other. In other words, 1. Disputes arise when the issues are not resolved in time; Balal A. Khawaja Paper No. 256 2. Dispute is a conflict of clai ms or rights. A dispute imp lies an assertion of a right or claim by one party and denial or ignorance thereof by another; 3. The repudiation by the other party may be either express (by words) or implied (by conduct); 4. Dispute may include dispute of law as well as of fact; It may be pointed out that the word “dispute” is not to be confused with words like contention, disputation, and default. Howeve r, words such as controversy, claim or difference may be used interchangeably for the word dispute. There can be different types of disputes such as major or minor, present and future, simple and complex etc. The author of a dispute resolution provision has to be very clear and precise as to what type or types of disputes will fall within the scope of such dispute resolution provisions of the contract. A careful drafting of this aspect of the scope of dispute resolution provisions can save and spare the parties lot of otherwise wholly unnecessary debate as to whether a particular dispute is or is not amenable to the dispute resolution provision provided in the contract. RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN DISPUTE RESOLUTION CLAUSES The standard dispute resolution cl auses in vogue during the last quarter of the last century usually provided for dispute resoluti on under engineering cont racts by requiring reference of disputes to the Engineer in the first place, giving the Engineer certain time to decide such disputes and then either pa rty, being unhappy with such decision of the Engineer, could go to arbitration under the agre ed arbitration clause. This option to go to arbitration would also become available to the parties where the Engineer failed to notify his decision within the prescribed period. The im portant features of this scheme of things was that the recourse to arbitration was possi ble only after the disput e(s) in question had first been referred to the Engineer for his decision. This procedur e attracted several objections over the period of time, the most important being that the requirement of reference to the Engineer wa s unnecessarily repeti tive and devoid of any meaning in as much as the dispute being referred could ha ve only arisen because of a position adopted by the same Engineer thereon earlier. So the reference to the Engineer, at best, was a request for a review of his own earlier decisi on which put the Engineer in an unenviable position under the dispute resolution mechanis m and robbed the provision of all meaning and effect. Add to it the fact that the Engineer was engaged by the employer and served at his pleasure and the said provision became even illusory. Towards the end of the last century the movement for taking the Engineer’s role out of the dispute resolution mechanism gain ed momentum and various ways and means were developed in this regard. Instead of the requirement of referring the dispute, in the first place, to the Engineer, a pre-agreed Expert Adjudicator was substituted for the Engineer. Similarly, a Disput e Review Board (DRB) comprising of 3 members, one nominated by each party and the third ag reed upon by the said two nominees, was introduced as an alternative. Detailed rule s and procedures were developed for the appointment of the Expert Adjudicator / D RB as well as for the conduct of proceedings by these bodies. There is yet another option which is being exercised with increasing popularity which is to replace the Expert Adjudicator / DRB with some other well-known Alternate Dispute Resolution (ADR) proced ure. This procedure may be Mediation Conciliation, Mini trial, Facilitation, Partne ring, Rent a Judge and some other kind of ADR procedure. Balal A. Khawaja Paper No. 256 It is thus quite clear that the thrust of deve lopments in the field of dispute resolution over the past decade or so has been to make th e dispute resolution mechanism more and more independent, neutral and readily accessible. The contractor has been afforded the right to participate in the pre-arbitral process, whethe r it is Neutral Expert, or DRB or any of the various ADR procedures, as all these appointments are with his consent and participation. Usually, there can be recourse to the agreed mechanism at any time during the currency of the contract and, subject to any time-bar provisions in the cont ract or under the law, even after the completion, abandonment or termination of the contract. THE NEED FOR DISPUTE RESOLUTION MECHANISM IN ENGINEERING CONTRACTS It is well-known that the pres ence of a balanced and easily accessible dispute resolution mechanism in the contract is taken as acceptable assurance by prospective tenderers that the usual disput es arising during the executi on of work shall be fairly settled either by the employer who will be awar e of the presence of the dispute resolution provisions or through recour se to such provisions. Th is welcome assurance also encourages the tenderers to quote more competit ive prices for the proposed project. It is, therefore, fair to say that the inclusion of a balanced and user-friendly dispute resolution provision is, in fact, in the interest of an employer. On the contrary, absence of such provisions generates suspicions and apprehensions of all sorts. Most of the professionally desirable tenderers either avoid participation in such cases or add reasonable and at times more than reasonable amount to the intende d tender price by way of protection for non- availability of an expeditious dispute resolu tion arrangement in the contract. No serious employer can possibly like either of these two situations. THE DOMESTIC SCENE The domestic scene regarding dispute resolution under engineering contracts regretfully does not offer a very rosy pi cture. Any dispute resolution mechanism presupposes the willingness and the capacity of the parties to meaningfully participate in such process and to take th e required decisions. Given that the government, semi- government and / or government controlled de partments, agencies and corporations are by far the busiest employers of engineering contr acts in the country, it has to be said that there is a pathetic lack of willingness on their part to effectively participate in any dispute resolution effort. There are several well-known reasons for this unfortunate attitude such as: i) The word claim or dispute is treated as a dirty word by these employers. It has been assigned a negative connotation and is treated as some kind of a conspiracy by a contractor to extrac t money or other concessions out of the employer. The immediate response from the employer and / or the Engineer, therefore, is to reject the claim, at times even without entering into any meaningful dialogue with the contractor or having carefully examined it. There are well-known reas ons for this undesirable attitude, most importantly being an utter la ck of any background or training in contract management and administ ration and the resultant lack of familiarity with even the basics of dispute management. Serious training of Balal A. Khawaja PaperNo.256 project staff within all these employers with a view to expose them to the latest developments in engineering disputes management is surprisingly unknown. The decision makers within these employers invariably try to cover this lack of experience and exposure with arrogant and professionall y unsustainable decision making. It is very rare that where outs ide independent consu ltants are acting as the Engineer who are, by virtue of thei r private sector backgrounds perhaps better placed to objectively advise the employer, will seriously challenge or appose such unprofessional decision making on the part of the employer. ii) Imbued with this conviction that a cl aim is a dirty trick which is sought to be played by the contractor at the expense of the empl oyer, the entire process of claim verification and evaluation becomes a futile exercise aimed at finding ways and means to somehow reject the claim. In doing so no respect is shown even for the letter and spirit of the contract between the parties, muchless the practice and usage of the industry or the stated views of well-known experts on such issues. In the exceptional case where the engineer goes out of the usual way and seeks prior consent of the employer for the notification of his determination of any consequence, such consent of the Empl oyer (usually required unde r the contract before notification of the Engin eer determination) is ar bitrarily and unreasonably withheld by the employer. The period of such unexplained withholding of consent can literally be anything and may even ex tend up to the very end of the project. The permissible requi rement of prior consent of the employer for the notification of any substantial decision by the Engineer (now practically all decisions of the Engineer except the dispute resolution clause decision) is thus being abus ed through such acts of delays and prevention on the part of the employer. The level of interference by the employer in the performance of cont ractual duties by the Engineer takes care of any prospects of the Engine er making a determination which the employer really does not want him to make. iii) The reluctance on the part of the employer to take the responsibility for any contractual decision carrying financial consequences (and all contractual decisions under engineering contracts invariably have financial consequences) has its roots in two ve ry well-known reasons. Firstly, the prevailing atmosphere within such employer departments / agencies / corporations is not conduc ive to the taking of such decisions. Accusing fingers are raised thoughtlessly and almo st as a matter of routine even and usually by those who otherwise generall y have no clue as to the facts or relevant particulars of the matter in which such decision may have been given by a particular employee. Th e prospects of inconvenient and unending series of enquiries and i nvestigations with all attending undesirable publicity are daunting enough to persuade the decision maker to avoid the decision. iv) The other well-known restraini ng factor in this regard is the role which is being played by the audit departments of these government agencies and Balal A. Khawaja Paper No. 256 corporations. The usefulness and, therefore, need for regular audit is apparently undeniable par ticularly in a socio ec onomic milieu as is ours but the defining parameters for the role of audit, equally importantly, have to be drawn very carefully and preci sely. In every case of award and implementation of an engineering c ontract, it is specifically laid down who will be responsible for the admi nistration / implementation of the contract and what powers will be exercisable by the various dealing functionaries and their authorized representatives. So long as the Contractor can show that there has been no violat ion or transgression of these parameters while taking decisi ons on the day-to-day issues no auditing principles should permit a ny audit officer to second guess the decision making of such authorized personnel in relation to the day-to-day issues, arising during the implementati on of the Contract. Merely because some of these decisions were given against the stated position of the department / employer and resulted in some financial consequences should not be a basis, a valid basis in an y case, for calling into question the validity of these decisions. There are examples galore where the dealing staff of the department has been harassed no end for performing their duties and functions under and accord ing to the contract. This cannot encourage decision making within the dealing officials of the department and their representatives. v) The prevailing attitudes in such departments etc are and this is most unfortunate, that an officer of the department can never be wrong and a contractor can never be right. This approach has grown over the years out of the utter lack of any accountability process for the Employers and their dealing staff which has understandably encouraged them to adopt such eminently unreasonable positions against the contractors. It is very rare that a position once so adopted is ever reviewed and recalled / modified. Lack of knowledge about the principles involved and the latest developments in the usage and practi ce relevant to engineering contracts add fuel to this fire. vi) Finally, one finds a ve ry visible distinction in the attitudes of these departments etc towards the performa nce of their oblig ations under the engineering contracts. It can very eas ily be seen that two sets of values are being adopted depending upon whether the Engineer and the Contractor are foreigners or they belong to the dome stic industry. It is an unpleasant truth that we tend to be more unreasonable and even harsh when dealing with local consultants / contractors as compared with the same entities from abroad. I cannot help submitting that in this regard part of the blame, and more than a small part must go to some of our local consultants and contractors belonging to the public sector who could have but did not care to make a difference in this regard and make their respect contributions towards the growth and development of healthy and balanced norms. AGENDA FOR REFORM In view of the above rather chao tic conditions prevailing in the domestic industry, dispute resolution under engi neering contracts needs to be thoroughly reviewed and Balal A. Khawaja Paper No. 256 improved. The alternative to inclusion of a dispute resolution mechanism before a private forum viz: litigation in courts is so unattractive and de-motivating that its adoption will invariably drive up the cost of the projects under these contracts. For the same reason, it can so easily lend itself to abuse. Yet anothe r undesirable consequence of absence of an efficient dispute resolution provision will be the pressure for executing poor quality work. An employer will thus end up paying on extra price which may not be negligible and, in any case, wholly unnecessary, not to me ntion the further loss in the shape of poor quality work. Presently, different departments / agencies involved in undertaking development projects are using different c ontract formats for their procur ement effort. Some of these formats are the heritage of our colonial past which we have never bothered to review or amend in the light of subsequent devel opments in the country. These formats are hopelessly one-sided and loaded in favour of the Employer and against the Contractor. Under these formats the Employer can never do any wrong and is invariably the judge in his own cause. The departments using these formats are understandably unduly defensive of these formats and do not want to part with the same. Several studies have revealed that use of such formats is the main reason for the time and cost overruns which afflict the execution and completion of related projects . For the same reason in an over-whelming majority of cases, the quality of executed work is poor and well below the prescribed standards. Pakistan Engineering Council ta king note of the above situation undertook preparation of standard country -specific contract formats for different times of projects. This effort resulted in production of a suite of documents which reflect the prevailing realities / attitudes in the country while addressing the various areas of concern in the said earlier contract formats. While it can not be anybody’s case that these documents reflect the ultimate wisdom and experience on the subject, the same are nevertheless a badly needed and necessary first step in the righ t direction. Adoption of a standard contract format for procurement by different department s and agencies can cl early be helpful in eliminating some, if not most, of the mo re offensive procurement procedures and practices in these departments. It can at the same time encourage a more enlightened participation by the bidders / contractors in th e process of procurement. All this can only be to the ultimate benefit of these departments who can expect more competitive and broad based participation in their procurement process. There is also an undeniable need to develop and strengthen the capacity of the said employers to manage disputes which can only be achieved through constant education and training of the dealing staff. The cultu re which encourages fair settlements of disputes and taking of necessary decisions for the same should be introduced and allowed to take roots. It should not be considered sinful to prefer process, negotiate and entertain claims as the same are unavoidable particularly where a contractor is to perform as per agreed standards. The current audit procedures ought to be reviewed to bring them in line with these imperatives. In some of the count ries around us, claims settlements percentage is as high as above 75%-ours is may be around 10%. This gap is indicative of the formidable dimensions of the effort that is required to bring the dispute resolution in engineering contracts at par with the prevailing standards.

Filename: P256.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 31 KB
Categories: Volume 0030- 2008
Author: Balal A. Khawaja
Downloads: 1