World Environment Day June, 2007 50 50 Fig. 1 A view of Blue Lake with Birch-Spru ce forest. The near denuded site is closer to the settlement. Photo. A.U.Khan, July 2001. Graziers bring their families and stay their for most of the summer, ranging from six to eight months. The extraction is mostly confined to the side closer to the settlements. The forest has wide tracks and is crisscrosse d with pathways. They have good ground cover of litter, but very little regeneration was obser ved as compared to the intact forest. The wood extracted is generally used for thatchi ng and fuel locally and also carried to the alpine meadows during summer. These fragme nts with increasing settlements are in a vulnerable state, as they are prone to furt her degradation. In the absence any regular monitoring the presence of Spruce in the Birch stand and on the mountain slopes could be either looked upon as the tree limit rise or it might be a relict from past vegetation. iii Relict trees and small stands along established routes of herders. The area includes the annual route of the herders which extends from temporary settlements to scrub forest and alpine m eadows. The well-trodd en tracks (38000 to 45000m), are used by the herders to carry thei r herds to the uplands during summers. It mostly presents a barren lands cape and eroded slopes. This is because the campers who accompany their herds to alpine meadows, use Birch and the scrub beyond as fuel, as it is the only satisfactory fuel available at these heights. The tree limit was, as a rule, composed of solitary senescent trees or bur nt stumps with no regeneration. Regeneration World Environment Day June, 2007 51 51 was observed in crevices on steep slopes and probably it is the steepness of the slope that discourages the casual logger from extraction from such sites (Fig. 2). Fig. 2 Burnt stumps of birch with no regeneration and surviving relict of birch in the middle, in the rock crevices on the steep slope on route of the graziers. Photo. A.U.Khan, July 2001. The distance measured between these relict st ands and surviving forest fragments range from one to three km down slope. The bare soil along the routes are heavily trodden and compacted and is no longer suitable for germ ination and establishment of the Birch forest. II Comparative assessment with ‘the tree-line rise scenario’ In order to adopt an optimis tic scenario in the tree-lin e ecotone of Pakistan it is important to appreciate the methodology an d policies practiced by the European countries. The criteria listed in the method section is used here to compare the similarities and dissimilarities between the two situat ions. This appreciation will help us in identifying gaps and developing a rationale for the governance of alpine and subalpine areas of Pakistan. i. Ecological equivalance between the tree limit ecotone of two biogeographical regions.. Organisms that occupy the similar ecolo gical niches in different geographical regions are known as ecologica l equivalents. The tree-line ecosystem of Pakistan and World Environment Day June, 2007 52 52 Europe can be said to be at ecological equivalence. This is because the physical habitat is similar regardless of geographic location, therefore, the spec ies occupy equivalent niches and are closely related taxonomically resulti ng in development of similar ecosystems. The ecosystem similarities in these two geograp hically different locations is mainly due to the fact that elevation of the tree limit d ecreases with increasing latitude. In Pakistan it is located at lower latitude (32- 34N) with tree-line elevation ranging from 3500 m.a.s.l to 4500 m.a.s.l,. In northern Europe with increasin g latitude (55 -71 N) the elevation of the tree limit decreases and ranges from 700 m.a.s.l to 1200 m.a.s.l (Fig. 3). 1200m 3000m 3500m 4000m 4500m Himalayan Tree Line Spruce & Pine Spruce & Birch Birch European Tree Line A lpine Meadows 65° N 34° N Birch Spruce & Birch Spruce & Pine Fig.3. A hypothetical model of the approximate tree line ecotones of two biogeographical regions showing the differences in tree-line elevation (right) with the latitude (left) and similarities in species and forest types. Both in Pakistan and Europe these forests come under the context of sub-alpine forests and alpine scrub. The tree limit ecotone i.e. the transitional belt between the upper closed coniferous forest and tree limit of birch is composed mainly of three tree species. In Europe the Birch is Betula pubescns Ehrh. and Betula utilis D. Don, Prodr. Fl. Nep. in Pakistan, The Spruce is Picea abies (L.) Karst in Europe and Picea smithiana, Boiss Fl. Orient. in Paksitan. The Pine is Pinus sylvestris L. in Europe and Pinus wallichiana A.B. Jackson. in Pakistan. Similarly the mode of reproduction of th e species is similar Spruce and Birch are mainly reproducing vegetatively and by seed regeneration, whereas Pine reproduce by seeds only. World Environment Day June, 2007 53 53 In both ecosystems the recognized climatic climax types formations are Birch- Confier and Birch forests. Birch is the only tree capable of growing to a fair height and is the topmost tree formation. They are crooked a nd branchy, reflecting the severe climatic conditions. This is that limit of forest growth where conifers are unable to withstand the severity of the climate; cold and often dry winds in addition to short growing season and deep snow. ii Anthropogenic utilization of tree-limit ecotone The sub-alpine landscape in Europe has been extensively used by man for several centuries for summer farming, livestock grazing, logging for firewood and as a result the tree limit positions was lowered in the early 19 th century. These activities gradually ceased during the late 19 th century, and presently the only grazing impact is that of herds of semi-domestic reindeer which regularly graze the alpine meadows during spring, summer and autumn and interact with climate to shape current vegetation pattern in the tree limit zone. Although this aspect is little studied in quantative terms but results based on monitoring clearly suggests that for most of the 20 th century tree limit rise has occurred concurrently with growing reindeer herds. The reconnaissance survey in Pakistan clearly indicat es that the surviving undisturbed fragments are only found on inaccessible rocky slopes having evidently been driven out of the more gentle slopes by ex cessive grazing. The present condition is the result of decades of free exploitation of Birch, which is both lopped for fodder and cut for firewood by graziers (Champion, et. al.,1965; Parker, 1951). The growth of Birch is slow and reproduction is usually wanting due to grazing and other cons umptive uses; outer bark is peeled off in large strips and used for umbrellas and roof ing houses, packing and in place of paper. The forest is heavily grazed in summer and is also still being steadily reduced by felling for fuel, regeneration being mostly prevented by the grazing. These activities are acutely threatening the continued existence of Birch and solitary conifers.These trends of disturbance has further probably aggravated climate change initiated stress; driven by earli er snow melt and soil drying. In areas with strong graziers impact severe vegetation stripping and so il erosion have occurred on early snowmelt sites. The frontal expansion of bare sites has rates of several metres per year locally. The survey of the ecotone regi on clearly shows that the graziers are using the fragile ecosystem beyond its carrying capacity. The traditional subsistence graziers are now exporting their products to other regions, which is obvious from the size of the herds and number and quality of construction of the houses in the temporary settlements at the sub-alpine regions. Since the Birch fo rest is not attractive from market point of view and because of inaccessible locations the government is not paying any attention to this fast depleting biologi cal resource. At the moment government agencies, determine land use primarily by the livestock produc tion capacity of the area in question, irrespective of its value to society in a more natural state. Whereas in the European case it seems that the abandonement of intensive utili zation of this fragile ecosystem could be a major factor in the large scale 20 th century advance of tree limits. Otherwise, the general World Environment Day June, 2007 54 54 structure of the tree limit ecot one (tree density, growth forms , ground cover, etc. ) might have followed the pessimistic scenario as being demonstrated in Pakistan . iii Climate change scenario and growth in height of established individuals (phenotypic) and upslope migration of new individuals (genotypic). Climate warming by 0.8 0C between the late 19 th and late 20 th century, has forced multispecies elevational tree-limit advance by more than 100m for the principal tree species in the European mountain ranges. Two principal types of elevaional tree limit change can be distinguished during this period. Phenotypic change, is in situ shifts in height of old established individuals. It is the prevalent mode of change recorded during the past century in the tree-line ecotone. Genotypic change, is the establishment and growth to tree size of newly established genetic individuals at ever higher elevations (Fig. 4). Fig.4 The tree-limit of birch has advanced by 140 m between 1915 and 1975. This is the highest known tree-limit in Sweden. After Kullman, (2001). Birch and Spruce have predominantly responded with phenotypic tree limit changes and have experienced the same magnitudes of elevation tree limit rise. Additionally, the Birches near the tree limit displayed annual shoots with a length th at is three times World Environment Day June, 2007 55 55 greater than the normal value for these sites. The net effect being co ntinual densification of the tree-line ecotones ( Fig. 5). Fig. 5 In the early 20th century, the local tree-limit was marked by this solitary birch (805 m.a.s.l.), growing in an open low alpine landscape. Subsequently, in response to climate warming and earlier snow-melt, re sulting in dense birch stands. After Kullman (2001). Thickening of birch tree populations within the tree limit eotone has imposed a positive feedback loop, by changing surface albedo a nd wind microclimate, the stands have stabilized this ecotone, making it more resilient to subsequent clima tic adversities. There is possibility that the existence of these ne w stands may facilitate further expansion by ameliorating edge effects within the local topography. And there is further possibilities that within the lower reaches of this ne wly evolved Birch woodland Spruce and Pinus may become more prominent, by increased growth of old specimens and establishment of new individuals. Expansion of Pine in the tree-limit eco tone , might be another good omen under the predicted drier climatic regi me as not only it develops faster, but it establishes and endures better on dry and shallow soils than does birch. iv. Regional base line network In Europe the recent tree li mit progression was quantified and analyzed in retrospect by the establishment of a regiona l baseline network comprising more than 200 World Environment Day June, 2007 56 56 tree limit sites. This network, also intende d for future long term monitoring, based on investigation sites es tablished around 1915. The large number of study sites distributed over a hetrogenous region enabled these an alyses to be made along various geo- ecological gradients, e.g. climate, topogr aphy, aspect, slope and human impact which added important details to the interpretation of emerging patterns. III Considerations for converting pessimistic scenario into an optimistic one In Pakistan the degenera tion of the tree limit ecotone is more related to anthropogenic land use changes than to clim ate. Therefore, inte nsive summer grazing in alpine region needs immediate attention as it could potentially prohibit any upward spread of birch. The natural conservation strategy (GOP, 1992) rightly pointed out the dearth of legislation for environmental protection an d resource conservation. The nature conservation policy in such regions should not only be to protect endangered species or economically important species of plants and an imals but also entire habitats of tree-line ecotone under the emerging scenario of climat e change. It should be based on biological aspects of the plants such as population sizes, numbers, and reproductive success and most importantly there is an urgent need fo r integrating agricultural and environmental policies, which appears to be the main reason for the environmental degradation in the fragile tree-line ecotone. European scenario clearly indicates that some of the measures adopted in the early 20 th century are bearing the fruits in the form of tree line advance in the subalpine region in response to climate change. The Pakistan’s scenario clearly shows the deteriorating plight of the tree- line ecosystem even in the protected areas. There is an urgency to set aside dem onstration sites like Naltar and introduce a comprehensive restoration and rehabilitation program. Setting up of permanent plots for detailed monitoring program of tree limit performance will substantially improve the functional understanding of the tree limit eco tone. Subsequently, emphasize should be laid on establishing a network of study site s distributed over th e entire region in collaboration with various other agencies monitoring glacial depletion and geo-ecological gradients in the region (SUPARCO, PARC, Paki stan meteorologist department etc.), for indepth analysis and interpretation of em erging patterns. Implementation of such practices will impose a break or retardation in the progressive tree limit decline reported but not documented for many decades. For the sake of good governance of sub-alpine ecosystems the Government should declare the tree-line ecotones, under the loom ing threat of climate change, as public goods and aims of conservation should in clude the valuation, protection and rehabilitation of natural vege tation of sub-alpine areas . As a matter of fact public value of these tree-limit ecotones s hould be derived from their pr otection function; protection against floods, erosion, lands lides and avalanches. It is an important physical welfare function at these altitudes, a function wh ich can be safe guarded only by natural vegetation. The timely realization of the protective function of this ecosystem in Europe is already being expressed in the form of an emerging band of newly appearing tree growth above the tree-limit (optimistic scenario). Ir onically, factually speaking, World Environment Day June, 2007 57 57 protective function of this ecosystem is more significant to Pakistan as compared to Europe. The reason being that these zones are located at higher altitude and the distance to the valleys is greater and the gradient is steeper, and therefore, erosion, landslides and avalanches, resulting from destabilization of tree-line ecotone, will bring far greater scale of disaster in this region as compared to Europe. Present extens ive utilsation of this fragile ecosystem leading to the disappearance of tree-line species and their seed bank, with no sign of upward migration, indeed, pres ents a pessimistic scen ario, especially, in the context of climate change. Frequent rainstorms will further aggravate soil loss and not only erode the protective capability of this ecosystem but also the productive ecosystem downhill. Retaining a plant cover on such fragile sites, would allow the vegetation to interact with changing environment and could act as a shield against gradual climate change as demonstrated in the European scenario. At the moment there is total lack of interest at local and national level regarding the new value, ‘the buffer against climate change’ of these tree-line ecotones. If these values are valuated they would definitely out-weight any other consumptive value of these biological resources. REFERENCES Ahmad, R. (eds.) (2000). Participatory forest management implication for policy and human resources development in the Hindu Kush Himalayas. Volume VI Pakistan. Bhatia Anupam (ed.), International centre for integrated mountain development in the altitude of the birch Champion, H. G., K. Sethi and G. M. Khattak, (1965). Forest type of Pakistan. Forest Institute, Peshawer. Khan, A.U. (2003). Conservati on of wild natural resources and the need for good governance in Pakistan. Lead-Pakistan 2000. Parker, R.N. (1951). Forest Flora for the Punjab with the Hazara and Delhi. Pakistan Printing Press Lahore. Hofgaard, A. (1999). The role of natural landscape influenced by man in predicting responses to climate change . ecol, bull. 47, 160-167. GOP (Govt. of Pakistan). (1992). The Pakist an National Conservati on strategy. Govt. of Pakistan and IUCN. Karachi Kullman, L. (1979). Change and stability in the altitude of the birch tree limit in the southern Swedish scandes 1915-1975. Acta Phy togeogr. Suecica 65, 1-121 Kullman L. (1981). Some aspects of the ecology of the Scandinavian subalpine birch forest belt. Wahlenbergia 7, 99-112 Kullman, L. (1986). Recent tree limit history of Picea abies in the Sourthern Swedish Scandes. Can. J. forest research . 16, 761-771. Kullman L. (1993). Pine (Pinus sylvestris L. ) tree-limit surveillance during recent decades, central Sweden. Arctic Anp. Tes. 25, 24-31. World Environment Day June, 2007 58 58 Kullman, L. (1998). Tree limits and montane forests in the Swedish scandes : sensitive biomonitors of climate change and variability. Ambio27, 312-32 Kullman, L (2001). 20th century climate warming and tree-limit rise in the southern scandes of Sweden. Ambio,Vol. 30, No. 2, pp. 72-80 Macdonald, G. M. , Szeicz, j. M., Claricoates, J and Dale, K.A. (1998). Response of the central Canadian treeline to recent climatic changes ann. Ass am gepgr. 88, 183-208 Payette, S. and Filion, L. (1985). White Spruce expansion at the tree line and recent climatic change. Can. J. forest Res. 15. 231-251. Young, M. D. (1991). “Overview: the Integration of Agricultural and Environmental Policies ”, In Towards sustainable Agricultural Development. Michael D. Young (ed.). Belhaven Press: London.

Filename: world-Environment-Day-2007Part-2.pdf
File Type: pdf
File Size: 487 KB
Categories: World Environment Day 2007
Author: Several