Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 109 FACTORS AFFECTING THE PERFORMANCE OF STEEL IN CONCRETE S. E. Benjamin* CONDITION OF STEEL IN CONCRETE ENVIRONMENT Steel in concrete is generally passive in the concrete environment due to the formation of γ- Fe2O3 formed on its surface. This passive condition is achieved by the high alkalinity in the cement pore solution that is generated due to the hydration of reactions of cement particles according to the following reactions: 2(3CaO.SiO2) + 6H2O → 3CaO.SiO2.3H2O + 3Ca(OH)2 tricalcium silicate calcium silicate gel calcium hydroxide 2CaO.SiO2 + 4H2O → 3CaO.SiO2.3H2O + Ca(OH)2 dicalcium silicate calcium silicate gel calcium hydroxide Calcium hydroxide imparts a buffered pH value of 12.6 that rises to values of ~ 13.2 due to the sodium and potassium alkalis present in cement. The hydroxide ion has an inhibitive action and steel can stay in a good condition for several decades. The concrete around the steel reinforcement also acts as a physical barrier against the ingress of deleterious substances. Further, the tri-calcium aluminate present in cement binds the chloride ion (Cl-) to form Friedel salt (3CaO.CaCl2.10H2O). THE DEGRATION PROCESSES The passive state of steel is destroyed due to several degrading processes caused by different substances. Carbon dioxide of the atmosphere com bines with Ca(OH) 2 in the cem ent to f orm calcium carbonate and the alkalinity of the pore solution is reduced: CO2 + Ca(OH)2 → CaCO3 + H2O The alkalinity m ay be lowered to value of 7 1 and general form of corrosion of steel reinforcement occurs. Sulphates from the soil/water etc., m ay also cause deterioration of concrete structures by consuming Ca(OH)2 by the following reaction: 2SO4 2- + 2Ca(OH)2 → 2CaSO4 + H2O calcium sulphate Sulphate ion also com bines with the alum ina phase in the cem ent to form mono sulpho aluminate (CaO.CaSO4.10H2O) after the formation of ettringite (CaO.3CaSO4.24H2O), which has an expansive volume, and cause the cracking of the concrete. Alkali-silica reactions m ay also cause cracking of the concrete by dissolution occurring at the particle interface2,3. It should be noted that the corrosion processes at the steel/mortar interface, due to the expansive volume of the rust product, create stresses in concrete and spalling of concrete cover takes place, Fig.1. * Forman Christian College, Lahore. Pakistan Benjamin 110 Fig. 1. Fall of concrete cover due to corrosion of the steel reinforcement Carbonation and the sulphate attack though harmful cannot be regarded as dangerous as the pitting corrosion due to the Cl – anion that causes intense localized pitting corrosion of the steel reinforcement . The pits may through the entire diameter of the embedded reinforcement bar in a short period of time due to coupling of a small anodic area with a large cathode and drastic failure may occur without any visual symptoms4,5, Fig. 2. Fig. 2. Corrosion of the Steel in Concrete In certain cases, the pits coalesce and appear like general form of corrosion, Fig. 3. Fig. 3. Pitting appearing as general form of corrosion of steel MECHANISM OF CHLORIDE ATTACK The exact mechanism of the chloride attack is not known, but the theories put forward so far Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 111 take penetration of the chloride ion through the passive film6, adsorption of Cl- ions7,5 on the metal surface, the metal ion vacancy model and the film breakdown concepts9 into consideration. In any case, when the concentration of the aggressive species exceeds a certain critical value, pitting occurs. Pitting corrosion may continue and a catastrophic failure of the concrete structure may occur without any warning symptoms. The common sources of chloride ions are as follows: 1) Deliberate addition of salt to accelerate cement setting 2) Use of contaminated water or aggregates 3) Use of de-icing salts in cold regions The corrosion of the passive steel progresse s inside the concrete due to following electrochemical reactions: Anodic reaction Fe ⇔ Fe2+ + 2e- Cathodic reaction H 2O + O2 + 4e- ⇔ 4OH- Other electro–chemical reactions controlling the corrosion processes are as follows: 3Fe3+ + 4H2O ⇔ Fe3O4 + 8H+ + 2e- 3Fe2+ + 3H2O ⇔ Fe2O3 + 6H+ + 2e- Thus, the pit environment is rich in hydrogen ions (H+) with current flow from the anodic to the cathodic sites. The pit propagation is auto cat alytic due to the generation of acidity that neutralizes the effect of inhibitive hydroxyl ions (OH-) in the cement pore solution. Thus, the passive state of steel is ruined. Pit re-passivation i.e., where the pit propagation is stopped, is only possible when the OH- ions are in sufficient quantities to inhibit the aggressive action of the chloride ion. The amounts of permissible chloride ion in concrete in the international codes of practice vary widely. ACI 318 allows a maximum water-soluble chloride ion content of 0.06% in prestressed concrete, 0.15% for the reinforced concrete that will be dry or protected from moisture in service and 0.3% for all other reinforced concrete c onstruction. The British code, CP110 allows an acid soluble chloride content of 0.35% for 95% of the test results with no result greater than 0.50%. It is considered that at 0.4% chloride content there is a risk of corrosion but in actual, corrosion has occurred at values lower than that, particularl y, where the chloride content was not uniform. The Norwegian code, NS 3474, allows an acid soluble chloride content of 0.6% for the reinforced concrete made with ordinary Portland cemen t (OPC) but only 0.002% chloride ion for the prestressed concrete. Thus, the highways, the pa rking areas, marine environments and industrial plants where chloride ion is present, additiona l protection against corrosion of embedded steel is necessary. The civil engineers place their concerted e fforts around the building design driven by the economics of the project but the corrosion scientists regard it extremely important to elucidate the environmental factors, before construction is st arted. Critical review of such factors can only guarantee a durable safe life of the structure. CRITICAL CL-/OH- RATIO Hausman10 was the first to put forwar d the concept of critical Cl -/OH- ratio from free corrosion experiments of steel in alkaline solutions inferring that ratios of <0.6% cannot possibly produce corrosion in aerated alkaline solutions. Diamond11 found that 1% Calcium chloride (CaCl2) Benjamin 112 by weight of cement or its e quivalent of NaCl (~0.48% Cl -) resulted in a Cl -/OH- ratio of 0.77 in CaCl2 cement pastes and 0.64 in NaCl in cement pastes, analyzed through pore solution squeeze technique, and concluded that CaCl2 was more aggressive due to the common ion effect, which leads to a reduction in pH. Goni and Andrade 12 have found that ratios of 0.25 to 0.8 can cause depassivation of steel in concrete mortars. Page 13 has reported a value of 3, obtained through polarization resistance measurements (Rp), above which serious corrosion rates can be expected. The critical Cl-/OH- ratio in the pore solution is also in fluenced by temperature to a large extent. Parkinson14 observed a higher Cl-/OH- ratio for solution extracted in pore press at 50 °C for both OPC and sulphate resisting Portland cement (SRPC) cement pastes. Benjamin and Sykes15, 16 also investigated the effect of temperature on the critical Cl-/OH- ratio in simulated solutions of pH 13.2. Pitting was observed at a ratio of 0.15 at 40 °C, 0.25 at 20 °C and 0.35 at 0 °C. They also showed that steel embedded in cement mortar of 1:1 aggregate/cement ratio (A/C) and water/cement ratio (W/C) of 0.5 containing 3% by weight of OPC, showed pitting at 40 °C and the same already pitting specimen re-passivated and became safe, when tested at 20 °C, Fig. 4. Potential mV vs SCE Fig. 4. Effect of temperature on the pitting corrosion of Swedish Iron in Concrete with 3% NaCl as an admixture. A/C ratio 1:1, W/C ratio 0.5 Benjamin17 developed zones of passivation and corrosion for different chloride levels as the function of temperature, Fig. 5. The BRE18 standards, which specify 0.4% NaCl (by weight of OPC) as safe limits with onset of serious corrosion problem at about 1% have thus become very doubtful for applications world wide, as these are set at temperatures around 20 °C, only. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 113 Temperature oC Fig.5. Domain of Pitting of Swedish Iron in OPC mortars as the function of chloride and temperature A/C ratio 1:1, W/C ratio 0.5 P– pitting (figures in parentheses show the pitting potentials) S – safe FACTORS CONTROLLING PERFORMANCE OF STEEL IN CONCRETE Several important parameters affect the performance of concrete structures: FACTOR IMPACT i. Cement content Alkalinity of the pore environment ii. Compaction Strength and porosity iii. Curing Strength, porosity and alkalinity iv. Cement/aggregate ratio Porosity and alkalinity v. Water/cement ratio Porosity and alkalinity vi. Depth of cover Time for initiation of pitting ACI 201.2R recommends a minimum of 50mm (2 inches) for bridge decks if the water cement ratio is 0.40 and 65 mm (2.5 inches) if the water/cement ratio is 0.45. Even greater cove r, or the provision of additional corrosion protection treatments may be required in some environments. Chloride attack is further aggravated by the changes in temperature especially when the structure is subjected to freezing and thawing. Internal friction between the crystals of ice and salt in the capillary pores of hardened cement pastes 19-20, expansion together with cracking and loss of Benjamin 114 strength due to hydraulic pressure in presence of chloride21, all add to the destruction of the concrete. Fly ash and silica fume are finding special applications in recent years. Usually the blast furnace slag cement concretes have proved successful to freeze thaw attack but failure is encountered in freeze de–icer situation22. Differences in the types of cements are a result of variation in composition or fineness or both, and not all types of cement have the same ability to provide protection to steel. EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE ON THE DIFFUSION PROCESSES. Processes occurring at the interface and in the bulk through diffusion of species importantly account for the condition of steel in concrete. Flux of species towards the steel is dependent on the concentration gradient existing between steel and the surface of concrete following Fick’s second law of diffusion23. The passive state of steel in concrete is maintained in the presence of oxygen (O2). The O2 diffusion coefficient in water saturated concrete is of the order of 10-4 to 10-6 cm2/s24 compared with values of the order of 10 -2 to 10 -4 cm2/s25 in dry concrete. Thus, in submerged conditions, the concrete pores are completely filled with water and therefore, the O2 content in the concrete is limited by its solubility in water which is affected by temperature. Therefore, at higher temperatures the diffusion rate of O2 will increase but the decrease in solubility may result in the depassivation of steel, which especially controls the de polarization process of cathodically protected reinforced concrete structures26. The chloride ion (Cl-) diffusion towards the steel/mortar interface plays a critical role in the de-passivation of steel i.e., at a critical threshold of Cl- at the interface, pitting occurs. Page et al27 have reported that the effective diffusivities of Cl- in OPC pastes of water/cement (W/C) ratio of 0.4 increase from 11.03 x 10-9 cm2 s-1 at 7 °C to 84 x 10-9 cm2 s-1 at 44 °C. Similar increase has been shown for other W/C ratios. At higher temperatures the diffusion imparts to the pitting propensity28 by directly affecting the Cl-/OH- ratio. THE EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE ON CHLORIDE BINDING The Cl- anion is bound in the cement matrix by tricalcium aluminate (C3A) forming Friedel salt (3CaO.Al2O3 CaCl2.10H20)29 and thus reduces the amount of free Cl- in the pore solution. Rasheeduzzafar and coworkers 30 have shown that the concentra tion of water soluble chloride, extracted with hot water, falls from 86% for 2% C 3A content in OPC mortars to 33 % for OPC mortars containing 14% C3A. Others observed that this binding of Cl- can be significantly reduced by carbonation, high levels of SO4 2- and high ambient temperatures31. Roberts32 worked with synthesised Friedel salt and postulated that this complex releases Cl- at higher temperatures and that the process is irreversible. However, the results given in Fig. 4 do not conform to Robert’s postulation. Benjamin and Sykes 33 developed the understanding of the mechanism by work on the stability of synthesised calcium chloroaluminate (SCCA) as the function of pH and temperature. The results showed that the stability of SCCA is affected by the changes in temperature but more markedly by the changes in pH. Some Cl - was re-absorbed by the complex when the temperature was lowered. They construed that it is not the tri calcium aluminate breaking at high temperatures but it is actually adsorption and de-sorption from the cement matrix that is markedly influenced by the changes in temperature. The pitting of steel depends upon several interac tive parameters that need more elaborate discussions as the problem diversifies. The foregoing context has merely taken the root causes that must be taken into account to safe guard the durab ility of the concrete structures. It is extremely important that the civil engineers utilize such information when outlining a construction plan, with a Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 115 particular emphasis on temperature in conjunction with the other conditions of exposure. CONCLUSIONS 1. Chloride/hydroxide ratio is an important parameter that effects the corrosion of steel in concrete. The ratio is markedly influenced by the changes in temperature i.e., it decreases with an increase in temperature. 2. The threshold chloride concentration to cau se the pitting of steel embedded in concrete deceases with an increase in temperature from 6% at 0 °C to 2% at 40 °C. 3. Synthesised tricalcium chloro aluminate is stable in the temperature range of 0 – 60 °C but is markedly influenced by the changes in pH. 4. Desoption of chloride from the cement matrix at higher temperatures contributes to the corrosion of steel in concrete. 5. The international codes of practice defined for ch loride threshold in concrete must be revised for the tropical and the high temperature regions. REFERENCES 1. Alonso, M.C., Toraja Institute, Madrid, Spain. Private communication 2. A. Traetteberg & P.E Gratten-below., J. of Am. Cer. Soc., 1975, 58, No. 5-6. 3. L. Heller & M. Ben Yair, Nature, 1961, p.191. 4. J.A. Gonzalez′ & C. Andrade′, Brit. Corr. J., 1980, 15, No.3. 5. J.A. Gonzalez′ , M.C. Alonso, & C. Andrade′ , “Corrosion of reinforcement in concrete construction”, ed. By A.P. Crane, Ellis Horwood Ltd., 1983, pp.159. 6. T.P. Hoar, D.C. Mears, &, G.P. Rothwell, Corr. Sci., 1965, p.5. 7. W. Schwenk, Corrosion, 1964, p.20. 8. H.H., Strehblow, B. Titze, B. & B.P. Lochel, Corr. Sci., 1979, p.19. 9. N. Sato, Electrochimica Acta, 1971, p.16. 10. D.A. Hausman, Materials Protection, 1967, 6, p.19. 11. S. Diamond, Cem. Conc. & Aggregate , 1986, No.2. 12. S. Goni, and C. Andrade, Toraja Inst., Madrid, Spain. Private communication. 13. C. L. Page, Proc. 2nd. Int. Conf. on, "Deterio ration of concrete in Arabian Gulf", Bahrain, 1987, p.161. 14. D.T. Parkinson, 2 nd year Research Report, Aston Univ., 1989. 15. S. E. Benjamin and J.M. Sykes, "Corrosi on of Steel reinforcement in concrete construction", eds. C.L. Page, K.W.J. Treadaway, and P.B. Bamforth, SCI: Elsevier App. Sc. publishers, ISBN 1-85166-487-4, 1990. pp. 59. Benjamin 116 16. S. E. Benjamin and J.M. Sykes, 3rd Int. Conf . on deterioration of concrete in Arabian Gulf, 1989, 1, p.573. 17. S.E. Benjamin, F.A. Khalid & J.M. Sykes, EUROCORR 98, The European Corrosion Congress on, “Solution of corrosion problems”, Event No. 221, Netherlands, 28 Sept. – 1st Oct. 1998. 18. L.H. Everett, & K.W.J. Treadaway, Building Res. Establishment, Info Paper , IP 12/80, 1980. 19. Xu; and M.J. Setzer, RILEM Proc. 1997, 34, p.269. 20. Q.B. Yang, X.L. Wu, and S.Y. Huang, Int. Congr. Chem. Cem. , 9th, 1992, 5, p. 282. 21. U. Balters, and U. Ludwig, RILEM Proc. 1997, 34, p. 111. 22. J. Stark, H-M. Ludwig, ACI Mater. J., 1997, 94 (1), p. 47. 23. N.S. Berke and M.C. Hicks, Corr., 50 (3), 1994, p.234. 24. C.L. Page and P. Lambert, J. Material Sci., 22, 1987, p.942. 25. A. A., Sagues and S.C. Kranc, Corr., 8, 1992, p.624. 26. M. Z. Lourenco and B.W.Cherry, “Factors which Control the Depolarisation process of Cathodically Protected Reinforced concrete Structures”, presentation at Conf. on Understanding Corrosion Mechanisms in Concrete, Cambridge,USA,July 25-29, 1997. 27. C.L. Page, N.R. Short and A. El Tarras, Cem. Conc. Res., 11, 1981, p.395. 28. A.V. Saetta, R.V Scotta,. and R.V. Vitaliani, ACI Materials J., 90(5), 1993, p.441. 29. L. Heller, and M. Ben-Yair, Nature, 191, 1961, p. 488. 30. S.S. Rasheeduzaffar, F.H. Saadoun, Dakhil, & A.S. Al-Ghatani, Corrosion of steel reinforcement in concrete construction” , ed. C.L. Page, K.W.J. Treadaway and P.B. Bamforth, SCI: Elsevier Applied Science, London, ISBN1-85166-487-4, 1990, p.213. 31. M. Masslehuddin, C.L. Page, Rasheeduzzaffar and Al-Mana, “Corrosion of steel reinforcement in concrete construction”, ed. C.L. Page, P.B. Bamforth, and J.W. Figg, Roy. Soc. Chem., Cambridge, 1996, p.67. 32. M. H. Roberts, Mag. of Concrete Res., 1962, 14, p. 143. 33. S. E. Benjamin, J.M. Sykes, & F.A. Khali d, “The Effect of Temperature and pH on the Binding of chloride by calcium aluminate”, paper presented at Conf. on Understanding Corrosion Mechanisms in Concrete”, July 27-31, Massachusetts Inst. of Tech., Cambridge, USA, 1997.
Filename:
637.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
85 KB
