75 TIRE NOISE IMPACT ON HUMAN HEALTH AT KOTRI, JAMSHORO, GUDDU & HALA THE TOWNS ON RIVER INDUS SINDH (PAKISTAN) By Engr. Zaheeruddin Memon1 ABSTRACT As regards noise emission from tire is one of main problems faced by humanity, particularly in urban areas. Noise is undesired and unavoidable consequence of mechanized operations, as the tire noise not only hinders communication, also results in different type of physiological & psychological effects on human health, such as feeling of annoyance, efficiency with which tasks are performed, work interference, accident at work, impairment of hearing, heart diseases, and cancer etc. The survey conducted on busy roads at residential and commercial areas of Kotri, Jamshoro, Guddu and Hala, the towns situated on r iver Indus in Sindh (Pakistan). The results show that the noise levels are alarmingly high i.e . 61-100 dB (A) and above, caused mainly due to auto rickshaws, motorcycles because of having very poor type of tires. Rapid increased traffic flow density resulted people above 90% being annoyed and complaining about health ailments. Like Karachi, and Hyderabad Sindh, the level of noise is much above the acceptable limits with reference to ISO, WHO, EEC, and other national standards. Hence proper control measur es are required; otherwise situation can be worst resulting more severe permanent health damaging effects. It is advisable that the existing road traffic noise rules and standards must be revised and implemented forcefully. Key words: Health & Safety Issues, Tire Noise. INTRODUCTION Tire noise is one of the most wide spread sources of noise nuisance in urban areas. The situation is getting alarming with the increased traffic density on roads of said towns. American traffic engineers under the term Trans portation System Management (TSM) have summarized that the road traffic noise pollution is a major cause of unrest and tension among the dwellers living along the roadsides all over the world, especially in urban areas due to dramatic increase in traffic d ensity on the roads, the noise levels have gone much beyond the comfortable limits. The towns surveyed are facing growing traffic congestion because of in efficiency to cope with dramatic increase in traffic density since last decades. The problem is com pounded by rapid population increase and shortage of resources to improve transport infrastructure. The United Nations (U.N.) estimated that by 2000 A.D. the people living on earth would be more than 6 billion out of which 5 billion will be in developing Countries (Presently 7 billion and should be about 10 billion by 2050) . Now it has become necessary that careful management of transport network is essential to eliminate the worst effects of congestion. _____________________________________________________________________________________________ 1. A. Prof (R) (Q. A. Engg. Universty Nawabshah) P.O. Tharushah-67480 Distt: Naushahro Feroze Sindh (Pakistan) Ph: +92 242 433534, Cell: +92 03013802732, 03337693964 Email: zhr_mem@yahoo.com, memon_zaheer@hotmail.com 76 Due to poor education of the society about civic privileges and lack of knowledge about ill effects of high -level noise, no vigorous community actions have surfaced against high -level noise. Most studies are ca rried out to record the community response to tire noise. In Path Analysis 1 the level of annoyance, sleep disturbance, Interference in daily duties, and health related symptoms 2  are found especially in the nighttime. A lot of work has been done in developed countries to assess the noise effects on human system and limit high level environmental and occupational noise within acceptable limits, but very little work is being done in Pakistan, which need more attention and thereby help in the formulation of noise reduction program by suppressing at source, preventing its transmission in space, and where it is unwanted is to recommend the protective devices and necessary measures laid down under ISO, E.E.C and other National standards, ISO CRITERION FOR COMMUNITY ANNOYANCE International Standards Organization (ISO) 3 has suggested out door criterion for community annoyance (in urban areas of cities with business, trade and administration), i.e.55 -65, 45-60 and 40-55 dB (A) for day, evening and night time. PERMI TTED/ PRO PO SED EURO PE AN ECO NOMI C COMM UNI TY ( EEC) MO TORCYCLE NOI SE LIMI TS 4 CATEGORIES MAX. PERMISSIBLE NOISE LEVELS dB (A) (w.e.f.) OCT. 01.1986 OCT. 01.1995 Equal or less than 77 75 80 cc Greater than 80 cc 80 78 and Equal or less than 175 cc Greater than 175 cc 82 80 EURO PEAN COMM UNI TY DIRECTI VESCO NCERNI NG PERMI SSIBLE NOI SE LIMI TS AT A DI STANCE OF 7.5m FO R NEW VEHI CLES 5 VEHICLE CATEGORIES NOISE LEVELS dB (A) Vehicles for passengers, equipped with 77 not more than nine seats Vehicles for passengers, equipped with not 80 more than nine seats, having max. Permissible mass more than 3.5 tons , with engine power less than 150 kW. With engine power of not less 150 KW. 83 Vehicles for Passengers, equipped with 78 more than nine seats, also intended for goods; with max. Permissible mass not exceeding 2 tones With max. permissible mass 2.0-3.5 tons 79 Vehicles for Goods, having max. Permissible 81 mass more than 3.5 tons. with engine power less 77 With an engine power 75-150 kW. 83 With an engine power of not 84 less than 150 kW. An increase of 1-2 dB (A) have been allowed for vehicles diesel engine HEALTH EFFECTS Noise is one of the deadliest pollutants in the urban areas of Pakistan. Depending upon the level, quality and exposure duration of noise, it may result in adverse effects on the human health. These effects can come about by the short -term exposure to intense sound or continuous exposure to less intense noise levels. In mild cases of either type, such exposures may result in reduction in output of work, l ack of efficiency, impairment of hearing or just a vague feeling of annoyance, etc. Studies on human working in noisy environments have suggested an increased incidence of heart disease problems, accidents at work, irritation, speech interference, Sleep di sturbance, work interference, cancer, headache, tension, digestive, respiratory, and nervous problems and so many physiological and psychol ogical effects on human system. The effects of sound on human system may be categorized as. (i) Auditory Effects. (ii) Non-Auditory Effects. METHODOLOGY i, Noise Intensity The prevailing tire noise survey conducted and data collected at four different towns has been analyzed for average background (L 90), average (L 50) and average peak (L 10) values and discussed w ith reference to recognized International criteria for community annoyance and existing legislation in Pakistan. Measuring instrument Sound Level Meter TES 1351 regularly calibrated and checked prior and after each measurement, keeping microphone 1.5 met ers above ground level at 1 -3 meters from source, data recorded in dB (A), at “Fast” response in Lmax. at every site. Noise level measurements made at intervals of every ten minutes. In each measuring mode, ten readings taken in a period of about two minutes shown in fig. 1, & given in tab. 1 ii, Vehicle Flow density Number of vehicles counted with respect to type of vehicle after every 10 minutes and a verage (hourly) flow of vehicles, percentage and general vehicle condition data, shown in figs. 2, 3 & given in tab. 2 Noise Questionnaire Public opinion obtained from various cross sections of people like, shopkeepers, cabin holders, general pedestrians and road dwellers given in tabs.3, 4, & 5 RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS From survey of towns n oise found 61 to 100 dB (A) which is far higher than the maximum limit of 85 dB (A) as allowed by ISO and other National Standards. The worst hit place from noise point of view is Jamshoro where the peak noise level is alarmingly high ranging up to 100 dB (A), because o f using sudden brakes at congested narrow road turning, railway crossings and unlawfull bus Stop also tires of mostly inferior quality create noise & pollute environment. 78 These results also show that average background noise levels (L 90) at these sites e xceeds 79 dB (A ), which is above the maximum permissible noise level criteria i.e . 60 dB (A) recommended for community annoyance by E EC, ISO and other national standards. The average (L 50) and average peak (L 10) and leq (T) values exceed 85, 93 dB (A) a nd 89 dB (A) respectively, showing tire noise levels alarmingly high and may lead to adverse effects to roadside traders and dwellers in the towns. Despite of less number the auto rickshaws with six passenger seats produce alarming noise, followed by rickshaws with two passenger seats and buses. This study shows that two stroke automobiles with inferior tires are the major contributors to noise pollution. Vehicle density found 16,730 per hour, the major contribution was from rickshaws and motorcycles which was above 65%, About 86% people at Guddu, while about 85 -92% living at Kotri & Hala and at Jamshoro 90 – 100% were annoyed, complaining about health ailments like headache, deafness, Irritation and respiratory trouble etc. Tab.1 Noise Level at various sites S.No. Spot Time hrs. L90 L50 L10 Recorded Lowest Peak LAeq Value Value dB(A) dB(A) dB(A) 1. Kotri 8:30-17:00 71.5 79.0 84.9 65.0 96.0 82.0 2. Guddu -do- 70.8 75.6 84.2 67.0 93.0 78.95 3. Jamshoro -do- 79.6 85.6 93.6 74.0 100.0 89.1 4. Hala -do- 70.2 79.2 88.0 61.0 97.0 84.85 Lowest values 61.0 – 74.0 dB(A) Peak 93.0 – 100 dB(A) L90 70.2 – 79.6 dB(A) L50 75.6 – 85.6 dB(A) L10 84.2 – 93.6 dB(A) Tab.2 GENERAL VEHICLE CONDITION (%) T Y P E BAD NOISE EMITTING USE OF CONDITION EMITTING POLLUTE POOR TYRES GASES CAUSING NOISE. Rickshaw 97 99 95 93 Four / Six Seater 97 99 97 90 Motor Cycle 70 75 65 85 Car 64 30 44 40 Van 55 45 45 60 Bus 55 80 70 98 Truck 80 85 75 90 Pickups 65 60 64 60 Tab.3 QUESTIONNAIRE ABOUT PUBLIC HEALTH AILMENTS 79 Survey Site Name/Profession. Working since. Disease If any. Kotri Abid Opticals 20 Yrs. Respiratory Ahmed Medical Store 25 Yrs. Allergy Mr. Qurban 16 Yrs. Deafness Jamal Juice cabain 45 Yrs. irritration Gul Muneer Chatt Cart 15 Yrs. Headache Hameed Cane Juicer 23 Yrs. eye sore Raees Pan Cabin 35 Yrs. Headache,Cough. Jamshoro Maula Bux Hotel. 15 Yrs. Irritration Jan Zaman Fruit Cart 30 Yrs. Insomnia, Ajmal Watch Maker 42 Yrs. Blood pressure Shaber Tyre repapir 10 Yrs. Headache Pasha Pan Cabin 50 Yrs. Eye redness, Riaz Hussain 25 Yrs. Deafness, Guddu Sharef Book House 24 Yrs. Normal Khalique watch maker 13 Yrs. Respiratory Sher Zaman Fruit 16 Years Headache, Deafness Karim Pan Cabin 25 Years Mental trouble,Headache, Hala Yousif Cassette Player 12 Yrs. Irritation, Respiratory Fast food Cabin 25 Yrs. Normal Shahid cloth store 12 Yrs. Headache Bhitai Electric store 26 Yrs. Tension, irritation Hala Hadi crafts 41 Yrs. Deafness, Irritation Shabnam Cold Drink 32 Yrs. Eye redness, Tab. 4 QUESTIONNAIRE ABOUT FLOW ANNOYANCE SURVEY SITE SPOTS SATISFA- CTORY UN-SATIS- FACTORY BOTHE- RING BOTHERING % Kotri Tea Stall Fruit Juicer Medical Store Pan Cabin Students Vehicle owner Drivers         96 Jamshoro Optional Center Watch Maker Rice Thella Stationary Mart Hotel Students Vehicle holder        100 Guddu Pan Cabin student Shoe Maker Medical Store Sugar Cane Juicer Hotel Police Man Lady          93 80 Hala Recording Center Washing M/C Shop H.M.C Office Police Station Pan Cabin Police Man Passer by Student         97 Tab. 5 WORST HIT PLACES SURVEY SPOTS REMARKS SITE LOWEST PEAK LAeq dB(A) dB(A) dB(A) G ud d u Main Chok 67.0 93.0 78.95 Alarming. Kotri Phatak 65.0 96.0 82.2 Alarming. Jamshoro Round about 74.0 100.0 89.1 Alarming. Hala Main Road 61.0 97.0 84.85 Alarming. FINDINGS a. The noise from 61 to 100 dB(A) is alarmingly high as against E.E.C limits, ISO criteria and other National Standards, and may lead to adverse effects to roadside traders and dwellers in the towns. b. Traffic density found higher as against roads capacity. c. Public mostly found annoyed, and complaining about health ailments, the major complains were headache and deafness, irritation, speech interference and tension etc. CONTROL MEASURES i. Use of proper muffling devices in automobiles should be made compulsory. ii. Awareness be created among the public about civic privileges and ill effects of high level noise through electronic media, press, posters and public rallies. iii. Narrow and uneven roa ds be widened and aligned properly, with sound absorbing treatment. iv. Encroachments should be removed and unlawfull stops of vehicles should be banned. v. In order to know more specifically the damaging effects of noise, complete medical check up of commercial vehicle drivers should be carried out. vi. Law enforcement agencies should be provided with sound level meters for spot – checking, and strengthened with trained manpower. xii. As suggested by the traffic police that buses, trucks, tractor trolley s, horse/donkey carts and four / six seaters (creating mainly noise and smoke) should be banned in city area. Main reasons of high -level noise are absence of regulatory laws, therefore , recommended that standards for maximum permissible noise in different sectors should be framed out and implemented properly through legislation closer to EEC & other developed countries. Recommendations 81 The control of noise pollution might require alteration or modification of any of these following basic elements. (i) Modifying the source to reduce its noise output. (ii) Altering or controlling the transmission path and the environment to r educe noise level reaching the listener. (iii) The main source of noise is auto rickshaws with tires in bad condition. The b est way would be to replace these rickshaws with new means of transport. (iv) Placing barriers, screens or deflectors in the noise path. REFERENCES [1] ISO Recommendation R -1996, Assessment of Noise with respect to Community Response International standard Organization Geneva, Switzerland (1971). [2] Department of Employment “Code of Practice for Reducing the Exposure of Employed persons to Noise” Her Majesty’s Stationary Office, London (1972). [3] Belgium, Arrete Royal etendant la Survillance medicate des travilleurs confieeauxservices medicaux du travail st modifant les tires ll et V du reglement general pourla protection du travail. 10 April, 1972. Arrete Royal relatif a la lutte contre les nuisances, 23 May 1974. [4] Denmark, the working Environment Act Law No.681 1975. [5] Journal official de la Republic Francaise, 1969, Decret no.69-348, 12 April, 1971. [6] Republic of Ireland, Statutory Instrument no.235, Factories Act no.10, 1975. [7] J. R. Hassall and K. Zaveri, Acoustic Noise Measurements 5th ed.pp.207, Chp.3.6 (Bruel & Kjaer, Denmark, June 1988). [8] U.S Department Of Labor “ Occupational Safety and Health Standards”, vol.39, No.125,Part II (1974). [9] Occupational Safety and Health Standard of Japan, Federal Regis ter Vol.48 no.46, 9738-8508 1983. [10] Federal Republic of Germany, unfallverhutungs vorschrift larmder berufsgenossenschaften 1st December, 1975, verordnung uber Arveitstatten,20 March, 1974. [11] J. C. Webster, “Effect of Noise on Speech Intelligi bility”, proc. Conference “Noise as a Public Hazard”. Washington D. C, June, 13 -14 1968. ASHA Report 4, the American Speech and Hearing Association, Washington D.C. 49-73 1969. [12] World Health Organization, W. H. O, Recommendation of Noise Exposure l imits, Summary, Envtl. Health Criteria No.12, Geneva, Switzerland (1980). 82 [13] Memon Z, “Road Traffic Noise resulting Environmental Problems in Hyderabad City (Pakistan)” paper presented at 1st; National Symposium on Condition Monitoring & Diagnostics, 21-23 April 2001 Organized by Dr. A. Q. Khan Res. Labs. Islamabad, [14] Memon Z, “Vibrational Noise & its impact on Human Health, a Case Study of Chinese unit no.4 Thermal Power Station (T.P.S .) Jamshoro Sindh” presented in 1st: International Vibration Monitoring & Diagnostics Symposium, 16th; Feb. 2002 Organized by N. E. D University Karachi, [15] Memon Z, Industrial Noise & Its Control, Monitoring and Diagnostics In Pakistan, A Case Study of Turbo Blower Station (TBS) Pak Steel Bi n Qasim Karachi presented in 9th HVACR Conference & Exhibition April 11-13, 2002 Lahore. [16] Memon Z, “Comparison of Vibrational Noise, between T. P. S. Jamshoro & T. P. P. Pak Steel”, presented in 3rd. Int l Symp osium (ISMV -02) Organized Dr. A. Q. Kha n Res. Labs. 23-27 Sept. 2002, Islamabad, [17] Memon Z, “Condition monitoring Occupational noise impact, on human health at Zeal Pak cement factory Hyderabad Sindh” Engineering News, A quarterly Journal of the Pakistan Engineering congress Vol: 44 April-Sept 2013 No: 8-9

Filename: 75-82-TIRE-NOISE-IMPACT-ON-HUMAN-HEALTH-AT-KOTRI-JAMSHORO-GUDDU-HALA-Zaheeruddin-Memon.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 173 KB
Categories: Volume 0046 No 01-02
Downloads: 2