Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 365 THE EFFECT OF ALLOY ADDITIONS ON THE MAGNETIC PROPERTIES OF RFeB SINTERED MAGNETS Dr. A. Ahmad* ABSTRACT The RFeB system has been developed over th e last fifteen years to provide perm anent magnets of the highest quality for advanced applications. Although these m agnets exhibit high saturation and good coercivity, their poor corrosion resistance and high temperature properties has led to considerable research into improving these properties through alloying additions. The paper describes the production of sintered RFeB based magnets by conventional powder metallurgical techniques and by blending with fine particles of other elements such as Zr. Properties of the m agnets made from Jet m illed and ball m illed powders have been com pared. Both the effectiveness of blending as a process and the va riation of properties by varying Zr content have been investigated. The effects of heat-treatment on the magnetic properties and microstructure are also investigated. INTRODUCTION Permanent magnets provide a constant magnetic field in an air gap without the continuous expenditure of energy required by an electrom agnet. Their uses range from low technology applications such as fridge magnets to state of the art applications such as MRI scanners. The type of m agnetic m aterial selected for each applica tion depends on a num ber of factors. The key properties are usually the magnetic field produced by a given volume of material and its resistance to demagnetisation. Fig.1 shows how the magnetic properties of the most common magnetic materials vary. It can be seen from fig. 1 that for any static gap application a smaller volume of NdFeB could be used in place of the ferrites or Alnico which are commonly used. The first studies of NdFeB system were m ade in the Ukrain (1) where the existence of three stable ternary phases was reported. Further investigation revealed the ternary phases to be Fig. 1 Magnetic properties of the most common magnetic materials Nd2Fe14B, NdFe4B4 and Nd5Fe2B6 (2,3,4) The phase responsible for the exceptional hard magnetic * Associate Professor, Departm ent of Met Engineering and Materials Science University of Engineering and Technology, Lahore A. Ahmad 366 properties was identified as being the 2:14:1 phase a tetragonal compound with its easy direction of magnetization along the c-axis. The magnets are produced by sintering a green compact of NdFeB powder. The powder is produced by ball milling an alloy of standard composition e.g. Nd16Fe76B8. This process was first em ployed for the production of Sm Co5 and was adapted for NdFeB by Sagawa and coworkers at Sumitomo. The material is subjected to hydrogen decrepitation before milling (5). The m ain m ethod of varying the com position of a sintered m agnet is to change the composition of the starting alloy at the pre-casting stage. Although alloy modification is the method used in m uch of the literature, powder blending provides a practical alternative with distinct advantages (6,7). The blending process used in this work is developed by Ahm ad, Mottram and Harris and is described elsewhere in detail (8,9). EXPERIMENTAL WORK Fig. 2 shows a schematic representation of the processing route em ployed. The blending process employed in this work involves simple powder mixing. In this process pre-milled powder with suitable particle size distribution were m ixed together before being aligned and pressed. This was done by tumbling the NdFeB and additive powder in a sealed pot containing stainless steel milling balls. It was found that a tum bling time of 1 hour was suitable to give a hom ogeneous mixture of powder. Rough and fine crushing of powder Alloy Production (Casting or co-reduction Ingots broken up Hydrogen Decrepitation Alloy ball or jet milled to 3-7 um Particles aligned and pressed Compact vacuum sintered Heat treatment and final shaping Fig. 2 Processing Route For Sintered Magnets Sintering of the green com pacts was carried out in a vacuum furnace system as shown in Fig. 3, using the temperature profile shown in fig. 4. After sintering any oxide from the sample was Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 367 removed from the surface of the magnet using wet grinding paper. The samples were magnetised for magnetic measurements by using a pulse magnetiser. The pulser consists of a bank of capacitors that discharge through a solenoid producing an internal field of 4.5 Tesla. A permeameter was used to obtain demagnetisation curves from which remanence , coercivity and BHmax were caculated. A Pendulum Balance was used to carry out therm omagnetic m easurements and assess Curie temperature. SEM-Jeol 6300 was used to obtain images of microstructures and to carry out EDX analysis on samples. Fig. 3 Vacuum Sintering Apparatus Fig. 4 Temperature Profile For Sintering RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Two types of NdFeB powder were used to produce magnets-freshly (ball) milled powder and a batch of powder jet m illed at Crumax, UK. Table 1 shows the average properties of magnets produced with each of these powders. Three m agnets were m ade with each powder, yielding a number of test sam ples for the perm eameter and pendulum balance. It can be seen that the properties of the magnets sintered f rom freshly milled powder are better than those f rom the jet milled powder. This is mainly due to the oxidation of the powder. Table No. 1 Summary of Properties from different powders, A = As sintered, B = heat treated 1 hr/600 oC Powder Br (mT) iHc (kA/m) bHc (kA/m) BH(max) (kJ/m3 Squareness % Curie Temp oC A 1204 634 598 231 0.65 312 Jet Milled B 1208 751 696 232 0.78 – A 1233 696 663 285 0.89 312 Ball Milled B 1240 854 777 291 0.85 – A. Ahmad 368 Table 2 shows the magnetic properties of the sintered magnets blended with 0.1 to 0.5 at % Zr. Blending with Zr has led to a decrease in both remanence and coercivity, which is not recovered by post sintering heat treatment. Despite all samples being fully dense (7.5 g/cm3) the remanence of these magnets begins to fall with even relatively small Zr addition. An explaination for this is obvious from the backscattered SEM image as shown in Fig. 5. It can be seen that there is m uch more of the lighter Nd rich phase present than in the standard 16/76/8 microstructure (Fig.6). Table No. 2 Properties of Nd16Fe76B8 magnets blended with zirconium A = As sintered, B= After heat treatment at 600 oC for 1 hour At % Zr Sample Br ±10 (mT) iHc ±5 (kA/m) iHc ±5 (kA/m) BH(max) ±15 (kJ/m3 Squareness % Curie Temperature ±3 oC A 1254 628 613 290 0.91 – 0.1 B – – – – – – A 1232 535 423 191 0.44 312 0.3 B 1250 547 500 266 0.72 – A 1226 378 320 144 0.34 312 0.5 B 1227 447 396 202 0.51 – Fig. 5 Backscattered SEM image of Fig. 6 Backscattered SEM image of Nd16Fe76B8 Zr blended magnet magnet It also appears that this increase has prevented the formation of the 2:14:1 matrix phase. This happens because the Zr has combined preferentially with boron during sintering, causing a depletion in the amount of boron available for formation of the matrix phase. This is supported by the EDX results which indicated that there was no Zr in the matrix phase. The apparent decrease in coercivity is more difficult to explain. The increased amount of Nd rich and Zr phases between the matrix grains should give better magnetic isolation and an increase in coercivity. A possible explanation for this is that as boron combines preferentially with Zr, excess iron remains in the Nd rich phase , probably forming soft magnetic Nd2 Fe17. This would have a Pakistan Engineering Congress, 69th Annual Session Proceedings 369 dramatic effect on coercivity, even at low compositions. The presence of such soft magnetic phases would explain the poor dem agnetisation loop shapes as shown in figs. 7 and 8. Fig. 9 shows the pendulum balance trace for 0.5 at % Zr blended magnet. Fig. 7 Demagnetisation curves for Zr blended magnets (as sintered) Fig. 8 Effect of Heat treatment for 1 hour at 600 C on 0.5 at % Zr A. Ahmad 370 Fig. 9 Pendulum balance trace for 0.5 at % Zr blended magnet REFERENCES (1) Chaban, N.F.; Kuzma, Y.B. Bilanizhko, N.S. Kachm ar, Dopov.Akad.Nauk USSR Ser. A Fiz.Mat. Tekh.Nauki 10 (1979) 875. (2) M. Sagawa, S.Fujimura, N.Togawa, H. Yamamoto and Y. Matsuura, J.Applied.Phys. 55(6) (1984) 2083-2087. (3) J.J. Croat, J.F.Herbst and R.W.Lee, J.App.Phys, 55 (1984) 2078-2082. (4) R. Grossinger, Mat.Lett., 2(1984) 539. (5) P.McGuiness, I.R.Harris, E.Rozendaal, J. Ormerod and M.Ward, J.Mat.Sci.21 (1986) 4107 (6) R.S.Mottram and I.R.Harris, Proceedings of the 15 th International workshop on rare earth magnets and their applications, Dreden, (1998)p 473-479. (7) C.Burkhardt, R.S.Mottram , F.Dim e, S.Kobe and I.R.Harris, Proceedings of the 15 th International workshop on rare earth m agnets and their applications, Dreden, (1998) p 953-957. (8) Production of PrFeCoB m agnets by blending with cobalt, A.Ahm ad, R.Mottram and I.R.Harris, Materials Science Fo rum Vols. 373-376(2001)pp325-328, Trans Tech Publications Ltd, Uetikon- Zuerich, Switzerland. (9) Blending additions to PrFeB and NdFeB- type m agnets, A.Ahm ad and I.R.Harris, proceedings of the 7th international conference on advanced materials,(ISAM7), Islamabad, Pakistan, sept.17-21, 2001, pp149-155.
Filename:
652.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
153 KB
