World Environment Day June-2012 18 PARTICIPATORY IRRIGATION MANAGEMENT AND ITS ROLE IN GREEN ECONOMY By Ch. Karamat Ali1 and M. Rizwan Aslam2 1. Introduction and Background Punjab Irrigation System was established more than a century ago, mainly operated under Gravity and was rated as o ne of the best in the world. However due to population growth, Administrative inefficiencies and increased irrigation intensities, system was over stressed leading to poor service delivery. Institutional Reforms were introduced in Irrigation sector during 1997 focusing on decentralization, participatory irrigation management and improved service delivery. Under this changed management for implementation of reforms process the current functions of irrigation department are being shared by establishing the new institutions viz. Punjab Irrigation and Drainage Authority (PIDA) at provincial level, Area Water Board (AWB) at Canal Command level, Farmers Organizations (FOs) at distributary level and Khal Punchayats (KPs) at water course level. A comprehensive legal frame work has also been developed for smooth functioning of this management shift. In this scenario, the FO is a basic farmer -managed unit responsible for irrigation management, operation and maintenance of distributary / channels, abiana assessment / collection and protection of environment within its area. Below PIDA, quasi-autonomous AWBs have been established responsible for operation and maintenance of irrigation network, monitoring, supervision and providing support to FOs. The main role of FO inc ludes Abiana collection, equitable water distribution and more importantly better Environment . The Participatory Irrigation Management (PIM) being based at the grass route level could play a vital role to achieve this objective. Under the present scenario the projects are executed without proper environmental analysis at the distributary level and as such analysis carried out is not the true Reflection of ground situation / realities. How far this Participatory Irrigation Management has been succeeded to a chieve its defined role, brief discussion / analysis is being presented in the paper. Although currently there are constraints and more input is required in terms of Capacity Building and awareness creation among the community but it is also beyond any doubt that if the transition Management is enforced in real terms then this is key for success of better irrigation, enhanced resource generation and reduction in environmental degradation. These positive indicators will substantially contribute for econ omic growth and environmental improvement. ______________________________________________________________________________________ 1. Chief Engineer Irrigation / G. M. (Operation) PIDA. 2. Manager (M&E) PIDA. World Environment Day June-2012 19 Three pilot FOs formed in Bahawalnagar Canal Circle during 2000 followed by pilot AWB LCC (East), Faisalabad. Thereafter four AWBs – LCC (West), Derajat Canal Circle D.G Khan, Bahawalnagar (BWN) and Lower Bari Doab Canal (LBDC) Sahiwal have been established/notified and their operationalization has either completed or under process. Five AWBs comprising of 401 FOs and 19404 Khal Panchayats have been established so far. The setup of reforms tiers and latest operational activities of AWBs are as under : Fig-1 Table-1: Reform Status *FO: Farmer Organization *Admn : Administrator’s Tenure 5 IRRIGATION REFORMS TIERS Irrigation Deptt. PIDAAuthority Board Farmer Members (10) Board of Management (MD PIDA, 3- GMs) AWBs FOs Management Committee of FO (9- Members) Vice President General Secretary Treasurer Executive Members (5) Head Reach (01) Middle Reach (02) Tail Reach (02) CHAIRMAN Non-Farmer Members (05) Chairman (Farmer) Vice Chairman (Farmer) Non-Farmer Members (09) Farmer Members (10) President World Environment Day June-2012 20 The first Pilot Area Water Board was established in LCC (E) Faisalabad, wherein 84 FOs were formed and Irrigation Management Transferred (IMT) during 2005. These FOs completed their 3 years tenure in 2008. Thereafter Administrators appointed (2009-10). Management has now again been transferred to FOs. Like-wise 65 FOs were established in LCC (W), 30 FOs in Chashma Right Bank Canal (CRBC), 6 FOs in LJC, and irrigation management was transferred during July / August 2007. All the FOs completed their 1 st tenure by March 2011. There after Administrators appointed in all the Boards and election for 2nd tenure is under way. 2. Discussion and Analysis 2.1 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF AWBs IN RESPECT OF ABIANA COLLECTION Table-2: Abiana Collection of AWBs (%) Sr. No. Crop Collection (%) AWB LCC(East) AWB LCC(West) LJC Circle AWB CRBC AWB BWN 1 Rabi 2004-05 1st FO Tenure 88 3 FOs Pilot (Kh 2000-Kh 2004: 95-78%) 84 2 Kharif 2005 78 81 3 Rabi 2005-06 75 84 4 Kharif 2006 68 83 5 Rabi 2006-07 79 86 6 Kharif 2007 64 1st FO Tenure 90 1st FO Tenure 95 1st FO Tenure 34 80 7 Rabi 2007-08 61 85 95 11 83 8 Kharif 2008 Admn Tenure 60 73 93 11 Admn Tenure 72 9 Rabi 2008-09 62 76 92 6 76 10 Kharif 2009 51 63 92 5 73 11 Rabi 2009-10 53 64 94 4 75 12 Kharif 2010 2nd FO Tenure 72 Admn Tenure 70 Admn Tenure 93 Admn Tenure 20 FO Tenure 68 13 Rabi 2010- 11 77 73 93 13 68 14 Kharif 2011 70 70 91 14 80 Aggregate % 68 74 93 14 80 Remarks Increasing Trend (53 to 77%) Increasing Trend (64 to 73%) Constant Increasing Trend (4 to 13%) Increasing trend World Environment Day June-2012 21 Table -3: Aggregate Abiana Collection of AWBs & PIDA Share Rs. In Million AWBs Net Assessed Abiana Aggregate Collection since inception Collection (%age) Total calculated PIDA Share Deposited Amount % LCC(East), Faisalabad 1219.506 826.708 68 408.658 338.642 83 LCC(West), Faisalabad 608.289 447.947 74 213.393 170.929 80 LJC Sargodha 48.152 44.810 93 20.003 19.925 99 CRBC, D.G. Khan 103.655 14.697 14 7.500 4.327 58 Bahawalnagar 238.885 191.940 80 102.801 85.828 83 Total 2218.487 1526.102 69% 752.355 619.651 82% Table-4: Categorical status of Abiana of FOs Abiana Recovery Ranges from : LCC (East) LCC (West) LJC CRBC Bahawalnagar No. of FOs (Rabi: 04-05 to Kharif :11) % FOs No. of FOs (Kharif: 07 to Kharif: 11) % FOs No. of FOs (Rabi: 07 to Kharif: 11) % FOs No. of FOs(K harif:0 7 to Kharif: 11) % FOs No. of FOs (Rabi: 00 to Kharif: 11) % FOs 0% 3 341 FOs 30% 1 105 FOs 19% 0 0 FOs 0% 116 0 1 – 10 % 21 8 0 53 255 FOs 94% 0 16FO s 12% 11 – 20 % 25 8 0 27 0 21 – 30 % 42 11 0 24 0 31 – 40 % 66 14 0 18 2 41 – 50 % 89 11 0 6 6 51 – 60 % 95 52 0 11 8 61 – 70 % 138 794 FOs 70% 89 462 FOs 81% 3 50F Os 100 % 7 15 FOs 6% 21 122F Os 88% 71 – 80 % 136 148 0 3 35 81 – 90 % 119 60 11 2 34 91 – 99 % 146 69 9 0 23 100% 255 96 30 3 9 TOTAL 1135 567 50 270 138 World Environment Day June-2012 22 Fig.II Crop Wise Consolidated Status of Abiana Collection (Rabi 2004 – Kharif 2011) Comments • The performance of PIDA/FOs in term of Abiana recovery remained reasonably good in all AWBs during the first year of their inception (more than 85%). However the Abiana recovery substantially declined (55%) overtime in almost all the AWBS. • Abiana recovery reduced from 88% to 60% during FOs first tenurein AWB LCC (East) and further reduced to 52% during Administrative period. Almost similar situation prevailed in LCC (West) where recovery continuously decreased from 90% to 64% during FO period. However due to substantial input and constant pursuance from PIDA Headquarter and response from field formation record abiana recovery improved 52% to 77% in LCC (E) and 73 % in LCC (W) (comparative Administrator tenure). • As an outcome of these initiatives aggregate recovery has improved to 68% and 74% in LCC East & West respectively. The recovery position during Administrator’s tenure generally remained on low profile compared to the FO management. World Environment Day June-2012 23 • Three model FOs, established in Bahawalnagar Circle since 2000, and a lot of input made therein, but inspite of that Abiana recovery of these FOs also reduced from 95% to 83% during FO tenure and further declined to 75% during Administrative period. The aggregate recovery in Bahawalnagar Circle is 80%. • The worse position is in CRBC, where recovery status is very disappointing and alarming. It declined from 34% to 4%. However due to constant drive, the recovery has increased from 4% to 14% and there are now positive indicators for further improvement. • The best performer is Lower Jehlum Canal (LJC) Circle Sargodha wherein the recovery status of FOs remained above 90% during the entire period. The aggregate figure of recovery is 93% which is a good indicator for the success of this new Management shift from PID to PIDA. • Besides this overall recovery picture, the categorical status of abiana recovery (FO wise and crop wise) indicates that 70% FOs in LCC (East), 81%FOs in LCC (West), 100% FOs in LJC, 6% FOs in CRBC, and 88% FOs in BWN, have abiana collection from 61-100% during their entire period of institutional reforms. The analysis further reveals that 60% FOs in LJC circle and about 20% FOs in LCC East & West have 100% recovery of abiana during their entire period. • Likewise 30% FOs in LCC (East), 19% in LCC (West), 12% in BWN, and 94% in CRBC have Abiana recovery lesser than 60%. Thus the poorest is CRBC then LCC East, followed by West and then Bahawalnagar. LJC remained on top as best performing AWB (100%). The above data analysis indicates that more pursuance and input both from PIDA formation, and FOs management is required in CRBC, LCC (East), LCC(West) and Bahawalnagar. LJC is performing very good and could be referred as suc cess story of the institutional reform. 2.2 EQUITABLE DISTRIBUTION OF WATER Besides abiana recovery the sustained equitable distribution of water is the prime responsibility of FOs management as well as the PIDA Administrators. The historical record / data of channels both for FO management and Administrator / PID tenure (Irrigation Department) have been analyzed and represented as under ; Table-5 Tail Status of Channels AWB/ Canal Circle Period Total No. of running channel Tail status of channels (Nos. & %) Tail running as per Authorized % Short % Dry % Closed % World Environment Day June-2012 24 LCC (East) FO Tenure Kh: 2005 to Rabi 07-08 236 144 61 29 12 61 26 2 1 Admn Tenure Kh: 2008 to Rabi: 10-11 236 167 71 22 9 42 18 5 2 LCC (West) Pre IMT(PID) Kh: 2005 to Kh: 2007 176 143 81 22 13 10 6 1 1 FO Tenure Rabi: 07-08 to Rabi 10-11 176 113 64 38 22 23 13 2 1 Total 824 567 69 111 13 136 15 10 1 Fig. III World Environment Day June-2012 25 Tabe-6: Latest Tail Status of Channel (Rabi 2011-12) NP: Non-Perennial Discussion and Analysis • Table-5 above reveals that Administrator’s performance in term of water distribution in channel is better than FO in LCC (E). Likewise the performance of irrigation department/ Pre-IMT in LCC (W) is better than 3 years FO tenure. AWB/ Canal Circle Divisions Total No. of running Channels Tails Running as per Authorized Tails Remained Short Tails Remained Dry Channels remain closed (> 80% of days during the period) No. of Chan- nels % No. of Chan- nels % No. of Chan- nels % No. of Chan- nels % LCC(East) Khanki 17 13 76 3 18 1 6 29 (NP)* 0 Upper Gugera 57 31 54 7 12 14 25 5 9 Lower Gugera 62 56 90 2 3 2 3 2 3 Burala 70 52 74 6 9 10 14 2 3 Total 206 152 74 18 9 27 13 9 4 LCC(West) Faisalabad 54 36 67 10 19 8 15 2(NP)* 0 Hafizabad 47 39 83 3 6 5 11 1(NP)* 0 Jhang 72 50 69 8 11 13 18 1 1 Total 173 125 72 21 12 26 15 1 1 Bahawalna gar Fordwah 8 7 88 0 0 0 0 51(NP) * 0 Sadiqia 39 30 77 6 15 3 8 13(NP) * 0 Hakra 41 40 98 1 2 0 0 3 (NP)* 0 Total 88 77 88 7 8 3 3 0 0 LJC Sargodha 16 16 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 CRBC 62 62 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 Grand Total 545 432 79 46 8 56 10 10 2 World Environment Day June-2012 26 • 18% tails remained dry in LCC (E) during Administrator period compared with 26% in FO management tenure. Likewise 6% tails remained dry in LCC (W) during Pre-IMT compared with 13% during FOs management. • The status of tails of channels in LCC East remained slightly better than LCC West (74% V/S 72%) during last crop season Rabi 2011-12. • Table-6 above further indicates that FOs have not performed as good as either by PID or Administrators. There is need of continuous and effective Capacity Building of FOs, Public awareness and appropriate legal provision to take action against the culprits / involved in water theft. • However effective steps / measures have been taken during last one year and situation has now improved. The status of Rabi 2011 -12 reveals that the equitable water distribution and feeding of tails has improved up to 74% against 71% in LCC (E), 72% versus 64% in LCC (W). While 12% channels remained dry for most of time in LCC (W) and 9% in LCC (E). In Bahawalnagar 88% channels are feeding authorized tails and LJC is on the top (100%). • The intra- divisional status of tails rev eals that performance of Upper Gugera Division in LCC (East), Jhang and Faisalabad Divisions in LCC (West) and Sadiqia Division in Bahawalnagar remained lower than average performance of the respective AWB. The best performing divisions are Lower Gugera, and Hakra, and poorest are Upper Gugera, Faisalabad and Sadiqia Division. 2.3 DISPOSAL OF THEFT CASES FOs management as well as PIDA Administrators have also been entrusted the role of controlling the water theft / unauthorized irrigation to ensure equitable distribution among the users / irrigators. The progress of water theft cases during last crop season (Rabi 2011-12) is depicted in following Table. Table-7 Status of Water Theft Cases during Rabi 2011-12 Area Water Board Divisions Total cases detect- ed Cases Report- ed to Police % Age FIR Register ed % Age No. of Arrests made Nos. of Cases for which Tawanini tiated LCC (East) Khanki 321 215 67 64 30 33 215 Upper Gugera 95 84 88 44 52 18 84 Lower Gugera 21 13 62 9 69 12 13 Burala 59 50 85 22 44 3 50 Total 496 362 73 139 38 66 362 LCC (West) Hafizabad 420 154 37 24 16 16 154 Faisalabad 347 247 71 3 1 10 247 Jhang 210 210 100 15 7 0 210 World Environment Day June-2012 27 Total 977 611 63 42 7 26 611 Bahawal-nagar Fordwah 12 12 100 0 0 0 12 Sadiqia 65 37 57 1 3 0 37 Hakra 190 190 100 14 7 0 190 Total 267 239 90 15 6 0 239 Derajat CRBC 40 40 100 0 9 0 40 LJC Sargodha 2 2 100 1 50 0 2 Grand Total 1782 1254 70% 197 16% 92 1254 Comments • Table-7 reveals that the tendency of disposing of identified / detected water theft cases in LCC (East) is higher (73%) than of 63% in LCC (West). Due to initiation of action (cases reporting to police and levying special charges / tawan against the offenders) has resulted into improvement in water supply at tails. • The achievement towards the registration of cases against the culprits is not encouraging which needs to be looked upon. • Incidence of water theft cases reported to Police in Bahawalnagar and CRBC out of which only 6% and 9% got registered. Poor Police response in registration of FIR and arresting the culprits remained slow in all AWBs. This apathy resulted in emboldening other farmers for wrongdoings water theft and consequently hampered the functioning of AWB / FOs. • The intra-Divisional status of water theft cases indicates that the police action for arrestation of culprits remained very poor in all AWBs particularly in Bahawalnagar and CRBC whereeven single arrest was not made. Similaris the situations in Jhang. • The above data further reveals that Bahawalnagar and CRBC is the best performing where 90- 100% detected cases reported to police followed by LCC East 73% then LCC West (63%). The overall achievement is encouraging (70%). 2.4 COMPLAINTS RESOLUTION Fig. IV World Environment Day June-2012 28 • The progress of complaint resolution regarding water distribution / channels operation in LCC West is better (75%) than that of LCC East (55%). • The intra divisional status of complaint resolution in AWBs LCC (E) & (W) reveals that the performance of Upper Gugera in East, Hafizabad in LCC (West) and Sad qia Division in Bahawalnagar is lower than the average performance of the respective AWB. • The best performer is LJC and BWN having 94% and 80% progress respectively. • The worst position is in CRBC, where overall complaints resolution remained only 32%. 3. ACHIEVEMENTS 1. Declining status of Abiana Collection has not only been controlled but now there is increasing trend in Abiana recovery in almost all the AWBs 53 to 77% in LCC (E), 64 to 73% in LCC(W) and 4 to 14% in CRBC. 2. Due to this paradigm shift form decrease to increase, additional resource generation of almost Rs. 200 Million has been made available which will be utilized for the up -keep and maintenance of irrigation infrastructure, leading to sustained equitable water distribution and improved tails. 3. Due to better Administrative control and enhanced public awareness / motivation there is substantial improvement in equitable water distribution and channels operation improved from69% to 79%. 4. Substantial embezzled / pended amount got recovered from out going FO Presidents / Chairmen. 5. Two Financial Firms hired during 2008 but no audit could be conducted. The Audit of LCC East, LCC West and LJC Circle has now been managed and got conducted which was pended for the last 3 years. 6. All the stakeholders have been brought on board. Meetings also held with the public representatives and civil Authorities seeking their assistance to improve the Abiana as well as water distribution. 4. CONSTRAINTS 1. Lack of legal provision and back up support to proceed against th e defaulters/ delinquents. Resultantly the field officers are currently handicapped to catch hold of culprits. 2. Interruption in FO tenures and prolonged Administrative period which leads to inconsistency and dis-continuity in the reforms process. World Environment Day June-2012 29 3. Neither there is effective internal audit system in vogue at FO Level nor post-audithas been conducted for years long. This lack of financial management has led to irregularities and poor financial control. 4. Dis-continuity in policies which has negatively contributed towards the confidence building of FOs as well as at AWB level. Clear and well defined sustainable policies need to be formulated and strictly adhered to. 5. Lack of coordination and delayed action by Police Department particularly at the FO level. The cases referred to are not mostly registered and no arrest is made. This lack of coordination has encouraged the in- equitable distribution and theft of water. 6. 6% Incentive only for Lambardar (Abiana Collector) and there is no incentive for FO Management Committee as well as Khal Panchayat Members. 5. WAY FORWARD 1. Appropriate provision in the rules for proceeding against the defaulters involved in inequitable water distribution and theft of water. 2. Continuity in the reform process, the Administrators tenure may be maintained to the minimum extent and election of FOs should be completed as per laid down procedure when the tenure of on- going FOs is completed. 3. Transparency in the fiscal and financial management. Capacity building of FOs at AWB and FO level. 4. Conduction of internal audit of FOs at AWB level as well as the yearly external audit through the External Auditors. 5. Strict vigilance/surveillance is required in abiana collection and its disbursement. 6. Good coordination and cordial relat ionship between the PIDA and PID formation. The irrigation officers have been associated under the rules in the functioning of FO. Their professional competence and year’s long experience needs to be availed of. 7. Effective role of Police Department is i nevitable to proceed against those involved either in the water theft or defaulting in abiana recovery. World Environment Day June-2012 30 8. Filling of vacant posts particularly at AWB level and uniform criteria for the recruitment of staff at various level.

Filename: 6-Participatory-Irrigation-Ch.-Karamat-Ali.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 266 KB
Categories: World Environment Day 2012
Author: Ch. Karamat Ali and M. Rizwan Aslam
Downloads: 1