World Water Day – 2017 67 Paper No. 133 THE INDUS DRAINAGE (ISSUES AND OPPORTUNITIES) Engr. Usman-e-Ghani 68 World Water Day – 2017 World Water Day – 2017 69 THE INDUS DRAINAGE (ISSUES AND OPPORTUNITIES) By: Engr. Usman-e-Ghani1 ABSTRACT Drainage is an integral part of water resource management. If not well catered the drainage inadequacies results in number of issues starting from water logging and salinity and going up to a number of forms of economic losses. Hence, all irrigation schemes are considered incomplete if the drainage components do not form a part of such schemes. In Pakistan, particularly in the area comprising of Indus Basin, the drainage issue started becoming prominent with various developments of irrigation schemes beginning the late nineteenth and twentieth century. It was a period whe n remarkable and massive improvement in the development of irrigation took place through the construction of dams, barrages, canals and number of link channels. Yet another impact was subsequent to the Indus Basin Development Plan which was embarked upon s igning of Indus Waters Treaty between Pakistan and India in the year 1960. Though several measures to address the issue were not too late to be initiated but still the need for the more of an adequacy has largely been felt. The paper under reference takes an overview of the issue so as to bring into the limelight the current needs, as well as some of the associated opportunities, which could exploited while keeping in view the local requirements or the best international standards and the practices. KEYWORDS Drainage, Water Logging, Salinity, Indus, Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas, Sutlej, Indus Waters Treaty 1960, Agricultural Economics, Groundwater Depletion. INTRODUCTION The Indus River System mainly comprises of River Indus and its tributaries viz. Jhelum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas and Sutlej. Proportionately these tributaries rather constitute for about 97% of the total surface flow of the system. With the extensive developments of irrigation system in the sub -continent in the late 19th and early 20 th century the i ssue of drainage gradually started to crop up. Though not much late but on occasions it was considered that the measures to cater for the issue were not well in time. The projects were instead initiated when the impacts were already too pronounced and the various aspects of opportunities rather transformed into an issue of drainage. Though most of the measures and programmes, which were started to address the matter, were considered as focused and productive but they gradually started losing their momentum and as a result the objectives were diluted. The sustainability of these 70 World Water Day – 2017 programmes was lost as well. The results were thus obvious and lower tranches of the basin in particular could now be seen as the most impacted. Irrational resource management, particularly when the need based distribution was curtailed, has made the problem even worse. As of today it is thus required that an overview of the issue may be developed so as to see where the issues and the opportunities now exist. Rephrasing of earlier programmes may work to some good advantage in this respect. The changing climatic scenarios would also be required to be looked into while rephrasing the earlier programmes or else while the instituting the new projects. THE CONCEPT The flow of water through w ell-defined channels is known as ‘drainage’ and the network of such channels is called a ‘drainage system’. The streams/rivers are often viewed as a part of drainage basins. A drainage basin in turn is the topographic region from which a stream receives runoff through surface flow and groundwater. Drainage basins are divided from each other by topographic barriers called a watershed (Figure-1). The number, size, and shape of the drainage basins vary with the scale of examination as they are arbitrarily defined ba sed on the topographic information available on a map. Figure-1: The drainage basins determined from topographic maps. The drainage systems could be divided on various bases. For Indian Subcontinent this could be on the basis of discharge of water orientation to the sea, i.e.: (i) The Arabian Sea drainage (ii) The Bay of Bengal drainage. These systems are separated from each other through the Delhi ridge, the Aravalis and the Sahyadris. Nearly 77 per cent of the drainage area consisting of the Ganga , the World Water Day – 2017 71 Brahmaputra, the Mahanadi, the Krishna, etc. is oriented towards the Bay of Bengal, while 23 per cent comprising the Indus, the Narmada, the Tapi, the Mahi and the Periyar systems discharge their waters in the Arabian Sea. The other classification co uld be on the basis of the size of the watershed. On such a classification, the drainage basins of Indian Subcontinent are grouped as follows: (i) River basins with more than 20,000 sq. km of catchment area. These include 14 drainage basins such as the In dus, the Ganga, the Brahmaputra, the Krishna, etc. (ii) Medium river basins with catchment area between 2,000 -20,000 sq. km., such as the Kalindi, the Meghna, etc. (iii) Minor river basins with catchment area of less than 2,000 sq. km include fairly good number of rivers flowing in the area of low rainfall. On the basis of the mode of origin, nature and characteristics, these drainages may also be classified into the Himalayan and the Peninsular drainages. Although it has the problem of including the Ch ambal, the Betwa, etc., which are much older in age and origin than other rivers that have their origin in the Himalayas, it is the most accepted basis of classification which is further being discussed hereunder: The Himalayan Drainage: The Himalayan drainage system has evolved through a long geological history. It mainly includes the Ganga, the Indus and the Brahmaputra river basins. Since these are fed both by melting of snow and precipitation, rivers of this system are perennial. While entering the plains, these basins form depositional features like flat valleys, flood plains and deltas near the river mouth. They also display a strong meandering tendency and shift their courses frequently. The Peninsular Drainage: The Peninsular drainage system is old er than that of Himalayan system. This is evident from the broad, largely -graded shallow valleys, and the maturity of the rivers. The Western Ghats running close to the western coast act as the water divide between the major Peninsular Rivers, discharging their water in the Bay of Bengal and as small rivulets joining the Arabian Sea. Most of the major Peninsular Rivers except Narmada and Tapi flow from west to east. The Chambal, the Sind, the Betwa, the Ken, the Son, originating in the northern part of the Peninsula belong to the Ganga river system. The other major river systems of the peninsular drainage are – the Mahanadi the Godavari, the Krishna and the Kaveri. Peninsular rivers are characterized by fixed course, absence of meanders and non – perennial flow of water. The Narmada and the Tapi which flow through the rift valley are, however, exceptions. Drainable Surplus: The Drainable Surplus is defined as the quantity of water (Cusec or mm/day) that must be removed from an area within a certain time perio d to avoid an unacceptable rise of 72 World Water Day – 2017 the groundwater level. Drainage coefficient is sometimes used as a synonym for drainable surplus. THE INDUS BASIN The Indus System of Rivers in the Indus Basin comprises the Indus and its five main rivers i.e. the Jhelum, the Chenab, the Ravi, the Beas and the Sutlej. They all combine into one river near Mithan Kot in Pakistan, which outfalls into Arabian Sea south of Karachi. The boundary of the Indus Basin is clearly defined on the West, the north and north-east, by mountain ridges (watersheds). However, the boundary on the south is not so clearly defined due to absence of hills and active rivers. The total area of the Indus Basin is roughly 350,000 square miles. Most of it lies in Pakistan and the rest is in occupied Jammu and Kashmir, India, China and Afghanistan. The climate in the Plains downstream of the rim stations ranges from semi arid to arid in the south. Annual rainfall ranges from about 30 inches to about 2 inches in the south. The total annual average discharge of these rivers at the rim stations is about 170 MAF (Million Acre Feet). Figure – 2: The Indus River System, Pakistan THE GEOGRAPHY AND FLOWS A short look on the geography and flows of Indus, Jehlum, Chenab, Ravi, Beas and Sutlej is as below: Indus: The Indus River is a major river which flows through Pakistan. Originating in the Tibetan plateau in the vicinity of Lake Mansarovar, the river runs through Ladakh district of Occupied Jammu and Kashmir and then enters Northe rn Areas (Gilgit -Baltistan) and after traversing through the country merges into the Arabian Sea near port city of Karachi. The total length of the river is 3,180 kilometers (1,976 miles) and it is Pakistan’s longest river. World Water Day – 2017 73 The river has a total drainage area exceeding 1,165,000 square kilometers (450,000 square miles). The river’s estimated annual flow stands at around 207 cubic kilometers, making it the twenty -first largest river in the world in terms of annual flow. The Indus is one of the few rivers in the world that exhibit a tidal bore. The flow of the river is also determined by the seasons – it diminishes greatly in the winter, while flooding its banks in the monsoon months from July to September. Jhelum: It is the largest and most western of the fi ve rivers of Punjab. It is a tributary of the Chenab River and has a total length of about 505 miles (813 kilometers). The river Jhelum rises from a spring at Verinag situated at the foot of the Pir Panjal in the south-eastern part of the valley of Kashmir . It flows through Srinagar and the Wular Lake before entering Pakistan from India -Occupied Kashmir through a deep narrow gorge. The Neelum River, the largest tributary of the Jhelum, joins it near Muzaffarabad, as does the next largest, the Kunhar River o f the Kaghan valley. It is then joined by the Poonch River, and flows into the Mangla reservoir in the Mirpur District. The Jhelum enters the Punjab in the Jhelum District. From there, it flows through the plains of Punjab, forming the boundary between the Chaj and Sindh Sagar Doabs. It ends in a confluence with the Chenab at Trimmu in District Jhang. The Chenab merges with the Sutlej to form the Panjnad River which joins the Indus River at Mithankot. Chenab: The Chenab River is formed by the confluence of the Chandra and Bhaga Rivers at Tandi located in the upper Himalayas in the Lahul and Spiti District of Himachal Pradesh, India. It flows through the Jammu region of Occupied Jammu and Kashmir into the plains of the Punjab, forming the boundary between t he Rechna and Chaj Doabs. It is joined by the Jhelum River at Trimmu and then by the Ravi River at Ahmedpur Sial. It then merges with the Sutlej River near Uch Sharif to form the Panjnad or the ‘Five Rivers’, the fifth being the Beas River which joins the Satluj near Ferozepur, India. The Chenab then joins the Indus at Mithankot in Pakistan. The total length of the Chenab is approximately 960 kilometers. Sutlej: The longest of the five tributaries of Indus, the Sutlej originates near Mount Kailash along with the Indus and runs a course of 964 miles (1550 km) through the Panjal and Siwalik mountain ranges and enters Pakistan through the plains of Indian Punjab. The huge 740 feet (225 m) high Bhakra Dam, which Nehru called “the new temple of resurgent India,” is also situated on this river. Ravi: This 475 mile (764 km) long river rises in 74 World Water Day – 2017 Himachal Pradesh and runs a course of 102 miles (164 km) before joining Chenab in Pakistan after flowing past Lahore. The Thien Dam (Ranjit Sagar Dam) is located on this river at the tri-section of East Punjab, Himachal Pradesh and J&K States and feeds the Upper Bari Doab Canal (UBDC) which irrigates North Western Punjab. Beas: This 290 mile (467 km) long river originates near Rohtang Pass in Himachal Pradesh and flows through Kulu Valley and the Siwalik Range. The Pandoh Dam is situated on this and diverts water to Sutlej through the Beas-Sutlej Link. Table 1: Distribution of Water in Main Rivers of Pakistan % of IRS Inflows % Seasonal Distribution Dominant Source in Summer Dominant Source in Winter Summer (Apr- Sep) Winter (Oct-Mar) Indus 44 86 14 Snow/Glacial melt Winter Rainfall + Baseflow Chenab 19 83 17 Snow/Glacial melt + Monsoon Winter Rainfall + Baseflow Jhelum 16 78 22 Mainly Snow melt + Monsoon Winter Rainfall + Baseflow Kabul 16 82 18 Snow/Glacial melt Winter Rainfall + Baseflow Others 5 THE INDUS WATERS TREATY 1960 In August 1947 when South Asia was divided into two independent countries there existed one of the most highly developed Irrigation System in the world and approximately 37 Million Acres received irrigation from the flow waters of the Indus System of Rivers. All of the available water supplies were allocated to the various states and provinces in conformity with the principle of equitable app ortionment of the waters with preferential right to existing uses. At the time of Independence major portion of the Indus Basin formed a part of Pakistan and out of 37 Million Acres of area which used to receive the irrigation supplies, 31 Million Acres were in Pakistan. The boundary line between the two countries was drawn without any regard to the irrigation works. It was, however, affirmed by the Boundary Commission and expressly agreed by the representatives of the affected zones before World Water Day – 2017 75 the Arbitral Tri bunal that the authorized shares of the two zones in the common water supply would continue to be respected. Instead of honoring the commitment made before the Arbitral Tribunal, India on the hand stopped the flows entering into Pakistan on 01 April 1948, i.e. as soon as the Arbitral Tribunal Ceased to exist. The dispute on water apportionment was thus obvious to arise. In view of increased tension and growing chance of hostilities the good offices of the World Bank offered their help in resolving the issue. The offer by the Bank was accepted by both the governments, i.e. Pakistan and India. The Bank Engineers worked out their initial proposals on averages ignoring the special needs of the seasons for the sowing and maturing of the crops when the demands of water are maximum and the flow are minimum. It took Pakistan two years to convince the Bank that Pakistan’s contentions were correct that the division of the waters put forward by the Bank would not accomplish the results visualized in its proposal. When the World Bank was finally convinced that the existing uses in Pakistan could not be met by transfer of waters from the Western Rivers and that Storages on the Western Rivers were required for the purpose, the Indus Waters Treaty was eventually signed in 1960. The Indus Waters Treaty is based on the division of the Rivers between the two countries. The waters of the Sutlej, Beas and Ravi rivers named in the Treaty “Eastern Rivers” are for the unrestricted use of India and the waters of the rivers i.e. Indus , Jhelum and Chenab, named in the Treaty as “Western Rivers” are for the exclusive use of Pakistan except for certain specified uses allowed to India in their upper catchments. Such a division of Rivers was a distinct departure from the concept of international law of upper and lower riparian rights (protection of existing uses from the same source). In this way Pakistan had to forgo the entire perpetual flow of fresh waters of the three Eastern Rivers (24.00 MAF) which it used to historically receive for irrigation. Under the Treaty, Pakistan was required to construct and bring into operation a system of works, which would accomplish the replacement, from the Western Rivers, of water supplies for irrigation canals in Pakistan, which on 15 th August 1947 were dependent on water supplies from the Eastern Rivers. These replacement works, comprising two storages dams (One on Indus River and one on Jhelum River), six new barrages (diversion dams), remodeling of two existing barrages, seven new inter-rivers link canals and remodeling of two existing link canals, have since been completed. The storage dams which were constructed are Mangla and Tarbela, whereas the canal and barrage projects are listed hereunder: Table-2: Link Canals Link Canals Capacity (Cusecs) Length (Miles) Trimmu-Sidhnai 11,000 44 Sidhnai-Mailsi 10,100 62 Mailsi-Bahawal 3,900 10 76 World Water Day – 2017 Link Canals Capacity (Cusecs) Length (Miles) Rasul-Qadirabad 19,000 30 Qadirabad-Balloki 18,600 80 L.C.C. Feeder 4,100 20 Balloki-Sulemanki 6,500 39 Chashma-Jhelum 21,700 63 Taunsa-Panjnad 12,000 38 Table-3: Barrages Barrage River Length Design Flood Sidhnai Ravi 712 167,000 Mailsi Sutlej 1601 429,000 Rasul Chenab 3373 900,000 Qadirabad Jhelum 3209 850,000 Chasma Indus 3556 950,000 Marala Chenab 4472 1,100,000 THE DRAINAGE ISSUE The rise of the grou ndwater table to or near the surface is a serious problem. It carries social and economic impacts on communities, health problems for humans and livestock, the issues like crumbling of mud houses, the difficulties in transportation as just few to mention. Some 25 percent reduction in the production of major crops is also attributed to soil salinity. For the province of Sind for example, it was estimated that the impact is even higher and ranges from 40-60 percent in SGW areas. High groundwater table inhibits root growth and therefore reduces crops yield. No project in a drainage basin or sub -basin may effectively be able to perform unless there are means to safely evacuate and manage the drainable surplus. Various studies and experiments have shown that in the affected areas the soil infiltration rates increase with the passage of time even up to the extent of 80% and 40% respectively under canal and tubewell irrigation. Pakistan has been implementing Salinity Control and Reclamation Projects (SCARPs) projects since 1960s. In the next fifty years WAPDA completed more than 60 SCARPs World Water Day – 2017 77 projects at various locations through which some 45% of the total irrigated area (i.e. about 42 Ma) was reported to be covered. As the drainage network was not interconnected, much of the drainage effluent is either reused in the Indus Basin Irrigation System (IBIS) or gets disposed into the rivers and canals. A summary of drainage works or the synopsis of 50 years progress by WAPDA on SCARPs is given in the table hereunder: Table-4: Fifty Years Progress by WAPDA on SCARPs (1960 onwards) Province Area with Drainage Surface Drains (km) Subsurface Drainage Tubewells (Numbers) Interceptor Drains (km) Tile Drainage GA (Ma) CCA (Ma) FGW * SGW ** ScW *** Length (km) Area (Ma) GA CCA Punjab 10.850 9.601 3883 8065 2256 – 6 2810 0.235 0.203 Sind 6.732 5.710 9185 4190 1587 361 154 2046 0.045 0.036 NWFP 0.884 0.725 971 491 – – – 7756 0.658 0.527 Baluchistan 0.177 0.161 322 – – – – – – – Total 18.643 16.197 14361 12746 3843 361 160 12612 0.938 0.766 * GW – Ground Water, **SGW – Saline Groundwater, ***SCW – Scavenger Wells GA – Gross Area, CCA – Culturalable Commanded Area Source: WAPDA, DMP 2005. Based upon the various projects undertaken in the country from time to time , following findings would be important to note: The earlier SCARPs, with emphasis on vertical drainage, though provided an immediate relief, but got a rundown due to huge O&M costs. Though tile drainage is expensive, but on the other hand, involves lesser O&M costs. Where farmers undertake an installation of tubewells in fresh and marginal groundwater areas, there is no need to invest public money. Quality of groundwater and salinity of soils is adversely affected by regional irrigation developments. Irrigation water containing salts is lost through seepage, evaporation and transpiration but the salts are left behind in both groundwater and soil reaching at times to intolerable limits. The overall salt balance in the basin is negative, i.e. more salts are being added to the soil and groundwater than are being taken out. As this poses a serious threat to the sustainability of agriculture, sufficient knowledge about the movement of salts should exist for further confirmation to this effect. 78 World Water Day – 2017 Pollution of both the surface and groundwater is becoming a serious sustainability issue. The main sources of water pollution, in order of their magnitude, are the municipal effluent, industrial waste, fertilizer and pesticides, solid wastes, disposal of salin e agricultural effluent and the sea water intrusion. Treatment/remedial measures to this effect are either absent or else inadequate. Preventive approach in drainage has not been pursued as vigorously as required. Improved irrigation practices and linin g of irrigation channel especially in saline area would have substantially reduced the drainable surplus. Effluent Quality It has been reported that WAPDA used to collect the surface drain data from 1969 through 1991 on a regular basis. Since then, however , there has been no monitoring of drainage water quality due to various reasons. Some earlier studies on the other hand, such as the ground water development study carried out by WAPDA in 1988 on command area basis, reports the existence of brackish ground water areas within the central parts of various doabs. In Sind most of the good quality water was reported to be closer to the Indus. The salinity level increases with distance from the river. The upper limits for useable and marginally suitable groundwate r are 1500 and 3000 ppm (TDS) respectively, as compared to 1000 and 2000 ppm respectively, used in case of Punjab Private Sector Groundwater Development Project (PPSGDP). Hence, too assess the possible reclamation methods for salt -affected lands, as determined by soil conditions, cropping patterns and other socio -economic factors, the following may required to be considered: 1. Source control to reduce bulk drainage effluent through irrigation scheduling based on crop -climate-soil relationships, high -efficacy irrigation methods, precision land levelling, and using the effluent directly for cropping. 2. Pros and cons of re -allocation of canal irrigation water to minimize pumping of saline groundwater. 3. Development of cheaper technology for extraction of salts and heavy metals from water. 4. Implications of high-efficiency irrigation systems under gravity irrigation for water stressed areas and with saline water use. 5. Water management of spate irrigation systems for harnessing the hill torrents. 6. Development of Water Management Information System under GIS. 7. Computer modelling of water balance components using Remote Sensing and GIS techniques. 8. Development of river salinity model for whole of the Indus River System so as to assess the extent o f saline drainage for disposal to the sea without adversely affecting downstream users. World Water Day – 2017 79 Table-5: Groundwater Recharge of the Indus Basin Location At Head (MAF) Infiltration Recharge of aquifer % MAF % MAF 1. Canals Diversions Canals 104.00 15 15.60 75 11.70 Distributaries/Minors 88.40 8 7.07 75 5.30 Watercourses 81.33 30 24.40 60 14.64 Fields 56.93 30 17.08 90 15.37 Crops 39.85 – – – – Sub Total 64.15 47.01 2. Tubwells Watercourses 45.00 10 4.50 60 2.70 Fields 40.50 30 12.15 90 10.94 Crops 28.35 – – – – Sub-Total 16.55 13.64 3. Rainfall (Average rainfall of 0.66 ft. over area of 41 Ma) Rainfall Recharge 28.00 50 14.00 50 7.00 Total Recharge 24.3 – 12.1 – 67.65 Source: WAPDA, DMP 2005. THE OPPORTUNITY SIDE The Drainage Master Plan (DMP) envisaged by WAPDA in the year 2002 could be taken as a good example to portray an opportunity side of the drainage issue. The DMP fundamentally had an aim to achieve following: the national food security through increased agricultural production; the overall contribution towards protection of environment; to assist in the goals for poverty alleviation; and to target the social uplift of the people, particularly the rural community. In order to achieve these targets, the following were c onsidered important to be accomplished: the control of waterlogging and salinity for sustainable irrigated agriculture; 80 World Water Day – 2017 to encourage and sustain increased agricultural production and improve agricultural productivity; to ensure equitable sharing o f benefits accruing from investment and as far as possible so as to target these benefits for the maximum benefit; to encourage beneficiaries’ participation in project preparation, construction and O&M; the protection of irrigation water quality fro m urban and industrial effluents to reduce their adverse impacts an agriculture and lands; the safe disposal and management of the brackish drainage effluent; the reduction of drainage effluent by integrated water management, prioritizing drainage ne eds, selection of appropriate drainage technologies and use of brackish drainage effluent for saline agro-forestry; the regulation and management of groundwater so that it is neither high enough to cause waterlogging nor low enough to include salt water intrusion; to endevour to remove salt from the root zone; the reduction of liability of O&M expenditure on the government by transferring some of the responsibility to beneficiaries; and to improve knowledge base of implementing and operating age ncies through R&D. Working for sustainability was thus accepted as an essential requirement encompassing the interdependence of individual, social, economic and political activities. Strictly from the irrigation and agricultural point view, a series of sig nificant options and measures, which could be adopted to turn the menace of Indus drainage to an opportunity may include the number of suggestions and proposals, which came up from time to time through the work of various individuals, researchers and organ izations both at the local and international level. Specific to the Indus Basin, however, few of such proposals and suggestions are being enumerated hereunder: 1. Bed and furrow irrigation of wheat, maize and cotton to reduce water use. 2. Integrated bed and furrow irrigation of cotton with tillage and without tillage. 3. Sugar cane intercropping in wheat-planted bed furrow systems. 4. On-farm high efficiency irrigation technology (drip irrigation, etc.). 5. To study changes in salinity and sodicity un der different leaching conditions by changing irrigation applications. 6. To evaluate different sowing -cum-irrigation management techniques for limited use of marginal quality water. 7. To evaluate changes in soil fertility within and beyond the root zon e and assess nutrient losses under different leaching conditions. World Water Day – 2017 81 8. To evaluate the salt tolerance performance of crop cultivars in different salt affected soil conditions. 9. To study soil salinity changes under different techniques. 10. To develop procedures for controlling soil erosion and enhance soil fertility. 11. To reduce the use of inorganic chemical fertilizers through green manure, press mud and farm yard manure without compromising on level of crop productivity. 12. To evaluate the impact of inorganic and organic fertilizers on crop yield and water use efficiency. 13. To develop and evaluate irrigation and agronomic practices on the model farms on spoiled banks of canals/drains. 14. To develop methods for sustainable reuse of drainage eff luent on productive and saline lands. 15. To monitor the existing cropping pattern, cropping intensities, water use and other inputs and crop yield. 16. To study zero tillage technology under rice-wheat cropping system. 17. To study different resource c onservation technologies under various cropping systems like intercropping, planting geometry and planting methods. 18. To evaluate the impacts of alternative agricultural systems such as sustainable agriculture and organic farming. 19. To develop a surf ace water quality model to predict temporal and spatial variations. 20. Adoption of measures to obviate the adverse impacts of effluent disposal into evaporation ponds. 21. Low-cost techniques for lining the watercourses. 22. Study on nutrient losses during reclamation of soil. 23. Fertility enhancement of reclaimed soils. 24. Quantified share of organic manures in crop production on saline sodic soils. 25. Role of zinc, boron and copper in improving crop yield in saline sodic soils. 26. Effect of ch loride, carbonate, bi -carbonate and sulphate ions on crop yields in salt affected soils. 27. Use of resins for improving brackish water. 28. Potential for utilization of drainage effluents for fodder production and its subsequent use in livestock. 29. Scope of crop diversification and related constraints. 30. Optimization for conjunctive use of saline and fresh water for irrigation. 82 World Water Day – 2017 31. Raised bed technology for low permeability soils subject to water logging and salinity. 32. Agricultural development on saline coastal areas for oil seed and other crop production. 33. Development of efficient rainwater harvesting techniques to improve fresh water availability in the desert areas of Punjab and Sind. 34. Establishment of community organization for rainwater harvesting. 35. Crop water requirements and cropping alternatives for desert areas. In addition to above, the following findings by some researchers on the drainage issue, specific to Indus Basin, would be worth reproducing as well: It is interes ting to note that Muhammad (1967) found that sorghum and maize yields decreased almost linearly with an increase in EC and SAR of irrigation water. Haider and Farooqi (1972) reported that potentially hazardous tubewell water with SAR ranging between 10 -14 (mmol L–1)1/2 can be used successfully if gypsum is applied to the soil. They further stated that the application of gypsum increases infiltration rate and reduces SAR and pH of the soil, enabling the farmers to get higher yield. Similarly Tripathi and Paul (1980) suggested that wheat crops could tolerate salinity of waters up to EC 8.4 mmhos/cm on sandy loam soils without any significant loss in the yield. Yadav (1980) suggested that wheat could be grown successfully on sandy loam soil with water having ECiw 8.0 dS m –1. He also reported that the same crop can be grown on black clay soil with water having ECiw 4.0 dS m–1. Rehman and Hussain (1981) reported that water with ECiw of 3 dS m –1 could be used on fine sandy loam soil with decrease in growth and yield of sorghum. Chaudhry et al. (1983) reported that reduction in wheat yield was more in fine (clay loam) than that in coarse textured soils (sandy loam) with the same ECiw 3.2 dS m –1. Such soils can be used safely and successfully for economic crop production under comparable conditions provided the SARiw and RSC are less than 5 (mmol L –1)1/2 and 2 me L –1, respectively, on coarse textured soils. Likewise Ahmed and Rehman (1986) found that paddy yield was affected at salinity level of 8 dS m –1 but was very much affected at ECe 16 dS m –1 where saline water was applied at panicle emergence and maximum at tillering stages. Saline water applied at heading and ripening stages had a slight effect even at ECe 16 dS m–1. Rhoades et al. (1989) concluded that agricultural crops/varieties behave differently with brackish water irrigation in relation to their growth and yield. They also reported that saline drainage waters could be used successfully to grow crops without any detrimental effect on either crops or soi ls. Gilani et al. (1990) revealed that the increments in SAR of irrigation water from 5 to 35 (mmol L–1)1/2 enhanced the ECe and SAR of the soil from 6.8 to 10.9 dS m–1 and 17.0 to 21.9 (mmol L –1)1/2 respectively as there was no provision of leaching in th e experimental plots. The decreasing trend in wheat and maize yields was World Water Day – 2017 83 observed with increasing SAR levels of irrigation water. Crop production, however, was favoured with the application of Farmyard manure (FYM) mainly due to its nutritional value and i mprovement in physical and chemical composition of the soil. Raza and Sadiq (2001) too evaluated the impacts of tubewell water of hazardous quality having TDS 3,500 ppm, SAR 24.2 (mmol L –1)1/2 and RSC 3.1 me L –1 with different treatments on secondary sa linization. The study was conducted on slightly saline sodic, silty clay loam soil with rice -wheat rotation. The pure tubewell water reduced the soil infiltration rate by 22 per cent but the application of pure tubewell water along with FYM and green manure considerably increased the infiltration rate of the soil. Subhani et al. (2006) concluded that if there is no problem of availability and quality of gypsum, preference must be given to the use of gypsum as compared to use of sulphurous acid generator and sulphuric acid for amending brackish water. The use of gypsum stones was recommended due to its continuous effects for longer period, whereas it proved to be the most cost effective in consideration to its slow rate of solubility. These are just few examp les to quote only as some basic reference. Hence, one may deduce that the opportunity side is lacking only in getting proper attention. In case the proper attention is not diverted to this issue then the opportunities would continue to remain unexploited a nd the detrimental effects of improper drainage would further aggravate. THE INNOVATION AND PROSPECTS Once on road to the opportunity side of the drainage issue, the innovation and prospects would keep on developing setting aside the shortcomings or failur es of the past. An outline of various indicators in this respect, which would also be able lightly define the extent of opportunities out of the issue of Indus drainage is being set as hereunder: A) Physical Reduction in waterlogged area Changes in soil salinity (surface and profile) Improvement in groundwater quality B) Agro-Socio Economic Better cropping pattern, cropped area and cropping intensity Decrease in people living below poverty Decline in rural to urban migration C) Environmental Increase in area under vegetation Bio diversity index change 84 World Water Day – 2017 Decrease in water borne and vector diseases and those due to excessive salt consumption D) Climatic The implementation of a development project affects the physical, biological and socio-economic setup of the area. The major impact would be the rehabilitation/reclamation of affected lands and increase in the crop yield, safe disposal of saline and polluted effluents, etc. Prevention of disposal of untreated industrial and mun icipal sewage into the drainage system would be another significant achievement. Protection of wetlands and Environmentally Significant Areas (ESAs). The case of Manchar Lake in Sind could be quoted as recent example. E) Economic The drainage projec ts usually show higher rates of return as the project area is significantly benefited. As a result of various drainage measures, cropping intensities and yield of crops rises and give reasonable returns. Economic parameters like present worth of benefits, benefits to costs ratios (B/C Ratio) and economic internal rate of return (EIRR), etc., support the drainage projects. For instance, the EIRR in case of DMP by WAPDA was worked out to be 15.89%. F) Innovative 1. To disseminate the findings among the end users regarding the study on water and salt balance. 2. To disseminate the research findings to local farmers and concerned agencies regarding the study of performance of various types of drains. 3. To disseminate the results of the studies on rainwater harvesting to the beneficiaries. 4. To disseminate the findings to the project affectees, farmers of canals and drains, regarding the study on improved water management practices and development of model farms on spoiled banks of canals and drains. 5. To arrange demonstrations on watercourses where water users’ associations are more effective. 6. Salinity/sodicity analysis, advisory services to farmers and others. 7 Render advisory services to farmers pertaining to transplantation and other issues on stressed lands. 8. Educate the farmers about land use policy options and their impacts with the database that may include land ownership, tenancy, political World Water Day – 2017 85 influence, economic dominance, cooperation, competition, conflict, decision-making capability when d oing collective tasks, presence of skepticism, suspicion and envy, etc. 9. Centralization of data and establishment of centralized data bank agency for proper planning and development of water resources. G) Prospective 1. Experience with organized activ ities, experience with the norms for informal organizations, e.g. Jirga/Panchayat. 2. Farmers’ motivations to develop rules and sanctions for community action. 3. Identification of economic incentives to pursue farmers to follow high – value farming. 4. To conduct economic benefits of community-operated wells. 5. Best approach to community development. 6. Agro-economic benefit monitoring and evaluation to provide necessary data for planning and implementation of strategic measures to boost up the agricultural economy in the Indus Basin. 7. Cost-benefit analysis of government regulations on agriculture, the food and fibre system, natural resources, and the environment. 8. Economic justification for forestation. 9. Legislation to bring revolutionary chan ge in canal water distribution system at the farm level by revising the rules and regulations controlling the system and implementing the rule of law in accordance with present – day requirement. 10. Legislation to control groundwater mining. 11. Review an d evaluate groundwater rules and regulations existing in different regions of the country to frame an effective groundwater regulatory framework. 12. Design new public policies for managing land use management. 13. Develop mechanisms to assess and mitiga te global environmental resource management including climate change and desertification. 14. Institutional framework to improve sustainability of irrigated agriculture. 15. Infrastructure development, capacity building of institutions involved in conducting research in waterlogging, salinity and allied fields through 86 World Water Day – 2017 higher education, training, acquisition of modern tools, equipment and the skill to operate them. CONCLUSION From the discussion we conclude by saying that though the irrigated agriculture h as established its indispensability to the development of many countries in the arid and semi-arid regions and to the food security throughout the world, it has also brought the associated consequences of waterlogging and salinity due to defective conveyan ce and inefficient irrigation methods. Drainage provision to the irrigated lands helps in mitigating the adversities of these two serious problems. However, disposal of drainage effluent itself has become a major issue, which is a peril for long -term productivity of irrigated agriculture/lands. However, along with the issue, there is n opportunity side as well. For Pakistan the agricultural sector is the lynchpin of the country’s economy. Since independence, it continues to be the single largest sector and a dominant driving force for the growth and the development of the national economy. Hence, there is a dire need that this sector should be given not only the best protection but also the best of all opportunities. Beside the various form of development pr ojects, for example the construction of storage reservoirs, the remodelling of existing water courses, etc., the menace of drainage is equally important to be addressed. Reduction of drainable surplus is too important not only for sustainability of agricul tural but also for environmental, climatic, social and several other facets of national growth. We know well that at present the surface water supplies in the country are insufficient to meet the crop water requirements. Hence, side by side, the safe and s ustainable reuse of the drainage effluent for agriculture is an imbibed opportunity which needs to considered and adopted. Reasonable crop production is possible even with saline irrigation water with, without or after some treatment. Saline groundwater co uld also be used to meet the crop water requirements but this water has different types of salts which ultimately affect the chemical composition of the soil. The exact extent of harmfulness of this phenomenon, along with the various other options which ha ve been discussed and precise solution for the farming community of the country needs to be further investigated so as to assess the long -term effects of drainage water on soil characteristics, to evaluate sustainable use of drainage water for growing of s alt-tolerant crop cultivars and tree species and the reclamation of salt affected lands and socio – economic uplift of the farmers. REFERENCES Aslam, M., Haq, A., and Javed, M. Indus Basin Experience on Disposal of Agricultural Drainage Effluent, ICID, 2008. C.M. Chang. 2005. Engineering Management: Challenges in the New Millennium. Pearson Prentice Hall. Ghani, Usman-e-. 2016. Environment and Eastern Rivers (Views and Options), Pakistan Engineering Congress, Lahore, Pakistan. Lacey, G. 1930. Stable Channels in Alluvium. Minutes of the Proc., Institute of Civil Engineers, London, UK. No 229, pp 259-292. World Water Day – 2017 87 Merritt, S. 2002. Water for Agricultures, Irrigation Economics in International Perspective, Spon Press, London and New York, ISBN 0-415-25238-5. Pakistan WAPDA, Drainage Master Plan (DMP) of Pakistan, 2005. Sidhu, M., Latif, Z., and Iqbal, M. Sustainable Reuse and Disposal of Drainage Effluent, ICID, 2008. 88 World Water Day – 2017
Filename:
5-The-Indus-Drainage-Usman-e-Ghani.pdf
File Type:
pdf
File Size:
686 KB
Categories:
World Water Day 2017
Downloads:
2
