Paper No. 687 PLANNING AND DESIGN OF TAUNSA BARRAGE REHABILITATION PROJECT S.M.A. Zaidi, M. Akram Khan, Saif ur Rehman 228 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 229 PLANNING AND DESIGN OF TAUNSA BARRAGE REHABILITATION PROJECT S.M.A. Zaidi1, M. Akram Khan2 & Saif ur Rehman3 1. SYNOPSIS Barrages have a pivotal role in providing sustained irrigation supplies to millions of acres of fertile lands in the country and specially Punjab Province. Eight (8) out of fourteen (14) Barrages in Punjab including Taunsa Barrage being 50 to 117 years old were suffering from serious problems threatening their overall integrity/stability. Taunsa Barrage located on Indus River at about 39 km south of Taunsa Sharif town and 16 km north west of Kot Adu was constructed from 1954 -1958 to provide weir controlled irrigation supplies to originally flood fed areas on both banks of the river alongwith some new lands in Thal desert area. This Barrage serves 2.351 million acres (951,400 hectares) besides diverting flows from Indus River to the Chenab Ri ver through Taunsa Panjnad (TP) Link Canal. The barrage also serves as an arterial road bridge, a railway bridge, and crossing for gas and oil pipelines, telephone line and EHV transmission lines. Taunsa Barrage soon after its completion in 1958 ran into multiple problems like oblique right sided river approach to the barrage causing heavy siltation in DG Khan canal with reduction in its capacity, excessive retrogression of water levels on the downstream, damage to stilling basin floor, breakdown of subsur face flow monitoring system and defects developing in mechanical installations. Extensive repairs were executed during 1959 -62 but problems persisted. Punjab Government constituted committees of experts in 1966 and 1973 but no specific measures, were taken to address the problems that continued to aggravate. Evaluation by Consultants engaged to review health of the barrage indicated the need for major rehabilitation works after a regular feasibility study. An Expert Group recommended some major rehabilita tion works in 1999 to obviate sudden collapse of this key structure of paramount importance. A feasibility study was completed in June -July 2004 for this project titled “Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation and Modernization Project” The World Bank in dicated their willingness in April 2004 to finance the Project. Consequently the Taunsa Barrage Rehabilitation Project was put on fast track and implemented from June 2005 to December 2008. 1 Project Manager, Punjab Barrages Consultants & Associate, National Development Consultants 2 Head Design Engineer, Punjab Barrages Consultants 3 Planning & Contract Engineer, Punjab Barrages Consultants 230 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman This paper presents the history of Taunsa Barrage, the problems, their impacts, proposed remedial measures, design of works and financial and economic analysis results for the project, for sharing the issues and experiences with professional colleagues. 2. INTRODUCTION Barrages play a pivotal role in providing sustain ed irrigation supplies to millions of acres of fertile land in the country and specially Punjab Province. Several Barrages are suffering from aging, hydraulic, structural and sedimentation/retrogression problems. Some Barrages and Headworks including Taunsa were endangered by multitude of problems and their overall stability was threatened. 2.1 Background and History of the Taunsa Barrage Project Taunsa Barrage Project was initially conceived in 1936 and after passing through many vicissitudes was sanction ed in 1953. Construction also commenced the same year. The project was commissioned in 1958 and formally inaugurated in March 1959. The evolutionary history of the project is very interesting and provides extremely useful information to the staff managing and operating this complex structure. 2.2 The Taunsa Barrage The Taunsa Barrage, built across Indus River is located at about 16 Km from Kot Addu, a Tehsil head quarter of Muzaffargarh District, with location coordinates of 30º 31’ N 70º 51’ E. The Barrage as originally constructed has 65 bays with a total width of 4,346 ft between the abutments. Width of each bay is 60 ft except for bay No. 8 which is 22 ft wide and serves as navigation lock. Bays No. 9 to 61 constitute main weir and there are two sets o f undersluices separated from the weir by two divide walls at left and right flanks bays No. 1 to 7 and 62 to 65. The Barrage has 2 fish ladders each 11 ft wide alongside each divide wall. The canal system fed by the Barrage initially consisted of Muzaffa rgarh and DG Khan canals. The former was completed in 1960 and is in operation since then, while the latter although opened in 1958 continued to remain under construction in some later years. TP Link canal was added in 1970, as a component work of the Indus Basin project Taunsa Barrage is the most important barrage amongst those built across the mighty Indus and its tributaries as it commands large areas in Punjab and Balochistan provinces. Three canals namely Muzaffargarh, DG Khan and TP Link canals off-take from this Barrage. Muzaffargarh and TP Link canals are on the left flank of the Barrage while DG Khan is on the right flank. Also recent construction of head regulator of Kachhi canal on right flank will enable a withdrawal of 6000 cusecs for irrigatio n of Kachhi plain in Balochistan. TP Link canal conveys Indus River water to the Chenab River to supplement irrigation in Panjnad Barrage command area during shortage period. Figure 1 -5 shows general layout of the Taunsa Barrage Irrigation System. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 231 Figure 1: Downstream View of the Barrage Figure 2: Upstream View of the Barrage 232 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Figure 3: Location plan of the Barrage Figure 4: Layout of the Barrage Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 233 Figure 5: General layout of Taunsa Barrage Irrigation System. Table 1 gives discharges, Cultivable Command Areas (CCA) and Districts irrigated by Taunsa Barrage Canals. Total Command Area of the Barrage is now 2,351,175 acres exc luding Kachhi Canal Coammand and Punjnad Command benefited through T.P. Link in shortage periods. Table 1 – Discharge, CCA & Districts Commanded by Taunsa Barrage Canals Sr # Name of Canals CCA (Acres) Length (Km) District Designed Discharge (Cusec) Remarks 1 Muzaffargarh 940,000 113 Muzaffargarh, Layyah 8,901 2 DG Khan 1,285,000 105 DG Khan, Rajanpur i) present day 11,540 Final 14,500 3 TP Link 126,000 62 Muzaffargarh, Balawalpur, Rahimyar Khan 12,000 Rangpur canal and supplement as supplies to Panjnad Command 2.3 Functions of the Barrage The functions of a conventional Barrage are: 1. Raising water level in the river to an extent required for feeding the off-taking canals; 2. Pinning down the river at one location and to fa cilitate transportation needs; 3. Regulation and control of the river flows. 234 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman But Taunsa Barrage is more than a conventional Barrage as It provides the following: i. Irrigation facilities to areas in Muzaffargarh, DG Khan and Rajanpur Districts (2.35 million acres); ii. Accommodates a trans Indus rail road crossing for direct rail link between Kot Adu on the left bank and DG Khan, Rajanpur and Kashmore on the right bank of Indus River; a. A Class 70/AA loading Arterial Road Bridge; b. A 16 inch dia hi gh pressure pipeline owned by PARCO for conveying petroleum products from Karachi to the up country storage at Mahmood Kot terminal. c. A 16 inch dia high pressure natural gas pipeline conveying natural gas from Dhodak gas field to KAPCO and serviceable areas. iii. Facilitates two single span EHV transmission lines crossings. Taunsa Barrage is thus a truly multipurpose complex see Figures 5 & 6. Figure 6: Transport and Energy Infrastructure Accommodated by the Barrage Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 235 Salient Features and Data Table 2: Original Design Data of Taunsa Barrage Maximum flood discharge 1,000,000 Cusecs Normal Pond level upstream 446.0 Highest flood level upstream & emergency pond level 447.0 Highest flood level downstream 444.0 Left Undersluice (Bay No. 1 to 7) 7 No. of 60 ft. span each Right Undersluice (Bays No. 62 to 65) 4 No. of 60 ft. span each Weir (Bays No. 9 to 61) 53 No. of 60 ft. span each Navigation Lock Channel (Bays No. 8) 1 No. of 22 ft. width Fish ladders 2 No. of 11 ft. width each Width of pier and divide walls 7 ft. each Total width between flanks 4346 ft. Crest RL in the undersluice Bays and navigation Bay 425.0 Crest RL in the weir Bays 428.0 upstream floor RL in the undersluices 419.0 upstream floor RL in the weir 421.0 downstream floor RL in the undersluice 415.0 downstream floor RL in the weir 416.0 Depth of sheet piles i) Upstream 15 ft. ii) Middle (toe of glacis) 15 ft. iii) End of floor 20 ft. Total length of impervious floor i) Undersluice Bays 238 ft. ii) Weir Bays 233 ft. Number of pressure pipes installed 541 against 579 designed Road bridge (width for wheeled traffic) 24 ft. (width of footpaths on left and right 6 ft. each Top RL of Road bridge 457.0 236 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Bottom RL of bridge girders 452.0 Top RL of decking of overhead bridge 500.0 Crest RL of off-taking canals 433.0 FSLs in the canals 444.0 Number of canal regulator Bays i) Muzaffargarh Canal 5 No. of 24 ft. each ii) D.G. Khan Canal 7 No. of 24 ft. each iii) T.P. Link Canal 7 No. of 24 ft. each downstream floor RL. In the canals i) Muzaffargarh Canal 430.15 ii) D.G Khan 431.35 iii) T.P. Link Canal 428.16 Table 3: Brief data of Original Gates and Gearings of the Barrage Particulars Nos Dimension of gates (ft) Types Length of ropes Gates Roller trains Weir Bays Undersluices Upper Lower Lock gates Upstream dowstream H/R of canals DGK canal MZG canal T.P. Link 53 11 11 1 1 7 5 7 61.67 ft. x 19 ft. high 61.67 x 14 high 61.67 x 8 . high 23.67 x 22 high 23.67 x 32 high 25.67 x13.50 high 25.67 x13.50. high 25.67 x 30.50 high Stoney Stoney Stoney Stoney Stoney Stoney Stoney F. wheel 51’-1” 75’-1133/4” 59’-93/4” 59’-93/4” 65’-41/2” 44’-6” 44’-6” 50’-1” 51’-23/8” 58’76/8” 54’-105/8” 53’-83/4” 39’ 39’ nil 2.4 Brief History of Problems and Need for the Project The Barrage soon after its construction in 1958 started experiencing multiple problems of: i. Tendency of river to revert to its old course on the right with a severe curvilinear approach and risk of outflanking ii. Excessive sedimentation in the D. G. Khan canal Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 237 iii. Ripping off reinforced skin concrete of the downstream floor iv. Damage to friction blocks thereby adversely affecti ng the efficiency of the structure v. Excessive retrogression of downstream water levels forcing limitation on head across and creating energy dissipation problem vi. Choking and malfunctioning of large number of pressure pipes, i.e. breakdown of monitoring system vii. Defects in the hoisting mechanism and other mechanical installations. Some repairs to the downstream skin concrete and friction blocks were carried out as early as in 1959, only a year after the commissioning followed by extensive repairs in subsequent years. After the repairs of 1962, it was thought that the problem was finally over. But, it was not. More recently, damages were repaired in 1986, 1994, 1998 and 2003 (Table 4 gives a year wise details of damages sustained by the Barrage. Table 4: Year Wise Serious Damages at Taunsa Barrage Sr. No. Year Location of Damage Nature of Damage 1. 1959 Various Bays 90 No. Impact Blocks 8 No. Deflector Blocks Skin Concrete of Bay # 9 2. 1960-61 Various Bays 9 No. Impact Blocks 2 No. Deflector Blocks Entire skin concrete of the downstream floor damaged 3. 1962 Various Bays 18 No. Impact Blocks Weir Portion Skin Downstream Floor heavily grouted 4. 1963-64 Bays No. 9, 10, 32, 35, 40 & 51 Skin concrete damaged at various places 21 No. Impact Blocks 9 No. Deflector Blocks 5. 1965-70 Various Bays 1 No. Deflector 6 No Impact blocks RC Skin Concrete in several bays 6. 1973-82 Various Bays 30 No. Deflector Blocks RC skin in undersluices and weir portions in several bays 7. 1986-95 Various Bays 2 No. Deflector Blocks 2 No. Impact Blocks Skin Concrete of Bays No. 41-42 (twice) and several other bays Downstream Glacis skin in several bays 8. 1996- 2003 Bay No. 33-35 Bay No. 33-35-40-41-Entire RC skin concrete 39 Deflector slabs and RC skin in several bays 238 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman 3. SPECIAL COMMITTEE REPORTS 3.1 Special Committee of 1966 Secretary Irrigation and Power Department (IPD), Government of Punjab during 1966 appointed a special committee of officers (known as First Taunsa Committee) to look in to the problems of Taunsa Barrage. This committee in their report dated November 1966 remarked that at least up to 500,000 cusecs stage, the worst of retrogression was already over yet stressed the necessity of determining the lower hydraulic jump limit curves from model studies. 3.2 Comprehensive Studies by Field Officers i) First Report 1967 A comprehensive study of the problem was undertaken by the field officers during 1967. All the data from 1954 to 1966 was analyzed and a report issued in June 1967. This report concluded that: Design gauge discharge curve deduced by Irrigation Research Institute (IRI) and adopted for design had erred both in the assumption of minimum gauge discharge relationship and the magnitude of retrogression. Hydraulic jump o n the main weir profile could be retained by the blocks only up to a discharge of 560,000 cusecs as determined by the minimum gauge -discharge relationship of 1966. Stilling basin was unsafe beyond the limits indicated above and serious consequences in the shape of damage to blocks and downstream protection were anticipated. It was recommended that, some remedial measures need to be implemented for safety of the Barrage. ii) Second Report, 1967 The 2nd report issued on September 9, 1967 after carrying out model studies at Taunsa Barrage stated that the safe discharge capacity of the Barrage for 1966 gauges was 560,000 cusecs and discharge in excess of this limit would cause damages on the downstream side whose extent would depend on the magnitude and duration of the flood. This report also proposed construction of a subsidiary weir about 1000 ft downstream of the Barrage gate line. The proposal was presented to an elite gathering of I&P Deptt officers, who agreed in principle, but somehow this proposal could not be implemented. iii) IRI Report 1968 VS Field Officers View Director IRI Lahore in his Technical report No. 614/HYD/1968 did not agree with the findings of the field officers and concluded that Taunsa Barrage had withstood the maximum retrogression that was likely to occur and accretionary trend had already set in. In November 1969, another note depicting the views of field officers on various issues contained in the note by the Director IRI was submitted wherein it was maintained that the safe capa city of the barrage was no more than 500,000 cusecs and that there had been no reversal in retrogression cycle. They maintained that IRI had again erred in assuming that extrapolation of the envelope would be a curve. They emphasized that the envelope base d on semi Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 239 log plot should essentially be a straight line. IRI was requested to provide the equations for the curve which was not done. The field officers also did not agree on the revised proposal of IRI envisaging construction of two spurs one on each ba nk downstream of the Barrage to constrict the waterway. During 1959, similar spurs were proposed at Khanki to reduce accretion on the downstream. iv) Report of 1973 Committee With the above differences of opinion and controversy about retrogression unresolved, another Committee was constituted by Secretary IPD in 1973. The Committee recommended converting the downstream row of friction blocks into a baffle wall. Consequently, Bay Nos. 37 to 44 of the main weir were selected and instead of constructing a baffle wall, the spaces between the blocks of the downstream row of blocks were filled with stone in wire crates that disintegrated during the very first flow it experienced and the proposal of baffle wall remained untested. Nevertheless, 1979 was yet anot her bad year and established that the stipulation was an optimism. 3.3 Report of Expert Group on Taunsa Barrage, July 1999 Secretary, IPD in May 1999, again constituted, a group of experts to probe into problems of the Barrage: – The main recommendations made by the group were: i. A rigid subsidiary weir is the most effective and viable solution for mitigating the ill effects of retrogression of levels. ii. Pressure pipes provided under the barrage structure are mostly out of order and those few in work ing condition have no significance for the sensitive and most important downstream floor area. Addition of conventional pressure pipes and vibrating wire (electronic) peizometers in selected bays/components of the barrage is a vital requirement. iii. A silt excluder is definitely needed in the right pocket to control the silt entry into D.G. Khan Canal. iv. The mechanical components i.e. Regulation Gates and Hoisting arrangements need immediate attention and rehabilitation / improvements. It was also su ggested that all the above recommendations need further investigation and studies, through an independent third party. 3.4 Evaluation Report on Safety of Taunsa Barrage by Consultants (June 1998) The IPD appointed a group of Consultants to evaluate the safety of Barrages and important canal structures including Taunsa Barrage. The Consultants for Taunsa Barrage maintained that the Barrage was unsafe and needed remedial measures. 3.5 Feasibility Study of Taunsa Barrage Project The IPD acquired the service s of a Consultants’ JV for preparation of feasibility study report for Taunsa Barrage project. 240 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman 3.5.1 Problems Identified by the Feasibility Study Taunsa Barrage soon after its commissioning in 1958 ran into multitude of problems, which multiplied with p assage of time. Then, a stage reached that indicated that the Barrage could collapse at any time, This, God forbid, would have resulted in; stoppage of irrigation water supply to 2,350,000 acres of fertile land and drinking water supply to about 6 million people and their live stock served by Taunsa Barrage canal systems; disruption of rail road traffic across the Indus; destruction of oil and gas pipe lines supported by the Barrage piers; etc. Thus problems to be solved included: Retrogression of levels on the downstream and resulting problem of jump washout and energy dissipation Subsurface flow problems and separation of foundation alluvium Repeated damages to impact blocks, deflection blocks and skin concrete Excessive sediment entry into DG Khan canal, silt ejector failure, and consequent feeding problems Fish ladder inefficiency The flared out walls – inefficient drainage Defects in regulation gates & gearings, causing multiple operational hazards General aging effects 4. PROJECT OBJECTIVES The main objectives of the Project were to take urgent steps to prevent an impending failure of Taunsa Barrage The World Bank helped launch the “Taunsa Barrage Emergency Rehabilitation and Modernization Project” in May 2005 to achieve the af oresaid objectives and assist Punjab IPD in overcoming the problems associated with Taunsa Barrage. 5. SURVEYS AND INVESTIGATIONS FOR TAUNSA BARRAGE PROJECT Taunsa Barrage being in operation for last five decades a wealth of information was available with the operators i.e. IPD. Only necessary and limited surveys and investigations had to be carried out for feasibility and project planning stages. 5.1 Surveys 5.1.1 Topographic Survey The cross -sectional surveys of the Barrage carried out during January to March 2004 are listed below: i. Detailed topo survey map 500 ft upstream and 1500 ft downstream of Barrage. ii. X-sections through Barrage bays No 11, 24, 37, 51 and 64. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 241 iii. X-sections on the upstream side at RDs 0+000, 0+033, 0+098, 0+230, 0+361 and 0+492. iv. Observed x -sections on the downstream side at RDs 0+085, 0+135, 0+177, 0+194, 0+243, 0+308, 0+374, 0+440, 0+570, 0+700, 0+900, 1+000, 1+200 and 1+500. In addition to above, x -sections were also observed at RDs 1+000, 1+500, 2+000 and 2+500 downstream of the Barrage gate line, 5.1.2 Hydrological Data Acquisition and Analysis Hydrological data comprising peak annual discharges for the period 1958 (Barrage commissioning date) to 2003 was collected and subjected to probability analysis with Gumbel’s EV-1 distribution model which yielded the following figures for probable maximum discharges for various return periods: Return Period (Years) Probable Maximum Discharges (Cusecs) 2.33 462,700 10 616,000 50 767,400 100 831,500 200 895,300 The barrages are normally designed for a return period of 100 years, which in this case comes to 831,500 cusecs. Since Taunsa Barrage has never experienced the designed discharge of 1,000,000 cusecs (max. recorded in Barrage life of 50 years was 760,000 cuse cs), the issue was discussed in the Design Review Committee of IPD and it was decided that the original capacity (Designed) of the barrage should not be compromised and hence the discharge for design of project/rehabilitation works was adopted as 1,000,000 cusecs. 5.1.3 Hydrographic Survey Consultants survey team carried out detailed survey of the Barrage proximities both upstream and downstream and verified the survey already done by Taunsa Barrage Division Staff in other reaches (further up and down). V erification of survey plans prepared by the IPD was also done by comparison with (Land Sat – 7ETM) satellite images duly digitized and vector layers prepared by Geographic Information System (GIS) analysis. Unnecessary details were not picked up to save on time because the project was designated to be implemented on emergent fast track basis. 5.2 Geotechnical Investigations The properties of alluvium supporting the subsidiary weir were determined with samples from 5 boreholes each 50 ft deep, and grain si ze analysis, Atterberg 242 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Limits, Standard Penetration Test (SPT) and Direct Sheer were determined by Soilcon Laboratory. The alluvium was found to be fine sand, non cohesive, and gave good SPT values which indicated safe bearing capacities of over 1.5 tons/ psf at RL 415.0, 2.5 tons/psf at RL 408.0 and over 3 tons/psf at RL 397.0 which is the bottom level of sub-weir concrete. The required value was 1.5 tons/sft. More over prescribed values of compaction having been kept as 95% modified AASHTO specifications, no problem could be expected. Three borehole logs for the river bed portion of the prism appear in Annex-A, sheet 1 to 3 of 12. 5.3 Geophysical Investigations Based on site conditions, electrical resistivity (horizontal profiling), gravity and shallow seismic refraction surveys were carried out to: Delineate the voids and channels below concrete mass of downstream floor of the Barrage. Assess the extent of the voids and channels underneath, including their shape and size The above mentioned survey s were conducted during annual canal closure of Rabi 2003-04 for the following locations on downstream floor of the Barrage: Right undersluice Pocket – Bay No. 62-65 Left undersluice Pocket Bay No. 1-7 Main weir Bays No. 36-39 Snapshots of Geophy sical Surveying in stilling basin of Right Undersluice appear in Figures 7, 8 & 9. Figure 7: Electrical Resistivity Survey in progress in downstream right undersluices Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 243 Figure 8: Gravity Survey in progress in downstream right undersluices Figure 9: Shallow Seismic Refraction Survey in progress in downstream right undersluices 5.3.1 Results of Geophysical Investigations i. Interpretation of data collected from downstream floor of right undersluices indicated presence of cavities/channels under the 244 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman structure. Also higher resistivity suggested the existence of coarse – grained material or voids/cavities at certain locations in downstream right undersluices. ii. In the stilling basin of Bays No. 36 -39, geophysical survey indicated presence of poor qu ality of concrete and presence of cavities/channels in the subsoil just below the concrete mass. iii. The stilling basin of left undersluice gave similar but worse results. 5.4 Confirmatory Drilling In order to verify the results of geophyscial investi gations, confirmatory drilling was carried out during March – April 2004. Conventional method of drilling was adopted and 5 boreholes were drilled, at three locations where electrical resistivity (horizontal profiling), gravity and shallow seismic refracti on surveys had been conducted in January 2004. Figure 10 shows snaps of confirmatory drilling at site. Photograph # 2: Confirmatory (Ground Truthing) drilling in Progress at D/S Right Under Sluice, Taunsa Barrage. Photograph # 1: Preparation for confirmatory drilling at D/S Right Under Sluice, Taunsa Barrage. Photograph # 3: Another view of confirmatory drilling in Progress at D/S Right Under Sluice, Taunsa Barrage. (Bay # 36) Photograph # 5: Confirmatory drilling in Progress at D/S Right Under Sluice, T aunsa Barrage. Figure 10: Brief Results of confirmatory drilling 5.4.1 Brief Results of confirmatory drilling i. While drilling on the downstream of right undersluice, it was observed that the rate of penetration was much faster than cutting of a well graded cement concrete, thus confirming existence of poor quality Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 245 concrete. The first one -foot was drilled in only 55 minutes. The concrete floor was penetrated up to a depth of 2’- 6”. ii. While Drilling in downstream floor in front of Bay No. 36, the rate of penetration increased drastically, after a depth of 2 ft unacceptable for concrete. Rate of penetration in alluvium below the c oncrete was 1 ft per minute showing loosely filled pockets or cavities. Drilling through the first 5 ft of mass concrete was accomplished in only 100 minutes, at an average rate of 20 minutes per ft, depicting poor quality of concrete. iii. In Bay # 5, 1’ -5” of mass concrete was drilled in only 3 minutes and fresh river water with sand started to spew out at an approximate discharge of 1 to 1.5 cusec. This indicated that a sizable cavity had developed in the concrete mass and connected to base alluvium. Considering the situation further drilling was stopped, pipe casing was installed to balance the water head and borehole was then plugged with epoxy cement, sand and aggregate mixture. 6. RETROGRESSION AND TAIL WATER RATING CURVE 6.1 Retrogression Taunsa Barrage had to be located at an un -gauged site. The original gauge discharge relationship for design of Taunsa Barrage was determined on the basis of the minimum gauges recorded at Ghazi Ghat during the period 1930 to 1939. Two options were considered and the adopted alternative, provided for a retrogression of 4.7 ft at 10,000 cusecs, 2.5 ft at 200,000 cusecs and 1.3ft at 900,000 Cusecs. The calculation model some how erred in assuming the river slope and rather high water levels were made the basis of bar rage design. The barrage therefore has a rather in-built element of lowering of water levels on the downstream. This is confirmed by the fact that water levels experienced during the construction period (1954 -1958) were observed to be substantially lower than even designed minimum retrogressed levels. 6.2 Actual Performance The retrogression phenomenon is generally experienced at all new barrages in the early post commissioning period. However, after the bed configuration in the upstream pond area stabil izes, the retrogression cycle is reversed (recovery cycle starts) and the bed configuration on the downstream of the barrage reverts to normal conditions with water levels generally close to pre barrage values. At Taunsa Barrage, the conditions did not va ry in the usual course. The barrage was experiencing tail -water levels (TWLs) that were substantially lower than even the minimum designed retrogressed levels, although 46 years had elapsed since its commissioning. This problem attracted the attention of the barrage staff in the Mid -sixties and their reports indicated a perpetually worsening situation. 246 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman 6.3 Effects of Retrogression The lowering of TWLs below the designed minimum levels causes reduction in tail water depths. This naturally results in depth s less than the conjugate depths required for formation of a good hydraulic -jump at the proper place and level for effective energy dissipation. The difference in actual and designed levels, results in the formation of an unstable jump due to inadequate ta il-water depth resulting in inadequate energy dissipation. The un -dissipated energy and the negative pressure in the trough, caused up-rooting of trapezoidal blocks and Reinforced Concrete (RC) skin. The shifting of jump downstream also causes settlement o f PCC blocks filter area and lifting / washing away of the apron stone. The lifting away of skin also exposed the lean mass concrete which had profusely leaking joints that yielded fairly high discharge, and velocity enough to dislodge and move fine particles from underneath the downstream floor resulting in cavities and increase in residual pressures and potential threat to the stilling basin floor of the Barrage. 6.4 Analysis of Available Data To analyze the existing retrogression status, gauges and dis charges observed on the downstream were plotted on semi -log graph paper and minimum and maximum level envelope lines drawn which allow for intra / extrapolation of levels for discharges other than actually experienced. Such envelope curves / lines, for the selected recent years appear in Annex-A, Sheet 4 to 7 of 12. The minimum TWLs obtained from semi -log plots of downstream gauges from 1954 to 2003 are listed at Annex -A sheet 9 of 12 wherein the levels for discharges higher than those actually experienced are extrapolated values. A comparison with the design minimum retrogressed levels is also exhibited by this table. These levels have been presented at Annex -A sheet 10 of 12 and compared with the designed tail water rating levels and designed minimum retr ogressed levels, which clearly indicate that, although a couple of recovery cycles had been experienced, still the retrogression problem did exist in substantial magnitude. The magnitude of retrogression for the year 2003 (most recent) levels is exhibited Annex-A sheet 11 of 12. The above discussions confirmed that the worst was not yet over at Taunsa Barrage with reference to retrogression. The retrogression appeared to worsen with high flood discharges and show recovery in the low flow years. 6.5 Reduction in Barrage Capacity The minimum levels required for formation of stable hydraulic -jump appear in Annex-A, Sheet 12 of 12 along with the designed assumption and latest minimum TWLs for 2003 in Annex -A, Sheet 11 of 12. The Barrage capacity had reduced t o 500,000 cusecs against the designed discharge of 1,000,000 cusecs (only 50 %). The situation warranted immediate remedial measures to mitigate the retrogression and ensure Barrage safety. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 247 7. REMEDIAL MEASURES The remedial measures directed towards miti gating the effects of retrogression mainly aimed at improving the TWLs. The following options were considered: i. Remodeling the stilling basin by introduction of devices that could raise the water levels required for improvement in energy dissipation. ii. Conversion of last row of deflection blocks into an end sill. iii. Adding a second stilling basin at the end of the present one. iv. A Subsidiary weir placed downstream of loose stone apron. v. A pair of spurs anchored one each to right and left ba nk to constrict the water-way. vi. A breaching section. vii. A low Ogee-shape weir crest on piles. viii. A flexible weir constructed with stone gabions at the end of impervious floor. The relative merits of each of the above options are discussed below:- i. Remodeling of Stilling Basin The stilling basin of Taunsa Barrage had inherent structural deficiencies like the damages to skin concrete, which had virtually no bond with the low strength base concrete. The impact blocks and the deflector blocks were not properly anchored. The remodeling of stilling basin would therefore have required major changes, like strengthening of skin concrete, provision of additional energy dissipation devices and consequently strengthening of the downstream stone apron and even extending the floor and providing measures equivalent to enhancing depth of the end sheet-pile. Even then this option had no efficacy for increasing the depth in stilling basin (d2) with no effect on jump formation. This option was therefore dropped. ii. Conversion of last row of deflector blocks into an end-sill / baffle wall This option required provision of an end sill with a top elevation of 423.5 i.e., 7.5 ft (423.5 minus 416) higher than the floor which could create a fall of 7.5 feet at the end of the impervious floor necessitating another stilling basin and so goes out of reckoning. iii. Adding a second stilling basin at the end of the existing one This stilling basin if provided had to negotiate a fall of 10.5 ft (7.5 plus retrogression all owance of 3 ft) with a stilling basin floor level of 412.0 with end sheet pile bottom at 388 increasing uplift pressures under the existing floor requiring thickening which would reduce the conjugate depth thus setting up a 248 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman vicious circle. Construction of this alternative would also have been almost impossible because excavation to a level well below the bottom of existing piles in its close proximity was extremely risky and unacceptable leaving aside the abnormally high cost involved. This proposal was, t herefore, found unworkable and thus ignored. iv. A Subsidiary Weir A subsidiary weir was considered to be an ideal solution from maintenance and operational point of view. There were two options for locating this structure: i. Place the subsidiary weir within the downstream divide walls. This, on surface appeared to be an attractive option, but had serious repercussions. Working within the divide walls with a dry bed excavated to a level of 408.0 could result in over turning of the divide walls which have been designed for a much smaller head across. The situation would have been similar to that for option (iii) above. Trying to implement this option would have been simply suicidal. This option was, therefore also discarded. ii. The sub weir was therefor e proposed to be constructed at a distance of ±900 ft downstream of barrage gate line which is a sound and feasible option. v. A Pair of Spurs on the Downstream to Constrict the Water-way This proposal formed a part of recommendations made in the late 196 0s but this could not serve the purpose because: The heading up caused by the spurs could generate severe scour at the spur-heads and also in the bed, thus causing damage to spur -heads and the heading up could be soon lost due to bed scour and consequen t deepening of the channels, which would have further aggravated the problem. The maintenance cost of spurs was too high. Contrary to the purpose we have, such Spurs were constructed at Khanki Head Works for retrograding the accreted bed levels in la te 1950s with little benefit. This option was, therefore, excluded from further consideration. vi. A Breaching Section The set up of infrastructure around Taunsa Barrage did not allow provision of a breaching section due to resulting damages to the Canal s, Highway, Rail Road and oil & gas pipelines. vii. A Weir Crest on Piles The construction of an RC ogee profile weir crest founded on piles and placed at the end of the present stilling basin with a hump level of 424 could also be Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 249 expected to provide th e required protection as visualized through model tests in Taunsa Barrage laboratory in 1967. However the construction could pose severe problems which could be hardly negotiated without prohibitive and wasteful expenditure. viii. Serge Leliavsky’s Rock Weir Serge Leliavsky suggests a rock filled gabion weir with profile walls and a cistern for such conditions, but such intervention is only useful in flashy streams like hill torrents. In Perennial Rivers like Indus a rock weir is an utter failure, because it has to face high velocities of upto 40 ft/sec for most of the time throughout the year resulting in serious damages to the trough area as the stones and even gabions can be dislodged due to hydrodynamic action and negative pressures. The persistent high velocities cause heavy scour at the end of the structure and settlement of the downstream protection and also the crest, ultimately leading to failure of the structure. The Ogee shaped crest and the Rock Weir, both showed comparable performance on the mo del, but the maintenance problems of rock weir and construction environment required for the ogee shaped crest out -weighed their utility. The above analysis led to the conclusion that only a regular Subsidiary Weir was the option of choice to be construct ed at a suitable distance of about ±900 ft downstream of the Barrage gate line, for mitigating the problem of retrogression of levels.. 8. HYDRAULIC MODEL STUDIES Hydraulic model studies are, extensively used to check, modify and improve the analytical de signs of hydraulic structures. Although model studies involve additional costs, yet they have been found very useful to improve the designs. Model studies of Taunsa Barrage were carried out in 2004 -05 by IRI at Lahore to verify the hydraulic design. A s ectional model of the existing Barrage on a geometrical scale of 1/50 & 1/60 was set up in a 40 inch wide glass flume to study the flow conditions. The existing flow conditions indicated the formation of hydraulic jump on glacis slope upto a discharge of 5 00,000 cusec only and beyond that, the flow intensities pushed the hydraulic jump down the stilling basin. The subsidiary weir designed by Consultants was tested on the model by placing it at different locations and maintaining the TWLs to prescribed values. As a result of experiments, the subsidiary weir with crest level at RL 424.0 placed at a distance of ±900 ft was recommended to cater for the inadequacy of tail water depths below the Barrage and to maintain the hydraulic jump on glacis slope of Barrage for the whole range of discharge upto the design discharge of 1,000,000 cusec. The details of experiments regarding sectional model of Taunsa Barrage were presented by IRI in Report # 1172 dated June 2005. Conclusions of this report were: 250 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman i. From the results of second phase of experiments, it was observed that the crest level of RL 423 for the subsidiary weir appears to be critical and the weir becomes very sensitive to any amount of retrogression or accretion downstream. It is therefore concluded that the crest level of RL 424.0 for subsidiary weir placed at a distance of 925 ft from Barrage gate line is quite optimum to cater for the inadequacy of tail water depths below the Barrage and maintain the hydraulic jump at glacis slope of the Barrage weir f or the whole range of discharge upto the design discharge of 1,000,000 cusecs. ii. It is also concluded that the replacement of impact and deflector blocks by chute blocks is helpful in reducing the fluctuation in the channel lower down. iii. It was also noticed that the end sill of the subsidiary weir caused fluctuation at higher discharges beyond 600,000 cusec. It is therefore advisable that the top levels of the end sill may be lowered by 2 ft and its slope may be flattened to 2:1 to eliminate any turb ulence in the channel lower down. iv. The end sill at the downstream floor of the Barrage appears to be superfluous. Rather, it produces turbulence in the flow lower down. It may either be done away with or its level may be lowered to RL 419.5. Table 5: Proposed TWLs by IRI against different discharges Q (cusec) Min. Gauges Assumed in Design by IRIR Designed Min. Retrogressed Levels Existing TWLs (Average) Proposed TWLs for New Design (allowing 3 ft retrogression) 30,000 – 427.18 420.96 417.96 40,000 432.00 428.35 422.14 419.14 50,000 – 429.33 423.04 420.04 80,000 434.14 431.33 425.00 422.00 100,000 435.15 432.15 425.92 422.92 200,000 437.50 435.00 428.67 425.67 300,000 438.90 436.70 430.35 427.35 400,000 439.90 438.00 431.48 428.48 500,000 440.70 439.00 432.44 429.44 600,000 441.30 439.70 433.22 430.22 700,000 441.80 440.30 433.82 430.82 800,000 442.30 440.90 434.42 431.42 900,000 442.70 441.40 434.92 431.92 1,000,000 443.00 441.80 435.31 432.31 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 251 9. IDENTIFICATION OF PROBLEMS AND PROPOSED REMEDIAL MEASURES As brought out in other sections, the problems and executed remedial measures are tabulated below:- Problems Remedies Retrogression of levels on the downstream of barrage and consequential issues Construction of subsidiary weir at 925 ft downstream of the barrage to raise the TWL to safe values. Repeated damages to stilling basin appurtenances including Rupture of skin concrete and leaking joints of the mass concrete. Grouting of mass concrete and cavities beneath, removal of existing shattered skin, 1 ft lean concrete under lay and laying of 3 ft thick concrete overlay with nominal reinforcement. Sedimentation problems in DG Khan canal Construction of silt excluder in the upstream right pocket and raising crest of head regulator of DG Khan Canal. Repeated subsidence of the backfill of left and right flared out walls on the downstream Provision of a proper drainage system. Choking of about 80% of pressure pipes and malfunctioning of the remaining 20%. Provision of Vibrating Wire Piezometers in 10 bays of the Barrage and 7 rows in the new subsidiary weir. Problems of gates and hoists Replacing the undersluices gates, rehabilitation and strengthening of main weir, & canal gates, replacing the Barrage hoist system. Improvements through amended design and automation for better regulation of flows. 10. DESIGN OF REMEDIAL MEASURES Design of the remedial measures proposed above was carried out as per established engineering principles. A brief description of design as pects for each component follows: 10.1 Design Standards The following table 6 exhibits the design standards adopted for design of various features of the Project. 252 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Table 6: Design Standards for Various Design Features/Works Sr # Design Features Theory / Standard Adopted 1 Frequency Analysis for Estimation of the Peak Annual Discharge Gumbel Extreme Value Type-I 2 Surface Flow Conditions – Hydraulic jump analysis and relevant floor thickness Crump and Khosla methods 3 Subsurface Flow Analysis Safety against Uplift Pressures Seepage Analysis Floor Thicknesses Khosla’ s Theory Khosla’ s Theory, & Lane’s weighted creep Theory Khosla’ s Theory 4 Stilling Basins Type USBR Engineering Monograph No. 25 Modified Type IV 5 Stone Aprons Scour depths using Lacey’s Method and the Blench Equation 6 Abutment & Flared out Walls USBR Monograph No. 27 7 Earth Pressure for Stability Analysis for walls and embankments Coulomb’s Theory 8 Structural Design American Concrete Institute (ACI), building code of 2000 or British Standards (BS) where ACI Code does not carry certain pertinent information. 10.2 Design Discharge Historical discharge data reveals that the original design discharge of 1,000,000 cusecs has never been experienced at Taunsa Barrage. Figure 11 depicts annual discharge data from 1958 to 2003, the highest peak discharge recorded at this site was 760,784 cusecs in 1958. The frequency analysis showed values of 831,500 cusecs and 895,300 cusecs for return periods of 100 & 2 00 years, respectively. The Barrages are usually designed for discharge capacity of 100 years return period flow. In a meeting of the Departmental Design Review Committee held on 31st March 2004, it was agreed that the original designed capacity of 1,000,0 00 cusecs should be adopted for the purpose of design of the subsidiary weir and its related works. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 253 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 700,000 800,000 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 Year Discharge (cusecs) Figure 11: Peak Annual Discharges of River Indus at Taunsa Barrage Site 10.3 Accretion / Retrogression At Taunsa, the accretion/retrogression condition s have not occurred in normal course. The Barrage was experiencing TWLs that were substantially lower than even the minimum designed retrogressed levels, although 46 years had already elapsed since its commissioning. A complete analysis of the present retrogression status showed that downstream water levels had suffered a retrogression of 4 to 7 ft. This lowering of TWL below the designed minimum levels had resulted in unstable hydraulic jumps and inadequate energy dissipation. This phenomenon caused up-rooting of (impact)/trapezoidal blocks and RC skin. To address the above mentioned problems, eight options for remedial measures were considered as already mentioned earlier in paragraph 7: After a detailed analysis of the above mentioned eight (8) option s, it was concluded to construct a subsidiary weir, with a crest level of 424 ft, at a distance of 925 ft downstream of the existing Barrage gate line. The design allows for an additional retrogression of 3 ft at a discharge of 1,000,000 cusecs. Likewise , the exit gradient of 1 in 6 has been based on soil analysis for subsurface alluvium. 10.4 Final Design Data of Subsidiary Weir Total length of weir between two abutments is 4,346 ft, which is the same as that of Barrage. This length includes 4,281 ft ov erflow section, navigation lock, 2 fish ladders, and 3 divide walls. Hydraulic design of the subsidiary weir and its navigation lock has been based on the tail water rating curve data depicted in Table 254 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman 7/Figure 12 Salient design features of the subsidiary weir are depicted in the following Table 8. Table 7: Permissible Discharge Intensities at Various TWL for Navigation Lock in the Sub Weir Tail Water level (ft) Discharge Intensity (Cusecs/ft) 425.50 23.40 428.00 46.80 429.50 70.00 430.30 93.60 431.10 116.50 431.70 140.00 432.20 163.00 432.70 186.30 433.10 210.00 433.40 233.00 T AUNS A B AR R AG E (F OR S UB -WE IR & NAVIG AT ION L OC K ) G R AP H S H OWING MAX IMUM P E R MIS S IB L E INT E NS IT IE S F OR T WL 23.4 46.8 70 93.6 116.5 140 163 186.3 210 233 0 50 100 150 200 250 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 T ail Water L evel -T WL (ft) D is c harg e Intens ity-q (C us ec / ft) Figure 12: Maximum permissible flow intensities for various TWLs Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 255 Table 8: Salient as Built Features of Subsidiary Weir Design Flood 1,000,000 cusecs Weir Type Sharp Crested / Glacis Type Crest Level 424.00 ft Weir Crest 6 ft wide Upstream HFL 441.54 ft downstream HFL 435.15 ft Upstream Floor Level 417.00 ft downstream Floor Level 408.00 ft Navigation Lock 1.0 Two Fish Ladders Each 11 ft wide Upstream Stone Apron 67.0 ft long & 5.5 ft thick downstream Stone Apron 90.0 ft long & 6.0 ft thick Upstream Block Apron 28.0 ft long, 4.0 ft thick downstream Block Apron 53.66 ft long, 4.0 ft thick Upstream Inverted Filter 1.0 ft thick (2 layers) downstream Inverted Filter 2.0 ft thick (4 layers) Upstream Impervious Floor 40.0 ft long & 2 ft thick downstream Impervious Floor 125.0 ft long & 10.5 to 3.5 ft thick Upstream Glacis 14.0 ft long downstream Glacis 48.0 ft long Total length of Impervious Floor 233 ft Left Upstream Flared out Wall Counterfort Type: (Retaining wall with counter forts) 152 ft Long Left downstream Flared out Wall (Counterfort Type: (Retaining wall with counter forts) 155 ft long Right Upstream Flared out Wall 152 ft Long (Counterfort Type: Retaining wall) Right downstream Flared out Wall 155 ft long (Counterfort Type: Retaining wall) Sheet Piles Bottom Levels: Upstream end of upstream floor 395 ft downstream end of upstream floor 395 ft At Toe of Glacis 379 ft downstream end of downstream floor 379 ft Divide Walls Three, each 7 ft thick, separating the navigation lock, fish ladders and the overflow weir section. Vibrating Wire Type Piezometers Forty nine piezometers installed in 7 rows Stand pipe Piezometers One in each row of VW Piezometers for comparison and calibration facility. 256 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman A brief description of major components of the subsidiary weir, such as navigation lock and fish ladder appears in the following: 10.5 Navigation Lock A navigation lock with radial gates and stop logs on upstream side and a service bridge has been provided within the subsidiary weir with following design parameters: Table 9: Design Parameters of Navigation Lock Maximum permissible river Discharge for lock operation 400,000 cusecs Minimum Operating Discharge 20,000 cusecs Location Adjacent to the left abutment of the subsidiary weir so that boats can easily negotiate as the existing lock in main barrage is also on the same side. Type Glacis Type Crest Level 420.00 ft Maximum upstream Water Level (HFL) 441.25 ft Minimum upstream Water Level 424.00 ft Maximum downstream Water Level (existing HFL) 435.00 ft Maximum downstream Water Level HFL (retrogressed) 432.15 ft Upstream Water Level at 400,000 cusecs 433.80 ft downstream Water Level at 400,000 cusecs 431.32 ft Upstream Floor Level 417.00 ft downstream Floor Level 408.00 ft Width 22.0 ft Length of lock Chamber 122.5 ft Upstream Gate 32 ft radius downstream Gate 40 ft radius Originally the upstream gate resting on the crest was to be a mitre gate and a radial gate at the end of the lock chamber. However in response to the advice / suggestion of International Panel of Experts (PoE), the design of the navigation bay was amended for perpetual flow and the upstream mitre gate replaced with a radial gate. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 257 These gates will help to regulate supplies through the lock as needed for keeping the vehicles (water crafts) approach channel clear for perpetual use, keeping the downstream area clear of debries and will also improve working of the left fish ladder. 10.6 Fish Ladders Fish Ladders for the subsidiary weir have been designed keeping in view design parameters of the existing fish ladders at Taunsa Barrage and the typical hydraulic conditions created due to newly constructed subsidiary weir. Conformity with the existing Barrage is necessary for proper fish movement. Two Fish-Ladders, one each on the left and right side of the subsidiary weir have been provided. The se ladders are pool and notch type with 2 feet wide notches, staggered in the baffle walls, which are inclined in plan at an angle of 60° in the upstream direction. As the subsidiary weir is un-gated, the fish ladders have been designed for an upstream water level of 424.0 ft which will increase for various discharges and for the designed discharge, the upstream level rises to 441.25 ft. Similarly, downstream water level has been adopted as RL 419 which is the existing TWL for a discharge of 20,000 cusecs. The design data for fish ladders in subsidiary weir is depicted in the following table: Table 10: Design Parameters of Fish Ladders Number 2 Location Adjacent to left & Right undersluices Width 11 ft Total Drop 20.00 ft Pond Level 446.00 ft Drop of each Pool 1.00 ft Total Length of Ladder 262.00ft Depth of Pool 4.00 ft Width of fish inlet 4 ft. Width of fish outlet 3 ft. Angle of baffle walls 60° Foot Bridge 5ft wide 10.7 Stone Aprons Stone aprons on the upstrea m and downstream sides of the subsidiary weir have been designed on the basis of probable scour depths for the design flood of 1,000,000 cusecs. For determining the maximum local scour, the traditional sub – continental methods covering mainly “the regime” a pproach have been used and 258 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman results checked and compared with USBR method of zero bed transport by Blench for checking the “non -scouring depth (or river bed equilibrium level)” for the maximum flood discharge intensity. Larger of the scour depths resulting from Lacey’s Method and the Blench Equation have been used for design purposes. The stone size/weight has been determined by using USBR curve for velocity versus stone size at the average velocity for the maximum design discharge intensity. Density of the stone is taken at 165 lbs/cft. The length and thickness of the stone apron have been determined on the basis of following conditions: Apron will launch to a slope of close to 2H:1V depending upon the characteristics of the river bed material. Thickness of stone apron when launched should not be less than 3 ft. The scour factor for aprons varies from 1.25 to 1.75 for the upstream and 1.75 to 2.25 for the downstream aprons. Application or other wise of flow concentration factor is decided on the basis of specific conditions prevailing at site of work. 10.8 P.C.C. Block Apron and Inverted Filter The upstream and downstream block aprons have been designed using traditional irrigation practices and by studying performance of the existing weirs. The length of aprons depends on the depth of scour and this has been calculated using the Lacey’s formula, i.e. R = 0.9 x (q2/f)1/3 For calculation of the length of block aprons the scour factor of 1.25 for the upstream apron and 1.5 for the downstream apron has been used. A flow concentration factor of 20% has been applied keeping in view the specific site conditions. As a subsurface flow transition between the impervious floors and the stone apron, an inverted filter has been provided. It consists of concr ete blocks of 4ft x 4ft x 4ft resting on four layer graded filter. Gravel/crushed stone filled joints between the blocks release the residual pressure safely The filter is graded so as to permit free movement of water but prevent the movement of sand. This filter bed of 4 layers of increasing porosity, from bottom to top, is weighed down by the 4ft x 4ft x 4ft heavy concrete blocks (for gradation, design of filter, reference may be made to the project design report). 10.9 Abutments and Flared out Walls Vertical-faced reinforced concrete abutments and the sloping -faced stone pitched earthen guide banks are joined through a transitional arrangement of flared out walls on each side. The upstream flared out walls are RC warped walls changing from 1 in 2 slope o f the river face of the guide banks to the vertical face of the abutments. Similarly, the downstream RC flared out walls change from the vertical face of the abutments to the 1 in 2 slope of the river face of the guide banks. The abutments forming central sections have vertical face on the river side. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 259 Except for the left abutment which is a solid RC retaining wall, right abutment and the flared out walls are reinforced concrete retaining walls with counter forts. However, thickness of the left abutment is governed by the space requirements for accommodating various protruding components of the adjacent navigation lock. For both left and right abutments, the top level has been kept same as of the guide banks along both upstream and downstream sides of the w eir section. The length of the vertical abutments is based on the length of the weir itself, whereas length of the upstream and downstream flared out walls is tied up with the top elevation of the guide banks, their side slopes towards the river, and their angles of convergence and divergence on the upstream and downstream sides. Provisions of USACE have been followed to fulfill the minimum steel requirements in thick sections. USBR Monograph No. 27 was used for moments and reactions for the design of ver tical slabs between the counter forts. Stability analysis was based on Coulomb’s Earth Pressure Theory and appropriate factor for earthquake was also taken into account. According to the latest seismic map of Pakistan, Taunsa Barrage lied in a very low tec tonic activity zone and accordingly an appropriate value of “g” for such conditions was used for design. 10.10 Guide Banks The upstream guide banks of the subsidiary weir are tied to the downstream guide banks of the existing Barrage. The shape in the pla n and the cross section are adopted as per practice followed in the recently completed similar structures. The general geometry of the guide banks of the existing Barrage has been adopted for the subsidiary weir as well. This of course, required some resha ping of the existing downstream guide banks of the Barrage to meet the geometrical requirements of linking the two works together. The top width of the guide banks has been adopted as 30 ft to provide access for maintenance vehicles and reserve stone sta cks. Slope on the river side and downstream nose of the guide banks is 2:1, and is protected by 1.5 ft thick hand packed stone pitching laid on 6 inches layer of rock spawl and 6 inches graded filter layer. 11. REHABILITATIONS OF THE EXISTING BARRAGE 11.1 Strengthening of Glacis and Floors A detailed examination of downstream floors of the existing Barrage based on Khosla Theory was conducted using excel spread sheet analysis, which revealed that floor thickness is deficient by about 1 ft, both in the mai n weir and the undersluice sections. The computed value of exit gradient was more than the safe value required for the sub -strata existing at site. A comparison between the required and the existing values of floor thicknesses and exit gradients is shown i n Table 11 below. 260 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Table 11: Comparison between the Required and the Existing Values of floor thicknesses and exit gradients Feature Required Originally Provided/Existing A. Floor Thickness, ft WEIR i. Upstream of Toe of glacis 10.44 9.50 ii. Downstream of Toe of glacis 8.54 8.00 iii. Downstream end of downstream Floor 5.39 5.50 UNDERSLUICES i. Upstream of Toe 11.24 9.75 ii. Downstream of Toe 9.24 8.50 iii. Downstream end of dowsntream Floor 5.57 5.00 B. FACTOR OF SAFETY AGAINST EXIT GRADIENT WEIR 6 to 7 4.50 UNDERSLUICES 6 to 7 4.40 On the basis of analysis mentioned earlier, it was decided to fill the cavities/hollows by controlled pressure grouting. As a structural stability measure, 1 ft damaged skin concr ete and 1 ft thick underlying lean concrete on the downstream floor was removed and replaced by 3 ft thick 4,000 psi concrete having nominal temperature reinforcement. On the glacis, however, only the 1 ft skin concrete was to be removed and replaced with the 4,000 psi concrete with nominal temperature reinforcement. The shortfall of pile depths was considered to have been mitigated by lower depths required after construction of the subsidiary weir due to reduced head across and 7 ft deep water cushion over the floor in the stilling basin. 11.2 Existing Fish Ladders in the Main Barrage Two fish ladders existed in the main barrage located on the left and right sides of the right and left side divide walls, respectively. Performance of these fish ladders had not been satisfactory owing to water levels lower than the entry ducts. On review of design aspects of these ladders, it was found that assuming a floor level of 438.0 in the first pool, water level would drop to 423.0 ft after 15 Nos drops Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 261 of 1 ft each. The level of 423.0 was 5 ft higher than the desired level of 418.0 ft. A drop of 5 ft was thus created downstream of the last pool, which no local fish could negotiate. To rectify the above design deficiencies and to make these ladders fish friendly, it was decided to proceed as follows: Increase the number of pools from the existing 15 to 23 in order to cater for a total drop of 23 ft from the raised floor level of 438.0 ft to the TWL. To accommodate the above modification, the length of the fish ladders had to be increased from existing 262 ft to 371 ft Salient features of remodeled design appear in the following table: Table 12: Amended Design Parameters of Fish Ladders in Main Barrage Number 2 Location Adjacent to left & right undersluices Width 11 ft Total Drop 23.00 ft Pond Level 447.00 ft Drop of each Pool 1.00 ft Total Length of Ladder 371.00ft Depth with Pool 4.00 ft Width of fish inlet 4 ft. Width of fish outlet 3 ft. Angle of baffle walls 60° Foot Bridge 5ft wide 11.3 Silt Excluder in Upstream Right Pocket To address the chronic problem of excessive silt entry into D.G Khan canal, some sort of effective intervention was essentially required to increase the discharge capacity of the canal to its designed value. Due to excessive silt entry, the canal bed silted by 6 to 7ft, thereby affecting its capacity adversely. It could not carry more than about 7000 cusecs against the interim design capacity of 11,800 cusecs. Silt level in the right pocket frequently rose to cre st level of the DG Khan Canal head regulator i.e. RL 433.0 ft and flushing of pocket had to be resorted to several times in each flow season. Actually only two bays (#65 and 64) were really necessary for serving D.G. Khan Canal but to facilitate future e xtensions/additions for Kachhi canal head regulator, Bay #63 was also provided with short tunnels. Each of these bays was divided into 4 tunnels of rectangular cross -section. Salient features of the silt excluder are given below: 262 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Table 13: Salient Design Data of Silt Excluder No. of Tunnels 12, 4 in each of Bay 65, 64 & 63 Length of Tunnels Immediately in front of DG Khan Canal Head Regulator = 246.50ft Last one in Bay 63 = 24.50ft Width of Tunnels 15 ft & 14.50ft for 2 outer & inner tunnels in Bay 63 & 64 and 13.75 & 13.5 ft for Tunnels in Bay 65. Height of Tunnel Height at Entrance = 11.50 ft Height at Exit = 5.5 ft Velocities at different Gate Openings for pond level of 447 ft, At Entrance 1 to 11 ft/sec and At Exit 20 to 22 ft/sec Top level of Tunnels Roof 432 ft Floor level of Tunnels at entry 419 ft Thickness of Roof Slab 1.5 ft Thickness of Walls 2.0 ft Discharging capacities of the various tunnels were calculated with due allowance for head loss inside the tunnels. These losses were based on Articles 227 and 228, Pressure Flow in Outlet Conduits (Design of Small Dams, USBR 1987). Hydraulic design computations based on the above criteria indicated the aggregate discharge capacity of all the tunnels as 26,230 cfs and 22,500 cusecs for the Low TWL of 425.0 ft and High TWL of 435.0 ft i.e. 185% and 158% respectively of the ultimate canal capacity of 14,200 cusecs including allowance for the future extension of Dajal Branch. Design capacity of the present D.G. Kha n Canal is 11,600 cusecs, say 12,000 cusecs. Required escapages for maximum efficiency will, however, be regulated by means of gates at the downstream end of the tunnels. Structural design of silt excluder tunnels was based on design methods set out in t he applicable provisions of the ACI, or BS where ACI Code does not carry certain pertinent information. All structural members were designed to withstand loads expected to be imposed during life time of the structure. These loads include the self weight of structure and the weight of water inside or on top of the structure, imposed loads such as hydrostatic and the uplift pressures, foundation soil pressures etc. The top slab of th e tunnels was provided with 3” Φ holes in a regular grid for pressure adjustment. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 263 11.4 Remodeling of the DG Khan Canal Head Regulator Remodeling of DG Khan Canal constituted raising the Head Regulator crest by 1.0 ft, replacement of sill beams, and reco nstruction of the breast wall, with simple design. 11.5 Rehabilitation of Gates of the Barrage and Head Regulators Taunsa Barrage along with the canal regulators was originally equipped with vertical lift stoney type gates which are operated manually thro ugh overhead wire rope hoist arrangement. The gates and hoist equipment along with allied steel structures and mechanical outfits were designed by M/s Brown & Roots, Inc. Houston, Texas USA during 1954. In view of the gigantic work involved, a full fledged mechanical workshop was set up at Bhalwal in collaboration with the said firm. The rehabilitation design of gates and hoisting system was firstly based on Pakistani standards but later on due to involvement of JICA, M & E works were divided into two par ts and also basis of design was changed to Japanse standards. Identical design was adopted for JICA component and World Bank assisted M & E works for sake of symmetry as two different design standards cannot be used in the same Barrage. For undersluice g ates, it was decided to replace the existing bowstring steel truss roller train gates with steel plate girder strengthened gates because truss structure is heavier and also difficult from maintenance point of view (cleaning and repainting) as large number of members are involved. Likewise, due to improved steel plate manufacturing and welding technologies, it is easier and cheaper to install a plate girder structure. 12. FINAL DESIGN DATA FOR M & E WORKS Design data of gate leaves, sill beams, guide frame s and hoists is given in following section. For design of gates, loads including self weight of gates, hydrostatic pressure, buoyant force, operating force, seismic forces and wind pressure have been considered. Table 14: Design Data of Undersluice Gates Parameters Description Gate Type Steel plate girder roller gate (stoney types) Number of Gates 11 Clear Span 60.00 ft Normal Maximum Pond Level 447.00 ft Sill Elevation 425.00 ft Gate Height 23.00 ft (448-425) Design Head Across 26.5 264 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Parameters Description Operating Head 24.00 ft (448-424) Sealing System Three edge with rubber seals. Hoist Type Electrically driven, 1 motor 2 drum type Gate Operation Local and Remote Control Operation Speed 1.0 ft/min (electrical operation) Lifting Height 32.00 ft (457.00-425.00) Table 15: Design Data of Main Weir Gates Parameters Description Gate Type Steel truss roller gate (Stoney type) Number of Gates 53 Clear Span 60.0 ft Normal Maximum Pond Level 447.0 ft Sill Elevation 428.0 ft Gate Height 20.0 ft (448.0-428.0) Design Head Across 26.5 ft Operating Head 24.0 ft (448.0-424.0) Sealing System Three edge with rubber seals at upstream Hoist Type Electrically driven, 1 motor 2 drum type Gate Operation Local and Remote Control Operation Speed 1.0 ft/min (electrical operation) Lifting Height 29.0 ft (457.0-428.0) 13. ALLOWABLE STRESS AND ALLOWABLE DEFLECTION The Technical Standards for Steel Water Gates and Penstocks established by Hydraulic Gate and Penstock Association of Japan has been used to determine these values. The above standard provides that the allowable deflection is less than 1/800 of the gate span in case of gate with 20m to 30m of span; however 1/600 of span is applied to the gates of Taunsa Barrage as the al lowable deflection taking into consideration the present gate span of 18m, that gives the gates almost equivalent deflection and stress as well as water tightness based on the following calculation, (25m/18m) x (1/800) = 1/576. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 265 14. INCREASING HEIGHT OF MAIN WEIR GATES For this purpose following two methods were considered: Adding one foot at the Bottom Adding one foot at the Top Addition of 1 ft at the bottom was selected for obvious reasons. 14.1 Rehabilitation of Superstructure Deck Due to raisi ng/shifting of the hoists, the upper deck structure had to be improved to make it compatible with new conditions. Improvement works included placement of hoist assembly system on top of the regulation deck for better operability, maintainability and safety . Also under improvement works, the timber boards of the regulation deck of the Barrage had to be replaced with steel grating. 14.2 Rehabilitation of Canal Head Regulator Gates Following remedial measures to existing problems were incorporated in the design process. Problem Cause Remedial Measures Guide frame becoming uneven The roller material is equivalent to or harder than the rail material. Use of a harder material for the rail than the material for the roller Leakage from the bottom The sill beams at the bottom had become uneven Renewal of the metal sill beams Changing the watertight plate at the bottom to watertight rubber to improve the capacity to deal with unevenness. Leakage from the sides Deformation of the gate leaf due to unevenness of the rollers Problem with the mechanism and structure of the rocker assembly. Improvement with the use of appropriate guide frames and rollers. Modification of the structure and mechanism of rocker assembly and replacement with the new modified ones. 15. FINANCIAL ARRANGEMENTS Sr # Source of Funding Amount (Rs. In million) 1 GOP 857.86 2 World Bank (Loan) 7,621.25 3 JICA (Grant in aid) 2,778.84 TOTAL 11,257.95 266 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman 16. PROJECT COST Description Amount (Rs. In Million) ICB-01 Cost (World Bank Financed) 4,709 ICB-01 Cost (World Bank Financed) 1,557 JICA Works Cost (Grant) 2,927 Other Charges (IDC, Duties, Taxes etc) 2,039 TOTAL COST 11,232 Financing ratio for World Bank assisted portion World Bank ~90% and GOP ~10% FINANCIAL ANALYSIS RESULTS (APPROVED PC-1) Benefit Cost Ratio = 1.14:1 at 12% discount rate Financial Internal Rate of Return (FIRR) = 15.19 18. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS RESULTS (APPROVED PC-1) Economic analysis as contained in the approved PC -1 gave the following conclusion: 1. EIRR (Base Data 30.37% 2. EIRR with 10% cost over run 22.40% 3. EIRR with 10% reduction in benefits 21.68% 4. EIRR with both 10% cost over run and 10% reduction in benefits 15.99% 5. Benefit cost ration at 12% discount rate 1.34:1 The above figur es establish that the opportunity cost of investment on this project is very healthy. 19. PEER REVIEWS (OVERALL) In addition to the studies under taken by special committees, research by Taunsa Barrage controlling staff and model studies up to design stag e, the project planning and design also passed through the following peer reviews by: i. Departmental Design Review Committee ii. Specialist Advisory Group iii. In House Peers iv. Independent International Panel of Experts (POE-1) v. World Bank’s Tech nical Experts (Engr. William T Smith, Barrage Specialist and Engr. Alessandro Palmieri, Dam Specialist) Considering the above, the Taunsa Barrage project is one of the most rigorously reviewed large international projects in the country which has been planned, designed and executed in time by purely Pakistani Engineers. Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 267 ANNEX – A Sheet 1 of 12 268 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Sheet 2 of 12 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 269 Sheet 3 of 12 270 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Sheet 4 of 12 TAUNSA BARRAGE ENVELOPE FOR TAIL WATER LEVEL YEAR 1981 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 10000 100000 1000000 Dow nstream Discharge (cusec) Downstream Gauge (R.L.)Maximum Envelope Designed Retrogressed Minimum Envelope Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 271 Sheet 5 of 12 TAUNSA BARRAGE ENVELOPE FOR TAIL WATER LEVEL YEAR 1990 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 10000 100000 1000000 Downstream Discharge (cusec) Downstream Gauge (R.L.)Maximum Envelope Designed Retrogressed Minimum Envelope 272 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Sheet 6 of 12 TAUNSA BARRAGE ENVELOPE FOR TAIL WATER LEVEL YEAR 2001 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 10000 100000 1000000 Downstream Discharge (cusec) Downstream Gauge (R.L.) Designed Retrogressed Maximum Envelope Minimum Envelope Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 273 Sheet 7 of 12 TAUNSA BARRAGE ENVELOPE FOR TAIL WATER LEVEL YEAR 2002 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 10000 100000 1000000 Downstream Discharge (cusec) Downstream Gauge (R.L.) Designed Retrogressed Maximum Envelope Minimum Envelope 274 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Sheet 8 of 12 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 275 Sheet 9 of 12 276 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Sheet 10 of 12 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 277 Sheet 11 of 12 Sr. No. Discharge Cusecs Designed Tail Water Level Rating (IRI) Designed Minimum Retrogressed Levels Actual Water Levels from Minimum Envelope for 2003 Actual Retrogression (ft) (3 – 5) Retrogression Provided in Design (ft) (3 – 4) Difference (ft) (6 – 7) Remarks 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 1 40,000 432.00 428.35 422.35 9.65 3.65 6.00 2 80,000 434.14 431.33 424.70 9.44 2.81 6.63 3 100,000 435.15 432.15 425.50 9.65 3.00 6.65 4 200,000 437.50 435.00 428.00 9.50 2.50 7.00 5 300,000 438.90 436.70 429.30 9.60 2.20 7.40 6 400,000 439.90 438.00 430.30 9.60 1.90 7.70 7 500,000 440.70 439.00 431.10 9.60 1.70 7.90 8 600,000 441.30 439.70 431.70 9.60 1.60 8.00 9 700,000 441.80 440.30 432.25 9.55 1.50 8.05 10 800,000 442.30 440.90 432.70 9.60 1.40 8.20 11 900,000 442.70 441.40 433.15 9.55 1.30 8.25 12 1,000,000 443.00 441.80 433.40 9.60 1.20 8.40 FOR 2003 TAIL WATER LEVELS STATEMENT SHOWING THE MAGNITUDE OF RETROGRESSION 278 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Sheet 12 of 12 Sr. # Discharge Intensities q (Cs) Min. TWL for Jump Formation Corresponding Upstream Water Levels Max. TWL for Jump Formation Corresponding Upstream Water Level Remarks 1 26.0 423.5 447.0 434.0 447.0 Gated Flow 2 52.0 427.0 447.0 436.0 447.0 Gated Flow 3 78.0 429.0 447.0 437.5 447.0 Gated Flow 4 104.0 430.7 447.0 438.5 447.0 Gated Flow 5 129.0 432.5 447.0 439.0 447.0 Gated Flow 6 155.0 434.2 447.0 440.5 447.0 Gated Flow 7 181.0 435.5 447.0 441.5 447.0 Gated Flow 8 207.0 437.0 447.0 442.2 447.0 Gated Flow 9 233.0 438.0 445.0 443.2 445.0 Gated Flow 10 260.0 439.0 446.0 444.0 446.0 Gated Flow PUNJAB BARRAGES REHABILITATION PROJECT SECITONAL MODEL OF TAUNSA BARRAGES (1/50) Limits of TWL for Hydraulic Jump at Glacis Crest Level = 428.0 Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 279 280 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 281 282 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 283 284 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman Pakistan Engineering Congress, 71st Annual Session Proceedings 285 286 Zaidi, Khan, Rehman
Filename:
PLANNING-AND-DESIGN-OF-TAUNSA-BARRAGE-REHABILITATION-PROJECT.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
5 MB
Categories:
0071st Annual Issue 2011
Downloads:
3
